4 ms·
General Electric: A Bigger Fraud Than Enron
- Eiriksmal 7y agoI clicked the link to download the report. The disclosure you have to agree to is very interesting: >Prior to the initial distribution of this Report on August 15, 2019, the Company entered into an agreement with a third-party entity to review an advanced copy of the Report in exchange for later-provided compensation. That compensation is based on a percentage of the profits resulting from the third-party entity’s positions in the securities, derivatives, and other financial instruments of, and/or relating to, General Electric Company (“GE”) (NYSE: GE). Those positions taken by the third-party entity are designed to generate profits should the price of GE securities decrease. So there exists a class of professional services designed to temporarily crash stock prices to make short sellers money? Curious.
- jdc 7y agoThe existence of said arrangements may be of some interest to the SEC as well.
- woah 7y agoObviously they’re not very worried about that since they made the above public disclosure
- stephenSinniah 7y agoSo from my understanding of what happened this investigation was initially self funded with the aim of getting paid through the SEC whistleblower program, not sure how the hedge fund got involved though. You can watch the interview with the accountant here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jE10T250bo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jE10T250bo
- tlb 7y agoThat's the most cynical way to look at it. Another way is, a guy discovered a huge fraud and planned to make it public. A hedge fund offered to pay him a pile of money for advance information about it.
- jgalt212 7y agosounds like they paid to acquire "material non-public information".
- yasp 7y agoThe information that formed the basis of the report was public.
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoThe information that formed the basis of the report was buried.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoIt sounds like perhaps you aren't familiar with the meaning of "material non-public information". I've found a lot of stuff by Matt Levine on the topic interesting. Ex: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-10-15/insider-trading-isn-t-so-simple https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-10-15/inside...
- prepend 7y agoIt’s only insider trading if the company is improperly using information to trade. 3rd parties can discover and trade on non-public information as long as they aren’t breaking other laws (ie, stealing information, bribing, etc).
- otterley 7y agoThe law is far more complex than you suggest, and I would strongly caution anyone in possession of material non-public information to consult a securities lawyer before proceeding to trade securities based on such information. See, e.g., https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2017/01/18/insider-trading-law-after-salman/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2017/01/18/insider-trading-l...
- 7y ago
- jonahbenton 7y agoThe causal relationship you are describing should not be inferred by that language. Note the "prior to the initial distribution." The work was already done.
- rolltiide 7y agoIs it interesting? Thats what you are supposed to do. When you don't have hedge funds on speed dial you have to try to take the risk with your own money yourself. Wow congratulations you got a 20% gain on the $1,000 to your name. When you make a big row about it, you protect yourself from having these disclaimers. It protects you from private litigation from people that copy your "not-advice", and it protects you from the SEC who will simply say you didn't disclose it. The SEC is funny because they will write a line by line statement of how bad you are and how you did all these insidious things, and you ask them what you were supposed to do, and they'll say "oh, just write a three sentence disclaimer next time and those exact same actions are state sanctioned"
- MaupitiBlue 7y agoThere are services designed to figure things out before the general public. Because companies tend not to keep good news secret, what’s left to figure out is typically bad news.
- jdietrich 7y ago>So there exists a class of professional services designed to temporarily crash stock prices to make short sellers money? Yes. The technical term is "activist short selling". The broad consensus is that it's good for the market, as it provides an incentive for investors and researchers to uncover fraud and mismanagement. Obviously someone could just make up a bunch of nonsense about a company to try and tank their share price, but that's all sorts of illegal. I think it's valid to think of activist short selling as a kind of distributed bug bounty program for the financial markets.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> but that's all sorts of illegal There's a subset of people who find this aspect appealing.
