8 ms·
G.E. Is Accused of $38B Fraud
- purephase 7y agoFuck. This is not good in either situation. If it's market manipulation, then shorters will be out in force. If not, then an org the size of GE will be a catalyst.
- tru3_power 7y agoCan you explain why more shorters means share prices drop? Is it all perception or am I missing something? Sorry n00b here.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoShare prices usually drop if there's a ton of short demand, because to short a stock -- you literally borrow a stock and then sell it. The idea is, you'll buy it back later (hopefully at a lower price) and return it to who you borrowed it from (hopefully for a profit).
- Areading314 7y agoIt doesn't matter who is shorting etc It matters if people are looking to sell the stock. Existing owners can also plummet a stock by selling even if there are no shorts.
- vageli 7y agoShorters _are_ people looking to sell the stock at the current asking price with the hope that they can buy the underlying equity at a discount in the future. Your statements are literally at odds with one another.
- Areading314 7y agono they're not. I said that existing holders and shorts can both cause a dip. It doesn't matter if its shorts or longs doing the selling.
- vageli 7y agoI took > It doesn't matter who is shorting etc to mean that short activity had no consequence.
- wyxuan 7y agoYou have the definition of shorting right, but it doesn't mean that shorts cause a stock to drop. Beyond meat has had a crazy amount of people shorting it, but that hasn't stopped it's 800% rise
- arcticbull 7y agoShort selling does directly cause the stock price to move down due to increased selling pressure. What you're seeing with BYND is not directly because of the act of short-selling, but the knock-on consequences and market dynamics. In part that has to do with the fact that BYND has very few of the total shares floated, all available shares were shorted (around 50% of float), and what little organic retail demand for their shares existed was enough to move the price materially. Eventually the market cap crossed the threshold for inclusion in the Russel 2000 index, forcing ETFs tracking the Russel to buy BYND shares too. This all caused the short-sellers to get liquidated, forcing them to buy at whatever price was available. This in turn liquidated more shorts. And so on. That was a textbook short squeeze. IMO the reason it didn't go all the way up to the moon is that brokerages were charging 140% APR to short the shares, so we were seeing consistent turnover in the short positions. The answer to "Who would buy BYND shares for $250" is "the trader and/or index fund who has no choice." It's worth more than 25% of the companies in the S&P 500, but only has $87M in revenues and 200 employees in a warehouse in LA with a handful of pea patties.
- wyxuan 7y agoShare prices don't drop because of shorts. Tesla had a ton of people shorting them but it still didn't drop immediately in the short term. So does beyond meat. That doesn't change how beyond still surged 800% post ipo
- arcticbull 7y agoShort-selling does cause the price of a stock to drop because the process of a short-sale is this: (1) You borrow shares from your broker, and agree to return the same number of shares at some point in the future without regard for what they'll be worth then. (2) You then immediately sell those shares on the market. Increased selling does cause downward pressure on shares as a result, in the same way that increased buying pressure pushes shares up. (3) Eventually, you re-purchase shares for what is ideally a lower price and return them to the brokerage. Your profit (or loss) is the difference in price between when you short-sold and when you re-purchased, minus the fees your brokerage charged you to borrow the shares. Where it gets a little messy is if the stock price goes up, you run out of margin, and your brokerage forces you to purchase shares to cover your position. Then you're buying them at whatever price you can get them. This in turn moves the stock further up -- far enough, and it may cause other short-sellers to get liquidated too, and so on. The stock may go parabolic like BYND and TLRY. This is called a short squeeze.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 6thaccount2 7y agoYea this is getting a lot of headlines. The fact that they put up a gefraud.com and they call them "GEnron" is interesting.
- newsbinator 7y ago> The company’s shares plummeted on the news, falling by 8 percent to a seven-month low. Mr. Culp [CEO of GE] responded by buying $2 million of G.E. stock.
- lawrenceyan 7y agoIf you think G.E. is bad, I encourage you to take a deeper look at Ford and gasp in shock and awe. The 2008 financial crisis didn’t treat either of these two companies well, but I’d much rather deal with G.E.’s finances than have to take on the mess that Ford is. Ford really should have declared bankruptcy like General Motors did then in the preceding crisis, and it was only through a miracle of financial engineering that they somehow managed to avoid it. To this day, you can still see the incredible burden it carries on the company.
- Maakuth 7y agoNot sure if you intentionally mentioned both, but it's worth noting that G.E. is General Electric, not General Motors.
- lawrenceyan 7y agoYes, that was intentional. General Motors, the counter part to Ford as a car company, declared bankruptcy in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. The financial practices that led to General Motors having to declare bankruptcy were largely the same at Ford. Ford didn’t go bankrupt then, but they basically had to figuratively sell their soul in order to avoid doing so.
