3 ms·
Does the article say they are sure they died there? If so, I think I missed it. Or maybe some did, and others were taken there? To die? Or were already dead? T
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
Does the article say they are sure they died there? If so, I think I missed it. Or maybe some did, and others were taken there? To die? Or were already dead?
There can't be that many roads / trails thought that area. So if they bottleneck at the point then perhaps the water from time to time goes bad? If some of them "lost it" (mentally) from the water then perhaps that explains the cracked skulls?
- Zenst 7y agoOther aspect is, ice cover would of been greater in the period a few hundred years ago, let alone longer. So has the possibility that these are the remnants of a past glacier melting and depositing these bones - has that been ruled out? As for losing is (mentally) - mad honey was more of an issue back in history than today. So could see how some village feast/celebration/`ritual` may of played out with this given Nepal is noted in history as having issues with it and less than 30km from this site. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grayanotoxin#Mad_honey_intoxication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grayanotoxin#Mad_honey_intoxic...
- dredmorbius 7y agoHauling corpses long distances through high, rugged terrain, only to deposit them randomly around a lake is ... somehow unlikely.
- coldtea 7y agoPeople do far more strange (and difficult) things ritually...
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI'd like to say I agree. But look at all the massive pyramids built throughout the world. Hauling _____ long distances seems somewhat a non-issue.
- dredmorbius 7y agoOther than the largish rockpile at the end, most material for pyramids was moved relatively short distances and largely via water (boats/barges). Probably on rollers on dry land, AFAIU. And gathering up large teams when you're the world's largest^WONLY civilisation, in the most fertile river valley the world has ever known, is somewhat easier than above 4200 metres. It wouldn't have taken much doing to accumulate a few hundred corpses, mind. Though having them walk under their own power would be easier.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoStonehenge. Etc. Regardless of how, BIG things were being moved. Also, and perhaps more importantly, the weight and difficulty of a body is a function of the number of people trying to carry it. One person carrying a single body might be a struggle. But five, ten or twenty people? That wouldn't be a struggle.
- dredmorbius 7y agoRoopkund is at 5,000 meters elevation. 16,470 ft. That's an altitude at which most people have enough difficulty in dragging their own body. Let alone 100s of others. Again: the the premise seems quite weak. The mainstream hypothesis of pilgrims, or very possibly travellers or traders (carrying very light, very valuable goods?) getting caught out in severe weather seems far more probable.