6 ms·
So it's okay for supermarkets and brick/mortar retailers to offer house brands but not online retailers. Pretty arbitrary line. And this would equally apply to
by threeseed 7y ago
So it's okay for supermarkets and brick/mortar retailers to offer house brands but not online retailers. Pretty arbitrary line.
And this would equally apply to Apple and Google who have a number of apps on their app stores. This would then lead to even more bundled apps on the phone e.g. Garageband which would decrease competition.
Most of these policies are really not well thought out.
- Avshalom 7y agoA lot this depends on what they mean by marketplace. Amazon (and Walmart I think) don't just buy and sell stuff. They also let you sell stuff through them. Target on the other hand have an online store but you are always buying from Target. So if the law considers "online marketplace" from "online store" then it doesn't apply to Target.
- RugnirViking 7y agoThe line is not 'you are not allowed to ever do this' but 'this particular instance is hurting competition'. If the vast majority of people shopped at one supermarket, and that supermarket's most popular products were largely it's own brand products, and most industries that competed with such products had largely shrunk to providing specialty alternatives or cheap knockoffs because it was so hard to compete, then there might be a case for breaking that supermarket up.
- mal10c 7y agoSo not really a leading question, just curious... why shouldn't I be OK with buying the cheap mega-supermarket brand product? As the consumer, I just want a cheap price - I personally don't really care where the money is going. If small companies can't produce a less expensive alternative, then won't breaking up the larger company just increase costs to the consumer? Thanks for your thoughts.
- damnyou 7y agoYou as the consumer aren't the only entity that matters. The long term health of communities might not be aligned with short term consumer benefit.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoTo answer with another question: how can you tell the difference between big pseudo-monopolies truly providing the best product or service vs. smaller companies being unable to enter the market with a better one because a big company has locked them out?
- workblood 7y agoI’m sorry, can you clarify what you mean by pseudo-monopoly? It’s not a term of art and I’m trying to understand your argument.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoMaybe pseudo-monopoly was the wrong term… I'm basically saying that if a company has enough market or lobbying power, it can distort the market by blocking entrants who might make better/cheaper products or services. For example, ISPs lobbying to ban municipal competitors.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rapind 7y agoUltimately if all those other brands go out of business, the cheaper option may no longer be that cheap.
- bduerst 7y agoThis comes up with predatory pricing antitrust claims, which are complex in themselves, but you shouldn't punish someone or an organization for behavior that they only have the potential to do, but have not done.
- rapind 7y agoI think it's destined to happen when there is less competition. I don't think of it as punishment, but as prevention. Even if we assume a company was altruistic and kept prices artificially low, the lack of competition would at least prevent a product from getting cheaper faster due to less players innovating... and we wouldn't even be able to measure what we're missing out on.
- GuiA 7y agoYes, and effective regulation is precisely about preventing broader emergent patterns that harm innovation, competition, and society as a whole as a result of the (inevitably) short sighted, individual actions of consumers who indeed often only care about the cheapest prices.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> why shouldn't I be OK with buying the cheap mega-supermarket brand product Just some random thoughts, in different contexts: 1. Buying the cheap mega-supermarket can lead to non-obvious degradations in your community (e.g. you find yourself in a news desert because the local paper went bankrupt, following the closure of the local stores who advertised there). 2. Competition keeps competitors honest, but if one company gets too much of a lead, it's competitors give up leaving fewer market-based checks on its behavior (even if it was fantastic and awesome in the first place). Eventually prices will go up or quality down, as the never-ending quest to provide increasing shareholder value continues. 3. The real costs may not be reflected in the sticker price. For instance, you pay for Facebook and Google with your data and privacy, not your money. A competitor that directly charges you $20/year may actually be a better deal.
- CWuestefeld 7y agoI don't think they can specifically address a single entity like that: the laws have to be applicable across the board. I believe otherwise it would be the constitutionally-forbidden "Bill of Attainder".
- LargeWu 7y agoIt would only be a Bill of Attainder if it targeted and punished specific entities. From what I can gather, this just sets parameters. It would likely fall under our existing antitrust framework.
