4 ms·
Even the ability to up or downvote I think takes away from the incentive to provide good discourse. Some people are content just down voting a perfectly reasona
by ehnto 7y ago
Even the ability to up or downvote I think takes away from the incentive to provide good discourse. Some people are content just down voting a perfectly reasonable argument rather than contributing to the conversation and having to reason out their opinions. You even see it here, where posts are greyed out but no one has given any reason why.
I don't have a better way mind you. Unmoderated discourse tends to end up bad, and voting is a form of self moderation. The alternative of fully staffed moderation also has it's issues. Community building online is just a hard problem to solve.
Just removing downvotes I think is a good step. Because if someone just agrees you aren't losing much by them upvoting instead of posting "me too!". But if someone feels like they disagree and want to downvote, that could be an interesting conversation that never happened.
- chr1 7y agoThis happens because people want a disagree button, but have only a milder version of flag button instead. Sometimes one just wants to support a viewpoint without bringing additional arguments. I think it would be better to display separate agree disagree and flag counters on each post, and not reduce karma if there are more disagree votes than agree.
- mc32 7y agoMaybe adjust the cost of upvoting and downvoting. So a downvote to a reputable commenter might cost 10 or 100 karma. Upvoting might also incur a cost. Maybe it should depend on the reputation of the post (post karma) or the poster (reputation) and also it should cost people with more karma more to vote (but not linearly). As a side-effect it would allow real-time insight into a sliver of online virtual economics.
- pjc50 7y agoStackoverflow "charges" you one point to downvote. You recieve 10 points for an upvote, which are free.
- wvenable 7y agoI think simply adding "Agree" and "Disagree" buttons and separate "off topic" or "downvote" button would make a big difference. What "up" and "down" means is a bit vague and everyone has a different opinion on the matter. I will readily upvote comments I agree with but I usually only downvote comments that add no value to the discussion rather than being something I disagree with. So even my own voting pattern on HN is asymmetric.
- cortesoft 7y agoMaybe how slashdot used to do it (still does it? I haven't been on there for a while, but not because of moderation)... People who had good standing would get N 'moderation points' that they could use, and you were allowed to mark N comments as being good or bad (with categories for which type of good or bad (e.g. insightful, funny, interesting, etc)) Most of the time you didn't have the option to moderate, so you can't just downvote or upvote, you have to reply. However, I am not sure if this is actually needed... most of the comments that get downvoted SHOULD be... they dont contribute to the conversation, and replying to them just feeds the trolls.
- munk-a 7y agoRemoving downvotes to have only positive reinforcement is, IMO, a bad idea - there are things that are incorrect, misleading, offtopic or offensive that we deem do not contribute to the discussion. The HN karma system (when the topic isn't political) helps to push more interesting insights on the article or question to the top of the board. Currently there are three actions that can be taken, upvote, downvote & flag. Since these actions are never actually defined (AFAIK) I can only report my interpretation flagging is something I maybe have done once for an openly hateful comment, but I mostly never do... I generally downvote when a statement is thin (without being amusing), redundant (common knowledge), FUD (probably a regurgitated false talking point) or off topic. This doesn't mirror my upvoting, my upvotes tend to focus on: insight, interesting question, well founded argument. I am a bit sad your comment has been downvoted as, while I don't agree with your idea, it's an interesting thing to consider and it seems to be suggested entirely in good faith.
- dvtrn 7y agoI don’t have a better way mind you I do Get rid of votes entirely. All of it.
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoPeople might start reposting stuff they think should be more visible. You'd have to do something like 4chan's /r9k/.
- philpem 7y agoIt's a problem that only gets worse at scale, too. At least with decentralisation, the problem is distributed among multiple instances and moderation teams.