9 ms·
Marshal Zhukov's Pocket Knife
- walkingolof 7y ago"an American general at the time expressed the desire that Germans would henceforth be a “nation of shepherds”, incapable of playing a major part in world affairs—yet shortly after the war’s end, it was well on its way to accomplishing the Wirtschaftswunder, the economic miracle that it maintains to this day. Japan arose the ashes in a similar fashion. And the United States…the country that for the entire postwar period served as a source of aspiration for people the world over, a model of domestic stability and good governance, and a guarantor of its allies’ military security, is now riven by toxic political discord and stands at the brink of social collapse."
- baybal2 7y agoThe history might be written by the Victors, but is always read by the survivors
- MichaelMoser123 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgenthau_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgenthau_Plan that wasn't a general: " It was first proposed by United States Secretary of the Treasury Henry Morgenthau Jr."
- mikorym 7y agoI don't agree with that last statement at all. Americans have seen too little hardship to have an idea what "social collapse" and "toxic political discord" is.
- mieseratte 7y agoConsidering my family lived through WWII in the thick of it and later came to America, and this is not a unique occurrence, to say “Americans don’t know” is just wrong.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoI think by "Americans" he means "the upper middle class Nth (N>=4 or so) generation Americans that dominate political discourse the 364 days of the year that aren't election day"
- rawTruthHurts 7y ago'“Americans don’t know” is just wrong.' Not so much. Sounds to me that, if you consider your family american, by your description they sound more like "european immigrants with the paperwork done".
- kmlx 7y ago"is now riven by toxic political discord and stands at the brink of social collapse." lol wut? the USA has seen a incredible rise on so many fronts: quality of life, removal of segregation, rights of gays, right of blacks, rights of women, emergence of computing, emergence of startups, and so, so many more. to say that the US is on the brink of collapse shows the author doesn't really understand the situation, or is simply pushing a narrative.
- walkingolof 7y agoI think you and the quote is both right in some sense...
- cm2187 7y agoIf you have not watched it, the movie The Death of Stalin is great, mostly historically accurate, though not in the depiction of the characters, and extremely funny. Zhukov is represented as a hilarious bully who intimidates the whole politburo.
- varjag 7y agoLater Zhukov was on his track to become a dictator in 1957, flaunting his personal command over Soviet military on multiple occasions. It took a combined pushback of (otherwise feuding) Soviet elites to bring him in check.
- cm2187 7y agoI am not praising Zhukov himself. The way he spent men to win Stalingrad is another questionable aspect of the character.
- wtdata 7y agoStalingrad was the decisive turn of fate during WWII, if the allies had lost it, the Axis would probably take over the all of Europe. Sure, a lot of men were sacrificed, but this was total war, those sacrifices saved tens of millions. We live with this slight propaganda that the USA was the responsible to liberate Europe, but in fact, USA showed up here at the end of the war when the Russians had already inflicted a major defeat on the German army, and it was the sacrifice of Russian men at Stalingrad (together with any material help the British could afford to spare to that front), that ultimately won the war for the Allies, not D-day.
- mieseratte 7y agoThe Allies weren’t exactly sitting on their hands. Just taking the strategy of picking off North Africa and Southern Europe before hitting Western / Central. Trying to reduce the war down to any one side is, IMHO, wrong and suspect.
- croh 7y agoI only noticed wine opener
- benj111 7y agoI noticed the same. I wonder when the pen knife changed from being a simple folding blade to the multitooled wonder we have today? Also does it say something about generals and the military that the two missing/broken tools are the scissors and tooth pick? Edit: Apparently they have a longer history than I would have thought "The Swiss Army Knife was not the first multi-use pocket knife. In 1851 in "Moby Dick" (chapter 107), Melville references the "Sheffield contrivances, assuming the exterior - though a little swelled - of a common pocket knife; but containing, not only blades of various sizes, but also screw-drivers, cork-screws, tweezers, awls, pens, rulers, nail-filers, countersinkers."" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_Army_knife https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_Army_knife
- jhellan 7y agoHow about this one from ancient Rome? https://www.fitzmuseum.cam.ac.uk/collections/greeceandrome/70534 https://www.fitzmuseum.cam.ac.uk/collections/greeceandrome/7...
- aries1980 7y agoThe tulip motives on the knife makes me wonder if it was actually Roman and not from the Middle East.