- CWuestefeld 7y agoif it targeted and punished specific entities Ummm... that's exactly what I said. In response to "The line is not 'you are not allowed to ever do this' but 'this particular instance is hurting competition'." I replied "I don't think they can specifically address a single entity like that: the laws have to be applicable across the board"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- novok 7y agoThen it should apply to walmart, target & costco then, which many of the same arguments applied now and 30 years ago and have a similar range of market cap. But these regulations never materialized.
- smhenderson 7y agoI don't disagree with you but I think the argument there is that those three compete with each other so no one has absolute dominance over the market place. Oligopolies aren't much better for the public than monopolies but they seem to get a lot less scrutiny from regulators. I am really not a fan of Walmart but I do shop at Costco and Target occasionally and I try to check both when making meaningful household purchases to see which one's cheaper. At some level, they do have to compete with each other on price and service.
- novok 7y agoThing is the big tech cos also compete with each other. You can online shop at amazon, walmart, ebay and many other small online shops. Same with advertising. You can advertise at google, fb, twitter and a bunch of other small advertising providers. Yes they distort their respective markets and put pressure on suppliers, but so does walmart and other big retailers. So if the law comes into place, it shouldn’t be limited to the online space
- ConceitedCode 7y agoThat doesn't strike me as a very clear line. Let's change the scale a bit instead of nationally / internationally. If there's only 1 Walmart store in a small town (no competitors near by), does that mean they can't sell their house brand there? What about a Walmart in a town with a Target and 80% of the sales are at Walmart? Can Target sell their house brand if Walmart can't in this scenario?
- samsonradu 7y agoA town is more open to competition, anytime a third player can open up a store with relatively small investment. Meanwhile to take on a dominant player like Amazon is extremely hard. I believe the line is drawn at ‘large-scale winner-takes-all players’. It doesn’t necessarily have to be fair but it is supposed to benefit the entire economy. As long as there’s a relative balance between the economical power of competitors no measures are required.
- ConceitedCode 7y ago> A town is more open to competition, anytime a third player can open up a store with relatively small investment. Meanwhile to take on a dominant player like Amazon is extremely hard. You think it's easier to open a physical store to compete with Walmart than to spin up an ecommerce site to compete with Amazon?
- exergy 7y agoFor sure. There are so many more parameters to physical store. Proximity is a HUGE one. Quality of service. Specific items that they stock. These kinds of things allow smaller stores to exist in my small town even while there is a huge supermarket nearby. On the other hand, I do not use ANY one-stop site for online shopping outside of Amazon.
- wyre 7y agoA physical store, at a minimum, has built in advertising based on location. Budget in local advertising and people will shop there if prices, service, location, and the products are good. I couldnt even imagine how a new online store would be able to start competing with Amazon. There are existing webstores that over the years have lost a lot of business to amazon (Newegg, Sweetwater, B&H Photo, etc). Even local stores are losing business to amazon.
- jhbadger 7y agoThis situation isn't just hypothetical. In the 1940s the grocery chain A&P was the largest retailer of any sort in the US and there was a real concern that they were anti-competitive because they owned a number of food processing plants in addition to their stores. The Federal government brought suit but didn't succeed in breaking up A&P. Ultimately, of course, A&P didn't succeed in monopolizing groceries, and even went bankrupt a decade or so ago, but they were the WalMart of their time.
- fbonetti 7y agoIt's funny that you mention supermarkets, because the A&P grocery store chain was from 1915 to 1975 the largest grocery retailer in the US. At its peak in the 1940s, A&P captured 10% of total US grocery spend. It too came under scrutiny and was accused of being a "monopoly", as its cheap prices forced smaller competitors out of business. And yet despite being a "monopoly", it began to decline in the 1950s when it failed to keep pace with competitors that opened larger supermarkets with more modern features demanded by customers. It continued its slow decline until it completely shuttered in 2015. A&P was once as recognizable as Google or Walmart is today, and yet most people have never even heard of A&P. Sears too once had a "monopoly" on mail order products. People marveled at how amazing it was that you could order a product, mail in a check, and receive the product six weeks later, all without stepping into a store! Now they're bankrupt. The whole concept of a business "controlling" the market is ridiculous. Amazon operates in a highly competitive, low margin industry that requires a tremendous amount of logistical overhead to function. The minute they stop innovating, they're toast.
