20 ms·
I want to say don't feel bad about being dogpiled here. Any time you find an in ordinate amount of reflexive blow back like this it means one thing, you've stru
by Gibbon1 7y ago
I want to say don't feel bad about being dogpiled here. Any time you find an in ordinate amount of reflexive blow back like this it means one thing, you've struck a nerve. That itself is interesting.
I'll make a point about technological complexity. It's not necessarily a uniform good. Financial engineering enabled by computers has allowed the finance industry (spit) to grow threefold in 40 years. That's of course very nice for people in that industry. For instance the finance code monkeys that are angry and downv0ting you have done extremely well.
A point, remove computers and computer machinery and the finance industry from US GDP and growth is zero to negative over those same 40 years. So that complexity has enable a large transfer of wealth from the productive parts of the economy to finance. But the total benefit is negative. And for some sectors massively so.
- pas 7y agoStruck a nerve, or just the Dunning-Kruger effect struck. I'm not a finance code money, never was, not aspiring to be either. The simple fact that these high-end/custom/complex finance products/services are not cheap but people buy them means that it provides value to some rich investment people. (And they usually know what makes them money.) Computers made everything grow since there are computers. Every company uses spreadsheets, uses or subcontracts the use of tax, payroll, healthcare/benefits and accounting software. Email, telephones (modern telephony is completely computerized), and so on (basically everything nowadays depend in its current form on chips and electricity). Finance was simply one of the most well suited aspects of the business world to benefit from computerization. So it grew a lot. But naturally we're nowhere near the "end of automation". Software is eating the world, but quite slowly, because the world is complex - as you said, however modeling it and putting some tracking indexes on it and quoting a price can be done well. (This is what MSCI do for example. Benchmark indexes are very crude but generally useful things - and their purpose is exactly to paper over the complexity of real life, of "real industry" for business analysis purposes.)