- Steve44 7y agoThe Roman Empire covered a huge area, including some of the Middle East and North Africa so it’s highly likely that people, objects, and ideas all moved around. They could well have taken inspiration from something seen at one of the outposts.
- aasasd 7y ago> Also does it say something about generals and the military that the two missing/broken tools are the scissors and tooth pick? The toothpick gets lost in the first months with these knives. Anyway, a bit weird to pick your teeth with the same stick for years. The scissors might actually be the most useful thing on the knife, or at least on a par with the blades, depending on the owner. Scissors aren't used just for cutting when you aren't hauling around a toolbox. But they have a moving part with a rather feeble connection.
- cm2187 7y agoBy the way the legend of the picture in the middle of “Four Commanders of the Allied Forces in Berlin” says that the 4th general is de Gaulle but it is clearly not. I think it is de Lattre.
- inflatableDodo 7y ago>As we know, there was no invasion of the Japanese home islands—not by the Soviets, nor the Americans, nor the British. Fearing massive loss of life both among Allied forces and the Japanese civilian population, President Truman ordered nuclear bombs dropped on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. These bombings quickly brought the war to a close. According to other narratives by historians, the main cause of the Japanese surrender was the Russians entering the Pacific war. https://www.history.co.uk/shows/x-company/articles/why-did-japan-really-surrender-in-ww2 https://www.history.co.uk/shows/x-company/articles/why-did-j... https://apjjf.org/-tsuyoshi-hasegawa/2501/article.html https://apjjf.org/-tsuyoshi-hasegawa/2501/article.html Is worth remembering that not everyone buys into the idea that nukes are ultimate weapons that definitively ended the second world war. There are actually a variety of views on the subject, which from a game theory perspective creates dangerous instabilities within the doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- trhway 7y ago>>These bombings quickly brought the war to a close. >According to other narratives by historians, the main cause of the Japanese surrender was the Russians entering the Pacific war. Both - USSR entering the war and the nuclear bombs caused the Japanese surrender. It would have happened soon even without the bombs anyway. The main role the bombs played is to avoid USSR actually invading Japan territory. Ultimately that saved Japan from the Korea and Germany fate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Japanese_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Japanese_War "The invasion of the second largest Japanese island of Hokkaido, originally planned by the Soviets to be part of the territory taken,[18] was held off due to apprehension of the US' new position as an atomic power."
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>"The invasion of the second largest Japanese island of Hokkaido, originally planned by the Soviets to be part of the territory taken,[18] was held off due to apprehension of the US' new position as an atomic power." I checked the citations for that part of the article and they do not back up that claim. They are talking about what territory the USSR will get and which surrendering troops will become Soviet POWs. There is no discussion of "well, we better hold off because the 'mericans are just gonna glass 'em all for us". Furthermore, the Americans had a shovel ready invasion plan with a start date in November. The soviets didn't have a real plan yet. It's not like they called off an invasion because we started lobbing nukes. Anyone who says that showing the USSR what we were capable of was more than just a side benefit understand the Pacific campaign. If we didn't nuke them we were going to firebomb them. It was basically common knowledge that these people were dedicated enough to follow their cause to the death. What was learned on Iwo Jima and confirmed on Okinawa was that they were going to make us fight for every inch. In lieu of that it's hard to justify not using every available means to kill them dead enough that they surrender without invasion or soften them up prior to invasion. Imagine the scandal has Truman just decided "this whole atom bomb thing is barbaric, we're going to invade them and/or let the soviets burn half a million lives invading them".
- coconut_crab 7y agoI didn't know that the Soviet made pocket knives,they look quite similar to swiss army knives! This part really struck me hard because my tools are all mint, despite being bought years ago: > For me, the knife’s most compelling quality is that it clearly saw hard use, most probably by Zhukov himself: some of the blades are stained; a slot that once contained a toothpick is empty; and a couple of tools appear to be broken off, including what was once a small pair of scissors.
- huhtenberg 7y agoI strongly suspect this is a one-off hand-made knife. This is certainly not a mass-produced item.
- aasasd 7y ago> certainly not a mass-produced item With a stock set of tools that is almost the same today on every multitool knife, including a toothpick which a marshal of course needs direly on a knife. And with handle finish that was ubiquitously used on kitchen utensils. (A fork is a rarity today, though.)