- AmVess 7y agoFord got rid of Volvo, Aston Martin, Jaguar, and Land Rover. All of these brands have been doing poorly since Ford sold them. Ford's relentless pursuit of cost cutting led them to keep many vehicles for far too long. Their former bread-and-butter model, the Ford Explorer, went 9 years in between platform changes. The ford Flex has been on the same platform for 11 years. The Ford Focus went 8 years without a change of platform. Further, their cost-cutting initiatives have earned many of their vehicles poor reliability marks to such an extent that Ford Focus sales are less than half of what they were in just 4 short years. I might add that Ford went upscale in price on a lot of its vehicles without an attendant increase in upscale features. The Ford Explorer sells about half of what it used to during its peak. Selling off car companies was a good idea. However, poor products, poor product planning, poor reliability, and a spineless vision of the future has put them into a bad spot with no real light on the very distant horizon.
- _rpd 7y ago> stems from understated liabilities in its insurance business, misrepresentation of its cash situation, and improper accounting for its acquisition of a stake in the oil field services provider Baker Hughes. So it stems from a dispute between the opinions of "fraud hunter" Harry Markopolos and the professionals employed by GE. This seems to be a "Everything Everywhere Is Securities Fraud" situation. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everything-everywhere-is-securities-fraud https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everyt...
- kyrra 7y agoOne point that WSJ that NYTimes calls out too is that Markopolos is working with a hedge fund in releasing this report (that I believe is shorting GE stock). He's doing this so he can get paid up-front and not have to wait for potential whistle-blower payout (which takes years). While this doesn't mean his accusations are fake, but it's important to take these into account when evaluating the claims. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4286597-markopolos-short-report-ge-full-inaccuracies https://seekingalpha.com/article/4286597-markopolos-short-re...
- panarky 7y agoJust because Markopolos will profit from his work doesn't mean his work is bogus. In fact, if his work proves to be bogus, he most likely won't profit, and his reputation will be damaged forever. When GE people go on CNBC and make all kinds of carefully lawyered statements that sound like denials but aren't actually categorical denials, they're also getting paid. The GE people get paid whether or not their statements hold up over time. Given that, I'd put more weight on Markopolos because he actually has skin in the game.
- S_A_P 7y agoWell put. My knee jerk reaction is to frame Markopolos as the villain here but he does stand to lose much more if he is wrong. That said it is a dangerous game to be playing that can/will have ripple effects on all the folks working at GE that aren’t complicit in the fraud.
- Traster 7y agoThe hedge fund shorting GE will profit from the value of GE dropping due to the bad news, it will profit from the value of GE dropping if there's an investigation, and it will profit if the accusations turn out to be true. There's no reason to think Markopolos won't profit if the accusations are bogus, because he profits from the market reaction, not from the actual merits of the accusations. In fact, his experience in the past tells him that even if his accusations are true, they're unlikely to result in successful investigations, and if his accusations are untrue, he's unlikely to face consequences for it. Also, whilst the people who go on CNBC to defend GE are paid to go on, they're paid a fixed salary, they generally aren't particularly incentivized to boost the stock price.
- majestik 7y agoTitle should be adjusted to end with “by activist short sellers”
- snek 7y agoWell that is the point of activist short sellers; not too different from security researchers having a monetary incentive with bug bounty programs.
- ChrisLomont 7y agoShort sellers lose money if they’re wrong.
- blairanderson 7y agoDear u/airstrike you posted two different GE fraud articles within minutes of each other. Please tell us how you’re connected to the situation.
- rdtwo 7y agoDuring the last financial crisis GE nearly imploded because GE financial was a hotbed of fraud , poor accounting and risk management. It’s not inconceivable that the same practices came back during the last boom years and and are only coming up now because someone looked. The thing is it might be a good buy because it probably won’t blow up nearly as fast as people think
- dang 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20705449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20705449
- martin1975 7y agoIt'd be nice if unaccredited investors could invest in this undisclosed hedge fund :).. I for one believe Markopolos.
- dehrmann 7y agoIf you have a margin account, you can always short GE, but if GE's claim is right, the damage has been done. Let's also start with which hedge fund it might be.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoAnyone have any insight into what he's doing as a business model? Basically having a fund, investigating companies (as you would have to do anyways to vet a potentially large investment) and then if you find malfeasance, corruption, etc. shorting the stock and exposing it publicly. You could probably pair it up with a management consultancy or something that could swoop in and charge a fee to clear out the corruption and get things running back on track if you wanted to go long on the stock too. I realize this may be somewhat like what activist investors do but I'm thinking more focused on corruption fully rather than just underperforming companies. Something like what Bill Browder did in Russia back in the day (and if you haven't read his book Red Notice, it's an incredible read, has helped lead to Magnitsky Acts around the world, but I won't spoil it)
- tdhoot 7y agoThe term for this is "activist short seller". It's pretty common. Citron Research, Bonitas, and Spruce Point are some of the firms I've heard of that follow this business model, but there are tonnes of them.
- whenanother 7y agois this another pension scam a la toys r us and usps?