5 ms·
Iain Duncan Smith, former Tory secretary for Work and Pensions in the UK, has just suggested that the retirement age should be increased to 75. Problem is that
by paganel 7y ago
Iain Duncan Smith, former Tory secretary for Work and Pensions in the UK, has just suggested that the retirement age should be increased to 75. Problem is that in places like Glasgow men have a life expectancy of 73, so the majority of them are expected to work till they die. If this isn't class warfare and "survival of the richest" I don't what else is.
- UI_at_80x24 7y agoI assure you, that is by design. What most amazes me is how blatant this is. Late-Stage Capitalism in it's death throes? The last time there was a multi-country, "common-goal of the general people" popular movement like we are experiencing was prior to World War 1 and the movement away from Monarchy to "Constitutional Monarch" on one end of the spectrum and Communism on the other. The overwhelming opinion of: "We don't have to live like this." has a very strong force of momentum to it.
- Mirioron 7y agoBut the problem here isn't capitalism. Politicians certainly want to set low retirement ages and high pensions, but they have to deal with the reality that the government simply cannot afford it. If you over promise then that's going to eventually blow up in your face. Every economic system would have this problem.
- pjc50 7y ago"Cannot afford" is usually a moral decision not an economic one. Nobody managed to stop the Iraq war by saying we "couldn't afford it". Besides, pensioners aren't even in the same category as unemployed people who you can attempt to shame or starve back into the workforce. Setting pension levels is effectively setting a standard of living for pensioners. What are they supposed to do if it's cut below acceptable levels?
- Mirioron 7y ago>"Cannot afford" is usually a moral decision not an economic one. Nobody managed to stop the Iraq war by saying we "couldn't afford it". It is very much an economic one. It simply comes down to stuff. If you have 50 million people in your country then you need 50 million people's worth of food and other goods. If 20 million of them are retired or children then the other 30 million has to produce enough to cover themselves and the 20 million. If the balance gets worse with 30 million not working and 20 million working then you're already in a situation, where society can't really continue down that path. And this balance is getting worse in the developed world. The only way to afford this is by reducing people's quality of life by simply having less stuff for people. This means less healthcare, worse (less) food, less safe equipment, worse entertainment etc. If you don't have enough stuff, then you don't have enough stud. No moral decision is going to change this. >What are they supposed to do if it's cut below acceptable levels? Then it's below acceptable levels. Welfare programs aren't old things. They haven't been around forever. In fact, many would even argue that the way we could afford many welfare programs until now is by borrowing from future generations. Eventually that's going to catch up to us. Some generation is going to be screwed by this.
- pjc50 7y ago> If you don't have enough stuff, then you don't have enough stuff. No moral decision is going to change this. Sure. Then it becomes a question of who gets the stuff. A situation where you import 50 million people's worth of food, let 10 million waste 20 million's worth of it, and let another 10 million go hungry: is that moral or sustainable? Remember this is all being eaten by automation from the other end. If you no longer have enough human-requiring jobs that everyone can have one who is capable of working, what then? Eisenhower: "Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed. This world in arms is not spending money alone. It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children. The cost of one modern heavy bomber is this: a modern brick school in more than 30 cities. It is two electric power plants, each serving a town of 60,000 population. It is two fine, fully equipped hospitals. It is some fifty miles of concrete pavement. We pay for a single fighter with a half-million bushels of wheat. We pay for a single destroyer with new homes that could have housed more than 8,000 people. . . . This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense. Under the cloud of threatening war, it is humanity hanging from a cross of iron."
- roenxi 7y ago> What most amazes me is how blatant this is. Late-Stage Capitalism in it's death throes? Retirement age used to be the point where people were physically unable to work, with justifications being that past 65 workers were completely unable to do anything useful [0]. If jobs have changed enough that a 70 year old can be productive (and they can) this represents a reversion to an anachronistic mean rather than death throes. If you want death throws of capitalism, look to whatever [1, 2] changed in the 1970s that delinked wage growth and productivity; the pressure that forced the US to abandon the gold standard is probably also the pressure responsible for a lot of other ills that are building with time. It isn't a fast process. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_retirement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_retirement [1] https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixon_shock
- saiya-jin 7y agoDepends on the job and the physical and mental state of a given person. For many manual jobs, this is unrealistic. Also, many people experience gradual mental decline and they become semi-unemployable in those ages
- roenxi 7y agoI'm not sure how things are run in the UK, but in Australia the theory goes that issues of physical and mental state would be picked up through the health system case-by-case. I suppose what I'm trying to get at is that the retirement age was never universally seen as a reward. If a 70 year old can work, they should work. On basically the same principle as when I say that a 40 year old who can work, should work. If they can't work then fair enough; 70 is a delicate age and life gets really hard past the early 70s. But it is a reasonable policy to say that the official age is 75 and then find a different way of filtering out people who can't work for health reasons.