- unreal37 7y agoI recently read that, to be a successful large-scale short seller, you have to be an activist. You can't just sell a stock and wait passively for it to eventually go down. You HAVE to be out on CNBC and elsewhere trying to actively prove that the company is overvalued. Look at the way Bill Ackman and Pershing Square Ventures went after Herbalife for years. Not (just) because they thought a fraud was going on. But they were trying to make billions of dollars for themselves too. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/28/business/dealbook/ackman-herbalife-pershing-square.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/28/business/dealbook/ackman-... Ackman spent 5 years on the road doing roadshows, on TV, trying to make the case for fraud.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Mengkudulangsat 7y agoMuddy Waters pioneered this concept I believe. The reason they need to partner with hedge funds is because building a compelling enough case requires expensive on-the-ground detective work. Their work on Olam is my favorite. [1] https://www.muddywatersresearch.com/ https://www.muddywatersresearch.com/
- qwhelan 7y agoThey're on the young side for the business and definitely didn't pioneer the concept. Also, Muddy Waters (Capital) is a hedge fund at this point.
- foldingmoney 7y ago>So there exists a class of professional services designed to temporarily crash stock prices to make short sellers money? Curious. There exists a class of professional services designed to uncover financial fraud. That's what this is (allegedly) an example of. Investors can make money by correctly betting that a stock price will go down, hence they might be interested in funding research that uncovers financial fraud. The key point is that the stock price goes down _because of the fraud_ that was exposed -- not because someone _accused_ GE of fraud. If someone put out a false report accusing a company of fraud with the hope of causing a temporary price drop, that would be illegal. They would be fined / go to jail and would be barred from working in the financial industry again. For the record, I think Markopolis's analysis is wrong. Whether it was done in good or bad faith is another matter.
- chkaloon 7y agoPeople have said GE's numbers have been suspect since at least Jack Welch's days of year after year profit growth. But this looks kind of weasely.
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoThe fact that the CEO of GE bought $3MM of shares after this report first came out makes me suspect it is, at the least, overblown.
- kristopolous 7y agoMany of Enron people also believed in their own malarkey. Systemic fraud usually doesn't have a foundation of calculating rational actors but instead irrational exuberance and magical thinking; as if economic fundamentals need not apply. Look at the dotcom bubble, bitcoin bubble, or the housing crash. The biggest offenders were also the biggest devotees to the dream. I say this being a shareholder in GE. I honestly hope I'm wrong and things turn around but insiders doubling down in hope of a brighter tomorrow is a poor investment indicator signal. It doesn't mean much.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoIsn’t $3mm pocket change for these guys? It doesn’t necessarily signal confidence to me.
- m0zg 7y agoSeven figures isn't pocket change for anybody. Unless they're doing this with someone else's money, that seems like a pretty good signal to me.
- uptown 7y agoHere are the details of his compensation agreement: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/05/new-ge-ceo-larry-culp-inks-stock-heavy-contract-worth-up-to-300-million-if-shares-soar.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/05/new-ge-ceo-larry-culp-inks-s... It's very much in his interest to stabilize the stock price.
- m0zg 7y agoIt's even more of a signal then. If these insinuations were true, there'd be no point whatsoever to spend $5M to buy shares of the company which he knows is insolvent. It's not like if this is true his share purchase would buoy all of GE.
- post_below 7y agoMore info: https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/ge-plunges-after-whistleblower-calls-it-a-bigger-fraud-than-enron/ar-AAFQjYf https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/ge-plunges-after-w...
- sho 7y agoDirect link to the report: https://fm.cnbc.com/applications/cnbc.com/resources/editorialfiles/2019/8/15/2019_08_15_GE_Whistleblower_Report.pdf https://fm.cnbc.com/applications/cnbc.com/resources/editoria...
- ma2rten 7y agoPrevious Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20705449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20705449
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoIt's only fraud if all the people who bought long term care insurance actually live a long time. Maybe GE (a major defense contractor) has reason to believe a lot of people are going to die soon.
- loganfrederick 7y agoAnother famous short seller, Citron, issued their counterargument to this report: https://citronresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Citron-Issues-Comment-on-General-Electric-and-Markopolos-Report.pdf https://citronresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/Citron...