- ivanhoe 7y agoFirst Swiss army knifes were produced in the late 19th century, and the idea of combined blades and tools existed long before. Folding pocket knives were in wide use everywhere, so surely Russians manufactured and used them even before USSR.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dimitar 7y agoZhukov is actually very controversial nowadays. A lot of the early historians accepted his autobiography as a the main source pretty uncritically. There is another historical view of Zhukov: - He wasn't the military genius he portrayed himself to be and actually stole the credit for the achievements of other officers. For example he supposedly saved Stalingrad yet was nowhere near it, he came to Halkin Gol when the battle was beginning and didn't credit the staff chief for the excellent planning and so forth. - He was a Stalin yes-man, and in stark contrast to his autobiography, there is no proof he ever challenged him on any decision. This is what Stalin liked, he needed talented commanders, but also people who will follow his orders to the letter. - His handling of the Red Army in the summer of 1941 while he was Chief of Staff, was absolutely disastrous. He lost millions of men in ill planned counter attacks. Stalin kept him around because he followed orders (see above). - Besides being a yes-man, by all unofficial accounts he was a brute and enjoyed humiliating his soldiers and officers. He was often in fights even with other marshals. - He didn't care much about his soldiers lives, this is why Stalin sent him to capture Berlin as soon as possible. - He wasn't demoted because of paranoia (he probably wouldn't be alive). He was actually demoted because he allowed his troops to pillage Eastern Germany for months, and took a huge share of the booty. Not that Stalin was particularly humanitarian, but this meant that discipline had become nonexistent. - Far from being apolitical and not involved in intrigue, he actually participated in a coup against Malenkov and Beria. He almost became the leader of the Soviet Union, however was cleverly outmaneuvered by Khrushchev who put him in retirement. - His mythos began during the time of Brezhnev, when he needed to rewrite the history of WWII to suit his ends. His autobiography was certainly not written by him, as are its subsequent 15 editions which hilariously contradict each other often. His daughter supposedly finds forgotten pages that just happen to complement the evolving views of Kremlin for over 40 years.
- fmajid 7y agoEven if true, by killing Beria, he probably saved more Soviet citizens from a horrible death than those killed by Hitler.
- arethuza 7y agoBeria actually wanted to liberalize the Soviet system - he reduced the power of the MVD and released a lot of people from the Gulag. Mind you, at a personal level, he was an asbsolute monster - but I don't think if he had stayed in power there would have been any more mass purges. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavrentiy_Beria#First_Deputy_Premier_and_Soviet_triumvir https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lavrentiy_Beria#First_Deputy_P...
- coffeemug 7y agoBrodsky's poem On the Death of Zhukov brilliantly reflects his controversial life. The english translation isn't very good, but it carries some of the flavor-- https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9780230373396_3 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9780230373396_3
- SiempreViernes 7y agoDissapointing that this text about a historical figure should end with the trope about the bomb ending the war before anyone invaded, when the historical consensus is that the best that can be said is that the bomb and the soviet entering the japanese theatre by invading manchuria had about equal importance. http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/03/08/the-decision-to-use-the-bomb-a-consensus-view/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/03/08/the-decision-to-us...
- slim 7y ago> As we know, there was no invasion of the Japanese home islands—not by the Soviets, nor the Americans, nor the British. Fearing massive loss of life both among Allied forces and the Japanese civilian population, President Truman ordered nuclear bombs dropped on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. These bombings quickly brought the war to a close. Why do American scholars have to justify the bombings each time? "President Truman ordered nuclear bombs dropped on the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki." would have been sufficient. It feels like newspeak in 1984.
- jackfoxy 7y agoNot the authors only gratuitous editorializing > the United States… is now riven by toxic political discord and stands at the brink of social collapse both cases unnecessary, off-topic, and detract from an otherwise good article
- fossuser 7y agoIt's not clear that it's even true: https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1159799358650499072?s=20 https://twitter.com/wellerstein/status/1159799358650499072?s...
- jjtheblunt 7y agoMy guess is that American scholars are annoyed at the reality that it happened, in contrast to imagined alternatives, like a "demo" off the shore of a city, or over the Japanese fleet somewhere.
- gwbas1c 7y agoWell hindsight is 20-20, and anyone commenting on the bombs has the luxury of decades of historical analysis of the war. My understanding is that the nuclear bombs were approximately as destructive as the fire-bombing technique. (Commonly used in the war) If we fire bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki, just as many lives would be lost but we would never talk about it. The difference is that fire bombing required many more planes and many more bombs, thus increasing American military risk. Enemy civilian casualties would be similar.
- 7y ago
- html5web 7y agoI used to have one of these knives :)