3 ms·
Removing downvotes to have only positive reinforcement is, IMO, a bad idea - there are things that are incorrect, misleading, offtopic or offensive that we deem
by munk-a 7y ago
Removing downvotes to have only positive reinforcement is, IMO, a bad idea - there are things that are incorrect, misleading, offtopic or offensive that we deem do not contribute to the discussion. The HN karma system (when the topic isn't political) helps to push more interesting insights on the article or question to the top of the board.
Currently there are three actions that can be taken, upvote, downvote & flag. Since these actions are never actually defined (AFAIK) I can only report my interpretation flagging is something I maybe have done once for an openly hateful comment, but I mostly never do... I generally downvote when a statement is thin (without being amusing), redundant (common knowledge), FUD (probably a regurgitated false talking point) or off topic. This doesn't mirror my upvoting, my upvotes tend to focus on: insight, interesting question, well founded argument.
I am a bit sad your comment has been downvoted as, while I don't agree with your idea, it's an interesting thing to consider and it seems to be suggested entirely in good faith.