4 ms·
> Companies with revenue of twenty-five billion dollars or more that provide an online marketplace I think Walmart fits that definition. Any sufficiently-large
by derefr 7y ago
> Companies with revenue of twenty-five billion dollars or more that provide an online marketplace
I think Walmart fits that definition. Any sufficiently-large brick-and-mortar business inevitably expands to have an online marketplace, whether it's their main line of business or not.
Your average grocery-store chain would only not fall under these regulations for lack of size.
- benburleson 7y agoIs the average grocery store online? I wouldn't expect so..
- derefr 7y agoThe average $25bn grocery-store chain is. Which was my point. The two criteria really just boil down to one criterion—size—because internet presence follows from size.
- LargeWu 7y agoThe average grocery store chain, even the largest (Kroger) doesn't have online dominance and potentially anticompetitive practices on the same scale that Amazon/Google/Facebook do.
- pwinnski 7y agoPresumably the wording of the bill would require separation in the online marketplace, but not the retail stores. That is, Walmart stores could still favor "their" own brands, while they would be forbidden from doing so online.
- Kalium 7y agoIt would affect Safeway, Kroger, HEB, Publix, CostCo, WalMart, SuperTarget... which is a list of grocery stores that covers most of the US.
- triceratops 7y agoNo more Kirkland brand?! No!!!
- dmoy 7y agoI'm unsure. A significant quantity of stuff sold with the Kirkland label is just whitelabeled, with varying degrees of hidden-ness. Their recent beer for instance is labeled Kirkland up top, but also have the company (Hopf Malz something), and it's a pretty trivial amount of digging to get to the underlying Gordon Biersch. I don't know where you draw the line though * white labeled but not really because it's still got the original name on it * white labeled without the original name * self produced Probably you could get finer grained than that too. So it's entirely possible that you could pass a law banning large chains from doing whitelabeling, but actually you'd still get the same stuff on the shelves with their original labels and it'd be fine. Or it's possible you could pass a law banning chains from selling their own produced stuff, but still have whitelabeled "house brand" be ok. But then if you were equitable about that in online space, - amazon couldn't sell fire phones or echo dot alexa things, but they could sell an "amazon choice" if it's just whitelabeled. So idk.
- triceratops 7y agoThe line between "own produced" and "whitelabed" is also tricky (or maybe it's not, if you're an expert in the industry). Is it "own produced" even if it's by a contract manufacturer, as long as that particular product isn't produced for anyone else? Large retailers demand unique models of things like electronics to prevent comparison shopping/price matching.
- dmoy 7y agoHah yes. My original list was much more than three long, you can find many places to draw the line. Going in another dimension, you can introduce the kind of wonkiness you get around "made in the USA" labeling on products which have all their parts manufactured elsewhere and then some trivial last step done on US soil.