- cairo_x 7y agoedit: turns out this rebuttal was by Andrew Left, a serial activist short seller himself, who was banned from trading in Hong Kong for falsifying reports on his website. LOL. Citron says the report didn't "pass the smell test". It's quite a lengthy report. One could simply read it and make a point by point rebuttal. But they don't do that at all. They say: > The credibility of Mr. Markopolos has to be questioned immediately when he was asked on CNBC and other media why he chose GE now. To this he responded: “They moved their headquarters to Boston last year. My hometown. I don’t appreciate when you’re running a scam in my hometown.” They then go on to frame this as a giant 'AHAH! Gotcha.' Instead of rebutting the actual report. They then go on to claim that "Aggressive accounting" is not fraud. LOL. I nearly fell out of my fucking chair when I read that one. HOW DARE YOU, SIR. IT'S NOT FRAUD. IT'S AGGRESSIVE ACCOUNTING. wut's aggressive accounting? Aggressive accounting refers to an accounting department's deliberate and purposeful tampering with its company's financials in order to outwardly characterize its revenues as higher than they truly are. So fraud? [HOW DAAAARE YOU!] "Aggressive accounting" .... "has helped fuel a growing economy" [AND EVERYONE DOES IT SO THERE!] (actual quote in quotation marks) In summary, their arguments are. - Aggressive accounting is not fraud (it is) - Activist short selling is the real culprit (This is like blaming bug bounties for bugs in code. Even more confusing is that THIS IS LITERALLY WHAT CITRON'S BUSINESS MODEL IS. WTF!?) - The author has a big head and we don't like him (so therefore made the whole thing up??? Or Something?) - The CEO bought 3 million in stocks as a demonstration of his belief in GE, therefore NOTHING TO SEE HERE, WOW. 3 MILLION. MUCH CONFIDENCE! Citron's arguments wouldn't be out of place in The Onion.
- b_tterc_p 7y agoQuestionable revenue recognition timing vs fictitious revenues would be an example
- unreal37 7y agoReading the report, he seems to be dipping into "future forecasting" quite a bit. "First, a stiff recession after ten years of domestic economic growth, will see that the next chapter in GE’s history is Chapter 11." You can't predict a recession, or when it comes how it's going to go, so how is that "first" when it comes to discovering accounting fraud?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- avs733 7y agoyeah I'm surprised as I read through this a lot of it seems predicated on assumptions of what will happen outside of GE. I'm far from a finance guru (but I did buy some holiday IHG stock last night)...but this one doesn't read as fraud as much as a time bomb that could blow up at any moment, it just hasn't yet. Fraud is an entirely different level of claim. Dishonesty about the risk...sure...probably GAAPish'ing your way into a higher than deserved stock price...sure. But I can't even parse through the reports repetitions of the same information over and over with increasing strident bolded red text and skull and cross bones emojis what is the core thesis.
- unreal37 7y agoHe's saying in two years they'll have to disclose losses that they don't have to disclose today. Um, OK. He's saying they don't have the cash in the bank to make a payment that they have coming due next year. Um, OK. Not really fraud, no. I think this is more of a "hope the stock falls in the future so we can get rich" kind of thing.
- mrfredward 7y agoAt GE's low after the report, it had fallen about 14% for a loss of $10 billion in market cap. You could interpret this as the market assigning an expected value of fraud at GE of $10 billion. The report claims $38 billion in fraud, so either market participants don't believe the accusation, or fraud was already priced in. The stock has rebounded since, so seems like the big market voting machine thinks this report is bunk. Time will tell who is right.
- dbuder 7y agoOr the latecomer pleb shorts are getting squeezed or the hedge fund "bought the rumour, sold the news".
- spectramax 7y agoI find the title whimsical because GE actually bought part of Enron after its collapse, specifically GE Wind is a spinoff of Enron's wind energy division.