5 ms·
No, the polarization (and attendant culture war) has been going on longer than social media as we know it have existed. It doesn't help, but it's just not the b
by anigbrowl 7y ago
No, the polarization (and attendant culture war) has been going on longer than social media as we know it have existed. It doesn't help, but it's just not the big factor it's assumed to be either - an assumption driven by social media companies' desire to trade engagement for ad $. The people who are doing most to drive social polarization are the least likely to be motivated by social proof. Consider that 8ch and its ilk have no social scoring mechanism but produce some of the most radical extremists.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> The people who are doing most to drive social polarization are the least likely to be motivated by social proof. Young females dedicating their lives to be Instagram fitness/fashion/bathing suit influencers would like to have a talk with you.
- mulmen 7y agoIs the Instagram influencer motivated by polarization or by social proof? I think the GP is arguing that when your goal is polarization you don't care about social proof.
- MuffinFlavored 7y agoMost Instagram influencers want you to know how awesome their body is. They want you to sign up for their fitness program or purchase (and envy) the latest fashion they are wearing. If you don't follow their fitness program or purchase their fashion, you're polarized against them, right? Because their lifestyle is the one with millions of followers and likes, not yours. Does that make sense?
- mulmen 7y agoNo, that doesn’t make sense. Polarization is a fundamental disagreement on some issue or set of issues. People pick sides for whatever reason and they are unlikely to ever change their beliefs. An influencer is just a marketer selling a personal brand for profit. It’s entirely different.
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> Polarization is a fundamental disagreement on some issue or set of issues I feel like "I have 1m followers and you don't" polarizes people into two separate groups?
- mulmen 7y agoNo, it doesn't. That's just jealousy. The 1m followers do not themselves have 1m followers and yet they still follow the influencer. You could make some argument that this is analogous to a religion and if the influencer pushes an agenda that could lead to polarization but is also probably bad business. I don't see social media influencers pushing anything controversial, they're marketers, they want to appeal to everyone. Polarization is when one politician says we should tax rich people but another says we shouldn't. It's a fundamental disagreement on a personal belief. Not a statement of fact. The belief may be informed by facts but polarization comes from a disagreement on a course of action.
- pjc50 7y agoThat's not what we mean by "polarisation": those women (not "females") are usually completely apolitical because it would hurt their product marketing. Doesn't seem to work the same way for male "influencers", who are more likely to have a connection to the right in some way.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoCould it be they're already that way and they're concentrated at 8chan due to them being driven out of places where social scoring is used?
- carry_bit 7y agoIf that was the case, would you expect anecdotes such as https://i.supload.com/HJ_QEC-rg.png https://i.supload.com/HJ_QEC-rg.png ? The internal narrative of those sites is that without the ability to appeal to popularity (no scoring) nor the ability to appeal to authority (anonymity), all ideas must stand on their own merits. Rationality means you don't get to believe what you want to believe (hence the hurt-box). Is it really surprising that a radical search for the truth would produce radicals?
- Mirioron 7y agoBut the ideas don't really stand on their own merit. The reason the poster claims to have gone onto the site at first was for trolling purposes and they used a specific political angle to do so. If you have enough people like this then it becomes easier to convince others that these bad ideas have merit as there will seemingly be many people supporting the ideas. Basically, you're not dealing with tabula rasa because the trolls seem to favor one side and it tilts the balance.
- kortilla 7y agoIdeas don’t have merit based on the number of parrots.
- ohduran 7y agoI disagree. Haven't been all told off by our parents that "if everyone jumped off a cliff, would you?"? That in my opinion means that humans are prone to do and think what their peers do or think. The key issue is what we define as "peers".
- carry_bit 7y ago
- kleer001 7y agoMy current hypothesis is that our current culture war is being driven by a lack of accountability. From graft in politics to anonymous bullying online, more and more people are able to get away with worse and worse bad faith behavior for longer and longer.
- tus88 7y agoOr maybe there are substantive sociopolitical issues at play - primarily people at some kind of disadvantage trying to wrest power, wealth and control from those who already have it (as if history has never heard that story before). Except now it is this weird kind of interplay between race, gender, migrants, and no-one is which side they are on.
- antupis 7y agoThe USA's problem is the voting system. Currently, it favors extremism eg try to get the nomination in primaries saying another side is actually ok. Change system something like ranked-choice voting and you get nominees literally singing kumbaya together https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IyJKh_CwPI4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IyJKh_CwPI4 .
- remarkEon 7y ago>Currently, it favors extremism eg try to get the nomination in primaries saying another side is actually ok. This is just flat out wrong, and I think you might be conflating what could be interpreted as a "purity spiral" on the left right now as "normal". It is most certainly not normal. The 2016 Dems nominated the most centrist candidate in a generation (at least), and Trump managed to win the general by essentially playing the game better in the Electoral College. Even if I accepted your premise for a moment (I don't, in reality) that ranked-choice voting actually pushes candidates into aligning with each other ideologically, to the extent it makes them less detested by their ostensible political opponents, it is not at all clear that this is an optimum outcome. Especially in times of political turmoil - and I don't think it's controversial to suggest that we are in one right now a la the 1970s - a "regression to the mean" of choice in political candidates seems to be the exact opposite of a good idea. That just spells "status quo" for electoral outcomes, and would cause many (or most) to lose faith in the political system all together.
- ahartman00 7y agoFar longer in fact. Before the internet was popular. "We find that despite short-term fluctuations, partisanship or non-cooperation in the U.S. Congress has been increasing exponentially for over 60 years with no sign of abating or reversing." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25897956 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25897956