- otakucode 7y agoWhat changed was computers. Computers didn't just improve productivity incrementally. It was easy for the management class to deal with giving a worker an 8% annual raise when their productivity grew by 10%. Then computers showed up. And workers using computers were suddenly gaining 80% or 150% productivity (if measured with the same metrics as previously). The management class could not tolerate giving out wage increases that large. The 'work hard, be more productive, and you will make more' mantra was only ever meant to be a means to preserve the status quo. It was not meant to facilitate the large-scale social change that rewarding profound productivity increases with profound wage increases would create. There was a very well-defined concept, held by both the upper class and the middle and lower classes, that it should require 40 hours of sacrifice per week for 40+ years before a person could financially survive retirement. If people could retire at 40 years of age, it would throw everything out of whack. Or at least that was the presumption. All those stories about how automation and technology would enable people to work less have two sides. They're very appealing with workers. They're grim horror stories for those who define themselves by how many people they control and how much value they get those people to produce for a low price.
- lioeters 7y agoI'm not fully convinced if "late-stage capitalism" is a suitable phrase for this historical era we're going through - I suppose we won't know until the next era defines itself. Aside from what to call it, I do agree that wealth and power dynamics have got so blatant and cruel, especially in the US. In the last few decades, the public has witnessed countless abuses and breaches of trust from the "elites", those in government and corporations that rule their world. There's systematic exploitation, "wealth transfer", power grabs, and consolidation of society as a human farm.. OK, gotta stop my rant. We really don't have to live like this, there must be better ways for society to self-organize. As the pressure mounts - it's been building up for a long time, and the ratchet keeps getting tighter - I think it's inevitable that there will be public movements to "take matters into their own hands", since clearly the rulers have lost touch with needs other than their own, long ago.
- avip 7y agoWhen pension funds are not actuarily balanced, there are 3 options: raise the retirement age, reduce monthly payments, or borrow from future generations. It seems most countries go with the obviously wrong, yet politically plausible option 3.
- pjc50 7y agoThe other two are also "obviously wrong", since people paid into the retirement scheme on the assumption of receiving particular benefits at particular times.
- Mirioron 7y agoThere's just not much you can do about it. You could argue that these programs shouldn't have been implemented in the first place, because they weren't going to be sustainable, but those decisions were already made. Somebody's going to get the short end of the stick here.
- pjc50 7y agoRemember that "sustainability" unavoidably depends on long term predictions of the future looking somewhat like the past. The value of my pension depends on economic growth between now and 2050. Hopefully we can continue average 7% equities growth as in the past, but everything from climate change to Brexit will have unpredictable effects on how that turns out.
- jgeada 7y agoExcept that is politically expedient to always under represent the costs to properly finance those future benefits (eg by making rosy expectations of growth, or pessimistic assumptions about expected lifetimes). Those invalid assumptions can remain untested long enough for the relevant senior people and politicians to retire and now it is someone else's problem. The someone else is always the following generation, as they are the one voice without a vote when these decisions are made. So yes, it is always option 3.
- growlist 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- moopling 7y agoAlthough I agree that raising pension age disadvantages the poor, not for that reason. Life expectancy is not the same as age most people live to. If you compare the percentage mortality between the ages 65-75 it's pretty equal (about 1%) both for the UK [1] and Glasgow [2]. Lower life expectancy looks to me due to much greater death rates in the 25-40 range. Raising the pension age hurts the poor, not because the poor won't experience pension, but because they have no hope of an earlier retirement, and so you are forcing people to work when they are potentially unable to effectively do so. [1] https://www.populationpyramid.net/united-kingdom/2019/ https://www.populationpyramid.net/united-kingdom/2019/ [2] https://www.understandingglasgow.com/indicators/population/trends/changing_age_structure https://www.understandingglasgow.com/indicators/population/t...
- chr1 7y agoPeople simultaneously want to have fewer children, to not have many immigrants, and to have high pensions for long time. It is obvious that if there are not enough young people there won't be enough money to pay pensions for the old, the old people who do not want to work until they die should live with their children, and take care for their grandchildren, like people did for millenia and still do in many countries where government interventions didn't break families yet. An additional benefit is that spending time with grandchildren increases the lifespan, and is most likely the main reason why people evolved to stay alive after passing childbearing age.
- mistermann 7y agoSome people want fewer children, some people have decided they cannot afford to have children. Which group is larger is unknown, and I haven't heard of a single country (and few individuals) that has expressed an interest in investigating it. Rather, most people seem intent on denying this situation is even true, despite little if any evidence suggesting that.
- jerrre 7y agoDo you have any good sources on the existance of the latter group? Also that could be seen as a subset of the former, I'd say people wanting fewer children have a combination of reasons for that, possibly including financial.
- mistermann 7y agoOther than plenty of anecdotal stories in personal conversations and on social media, none at all. Considering Western countries are having to jack up immigration rates to make up the shortfall in reproduction, arguably contributing to a noteworthy increase in populism and racism (which does seem to greatly bother politicians and reporters), it seems odd that no one is interested in looking into the actual reasons for low birth rates.
- ivanche 7y agoSomehow I believe that former is much larger, the reason being that poorest countries usually have enormous number of children per family, while richest countries usually struggle to have even 2 per family.
- woah 7y agoIs that 73 number an average? If so, what are you talking about?
- pmiller2 7y agoIn 1939, when the first US Social Security payments were issued, life expectancy was 62.1 for men and 65.4 for women.