- CharlesColeman 7y agoSo if we just let the market work, I can look forward to finally getting out from under the thumb of FAANG when I'm retired?
- jaredklewis 7y agoWhat exactly is your complaint against FAANG? You are free to buy a Linux or windows laptop, not create a Facebook account, subscribe to Hulu, not Shop amazon, use fast mail etc... Hard for me to get too worked up about tech giants seeing as using them is optional and alternatives abound. I don’t see how my life is made worse if someone else buys a MacBook. None of the things that do irk me about tech companies (security breaches, unethical advertising, spread of fake news, and so on) would be addressed in any way by a breakup.
- majewsky 7y ago> You are free to buy a Linux or windows laptop, not create a Facebook account, subscribe to Hulu, not Shop amazon, use fast mail etc... Try participating in modern society without an Android or Apple smartphone or tablet. It's still possible, but becoming more difficult each day. (And to clarify, I don't mean "leave your phone at home today". I mean not owning a smartphone or tablet at all.)
- derefr 7y ago> Companies with revenue of twenty-five billion dollars or more that provide an online marketplace I think Walmart fits that definition. Any sufficiently-large brick-and-mortar business inevitably expands to have an online marketplace, whether it's their main line of business or not. Your average grocery-store chain would only not fall under these regulations for lack of size.
- benburleson 7y agoIs the average grocery store online? I wouldn't expect so..
- derefr 7y agoThe average $25bn grocery-store chain is. Which was my point. The two criteria really just boil down to one criterion—size—because internet presence follows from size.
- LargeWu 7y agoThe average grocery store chain, even the largest (Kroger) doesn't have online dominance and potentially anticompetitive practices on the same scale that Amazon/Google/Facebook do.
- pwinnski 7y agoPresumably the wording of the bill would require separation in the online marketplace, but not the retail stores. That is, Walmart stores could still favor "their" own brands, while they would be forbidden from doing so online.
- Kalium 7y agoIt would affect Safeway, Kroger, HEB, Publix, CostCo, WalMart, SuperTarget... which is a list of grocery stores that covers most of the US.
- triceratops 7y ago
- TuringNYC 7y ago...or...it might lead to where we were in the 90s where you installed un-trusted apps from the web and took your risks with viruses or spyware. I actually like the idea of a central app store where at least there is some process. Perhaps we can have a better process, or more fine grained permissions rights, but to open up the gates seems like a big step backwards.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y agoI want you to be right, but the truth is we already have that _with_ these centralized platforms. The centralization benefits are not geared towards consumers, and they never were.
- icebraining 7y agoWell, what about the EU browsers solution? Google could still have its own app store, but instead of being pre-installed and integrated, the user would have to select one or more during the initial system configuration (and have a menu for changing that later).
- danShumway 7y agoYou can always add moderation on top of something, but once it's on you can't take it off. What I mean by that is that Apple isn't the only company that could vet apps. Anyone could put together a list of "trusted" apps into a software repository/store and you could pick whichever one you trusted and use only it. This is already how Linux works. In the long run, this is probably even better for people who want to only run vetted apps. Apple's app store policies have to cover everyone who runs iOS, which means that even with the best intentions, they can't be as permissive or as strict as some people want. If Apple wasn't in that boat, you could have an app store that had much harsher rules about data collection, performance, and permissions. My experience has been that specialized platforms usually produce better results for their target audiences than generalized alternatives. As the sole gatekeeper to iOS, the best Apple is ever going to be able to provide is a generalized storefront.
- bduerst 7y agoKey differentiation: - Brick and Mortar stores buy inventory and choose from what they own to sell inside their stores. - Online platforms make revenue by being open to anyone to sell their own inventory through.
- 0xffff2 7y agoI don't think it's quite that simple. I'm not in the business, but every time this comes up someone points out that stores don't actually always buy inventory. Often times they are simply selling the shelf space and it's up to distributors to stock it themselves.
- bduerst 7y agoIt's still different. For those retailers (e.g. Best Buy is a good example) they're leasing floor space in what is essentially a public warehouse. You still need to outbid existing inventory space, which is not the same as an open platform for anyone to sell through.
- r-s 7y agoI know a rep who leases freezer space from our local big chain grocery store and is responsible for that area. Ive heard of quality issues from this specific ice cream before, and it always reminded me of getting poor quality items from non-amazon sellers.
