5 ms·
An extremely easy way for a bunch of people to get together and destroy someone's ranking? That doesn't sound like such a good idea.
by eli 16y ago
An extremely easy way for a bunch of people to get together and destroy someone's ranking? That doesn't sound like such a good idea.
- jobu 16y agoPerhaps, but I'm sure any legitimate site could contact Google and resolve the issue...
- csomar 16y agoGiven that Google gets hundred of millions of search and visitors, then you'll need a hundred of thousands of down votes to get black-listed. No black hatter can really do that (create a 100K account/IP to avoid Google radar and down vote the website).
- tomjen3 16y agoMost botnets would easily have more than that number of computers. So yeah it can be done.
- moe 16y agoIt would also be a significant undertaking if the down-votes are tied to google accounts. Not only do you have to bypass the captcha, but also the heuristics that google could (does?) employ to detect fake accounts. If the votes were weighted by account activity then the spammers would not only have to sign up and vote; they would also have to keep all these accounts busy with fake queries or other means.
- jawn 16y agoGmail accounts and capcha solving services are cheap compared to the profits you could make off of getting your site ranked #1 for a profitable search keyword.
- moe 16y agoNot necessarily when you factor in that you may need tens of thousands of accounts to suppress one popular site. - And in a profitable niche you're likely competing with multiple sites. Keeping all those accounts active, cycling out dead accounts etc. could take quite an ongoing infrastructure investment. Moreover google could give significantly more weight to accounts that look very real (i.e. actively using multiple google products for a long time) and thereby further devalue the botnet impact. It's yet another arms race of course. But one with fairly good odds I would think.
- tomjen3 16y agoNot really, you just have to steal the account of the person who owns the computer. If you have a botnet, you shouldn't have much trouble doing that.
- eneveu 16y agoExactly. Google accounts have so many uses (gmail, youtube, google code, google docs, picasa...), it would be easy to detect how "active" / "real" an account is. Of course, anything can be gamed... But it's better than nothing. If I were to create a web-app with user-generated content, I would try to create a "trust" system based on a "reputation" / "real person" metric. It may come from his StackOverflow / reddit / HN reputation, his Google Account activity, Facebook activity... Before buying a product based on a review I read on a forum, I always look at the author's post count / history / reputation. That's why I like HN / Reddit and their Karma systems. We need to automate that
- bromley 16y agoHundreds of millions of searches and visitors in aggregate: yes. Hundreds of millions of searches and visitors in any one keyword niche: not so often. Many websites live off a handful of visitors a day coming from a few core keywords and associated long-tail traffic. For a keyword that only gets 100 searches a day, it wouldn't take many down-votes to affect the rankings of the relevant sites.
- moe 16y agoFor a keyword that only gets 100 searches a day, it wouldn't take many down-votes to affect the rankings of the relevant sites. Why do you assume a flawed implementation? Naturally there would be thresholds. There is no reason to devalue a site that's only displayed in 100 search-results/day at all. The sites we want to hit are orders of magnitude worse at polluting the results. We're talking about the Mahalo's and expert sexchanges.
- bromley 16y agoGoogle seems to like building systems that automatically scale across all keywords and niches. For example, for a low competition keyword, 1 link can make a big difference to a site's rankings. For a high-competition keyword it takes many many more links to change anything. It's the same algorithm affecting the rankings in both cases, just in the latter case there's a lot more data being used as input. That's the way they seem to do things, so I'm guessing there's a fair chance they'd take a similar approach to the influence of down-votes on rankings, if they went down that road. There'd have to have some sorts of thresholds, but there'll always be points above which the algorithm can be gamed, just like pretty much every other aspect of their ranking algorithm can be gamed. Right now, in a low-volume-keyword niche, a sleazy operator can kill the rankings of competing sites pretty easily by buying them a few dirty links and letting Google's algorithm do the rest. If a site hasn't got lots of quality links pointing to it, and let's face it, the vast majority of sites don't, it's pretty easy for someone to kill its rankings. A lot of people say that it's impossible to affect the rankings of someone else's site, but that's simply not true. You can't easily affect the rankings of a big established site with lots of good links, but a little small-business site? The reality is it's pretty easy. I don't think Google have any interest in quashing that particular myth, because the reality is actually kind of scary for small business operating on the web. (Apologies if I'm going off on a tangent there. You are absolutely right in pointing out that I was assuming a flawed implementation.)
- aubergene 16y agoSounds like a perfect challenge for 4chan
- robryan 16y agoIf this wasn't at all preventable the idea of adwords would never work, people would just be running up competitors costs.
- eli 16y agoI don't know how many people get away with it, but that sort of thing definitely happens. Google claims they filter all the bogus clicks out and you aren't charged for them, but you kinda have to take their word for it since there's virtually no way to verify.
- al_james 16y agoTrue, but as it stands, someone's ranking can be destroyed by not playing the black hat SEO game when your competitors are and allowing their crappy spam filled site to outrank you. Swings and roundabouts.
- docgnome 16y ago4chan would go bananas.