- Tiktaalik 7y agoyep. Online platforms can just peek at the data and when they see something selling they can make their own version. They are taking zero risk. In contrast brick and mortar has no idea what does well until they start buying the product to sell themselves.
- bilbo0s 7y agoWait? What? Would this not apply to Walmart and Target too? If this only applies to digital stores, then yeah, it's total bull. Because Amazon could just build some stores like Target and Walmart.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIt's OK for competitive businesses to offer house brands but not monopolies. Bundling Internet Explorer into Windows was only disallowed because Windows was a monopoly.
- magduf 7y agoThis isn't quite true. It was never disallowed for IE to be bundled. There was a court case about it, and then they lost the case, and then Bush took over the White House and the DOJ just completely dropped the whole case, so MS was never punished nor made to unbundle IE. IE is still bundled in Windows to this day.
- WalterBright 7y agoWhich demonstrates that the fear of Microsoft, and before that the fear of IBM, was unjustified.
- magduf 7y agoWrong. These companies held us back because of their size, and it took a lot for a competitor to come along and unseat them because of their market inertia. Generally, tech had to advance enough to make their dominance obsolete, instead of a better competitor being able to unseat them just by having a better product. If this hadn't been the case, we'd be farther along now.
- WalterBright 7y ago> These companies held us back because of their size I don't see how, for example, Explorer being free held anyone back.
- magduf 7y agoI guess you don't remember ActiveX, do you?
- elihu 7y ago> And this would equally apply to Apple and Google who have a number of apps on their app stores. This would then lead to even more bundled apps on the phone e.g. Garageband which would decrease competition. ...or it could cause Google and/or Apple to spin off their app store as an independent company, and allow other independent companies to offer their own competing app store.
- fooey 7y agoI agree, Amazon having a house brand while knowing the sales numbers and margins for other products is completely analogous to Walmart and CostCo having house brands while selling competing products.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> Walmart and CostCo having house brands while selling competing products Not really. CostCo and supermarket house brands are often manufactured by the same companies that makes name brands. Also retail stores aren't "marketplaces" like Amazon is, they buy the products they offer. In short, it's often not competition, just a way to segment customers. Amazon, on the other hand, runs an actual marketplace AND competes in it, which has different dynamics. Though, personally, I'd rather Amazon shut down its marketplace and go back to something more like a traditional store. Either that, or they need to be make responsible for the rampant fraud that they've allowed in their marketplace.
- munk-a 7y agoThere are lots of things we don't have specific laws about because they haven't become a problem to everyday people - online retailers absolutely have abused market control to enrich themselves - but if a brick and mortar store ever managed to Amazon things up then I'd be happy to see this law expanded to include them... to my knowledge, as terrible as Walmart is, it isn't quite up to Amazon's level of terrible.
- walshemj 7y agoWell not sure how it is in the USA but the big supermarkets in the UK defiantly abuse their position to bully farmers and even big multi nationals. Forcing then to cut costs and corners (hence the adulterated meat scandals a few years ago) and bullying them into paying for in store promotions even big companies like Heineken have been shaken down. The big 4 probably should be forced to divest themselves of their audit functions as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- m_ke 7y agoSupermarkets purchase their inventory so it's in their best interest to sell it. Amazon doesn't really care if the 3rd party seller's inventory never moves because it doesn't cost them anything.
- fcarraldo 7y agoSupermarkets are not marketplaces. Amazon is. This is well thought out and it’s a very clear distinction. If Wal-Mart started allowing anyone to set up shop and sell there, it would be a more apt comparison. Apple and Google will have to spin out divisions that sell apps on their app stores. They can still partner under this plan, but must be independent entities. What’s the problem there?
- d1zzy 7y agoSo people would have to pay money for the official Gmail application? I sure hope not!
- majewsky 7y agoIt always amuses me how people spend 4$ on a cup of coffee, but refuse to pay 99 cents for an essential productivity tool. If payed GMail means that they actually listen to their users when desigining their interfaces, it sounds like a positive change.
- refurb 7y agoYup. The law books are stuffed with well intended laws that simply shifted the incentives in another direction. The 80/20 rule for insurance companies is a good example - now they have an incentive for prices to go up, not down.