5 ms·
I actually think this would just make things worse. If you were strip Google to just search and Facebook to just Facebook then they would have to more aggressi
by threeseed 7y ago
I actually think this would just make things worse.
If you were strip Google to just search and Facebook to just Facebook then they would have to more aggressively go after advertising dollars to ensure they are growing revenue. And since they would've already been broken up they would surely do this by invading privacy even more.
Surely the smarter move is to focus on heavily regulating their ability to track users. And make approaches like Apple did with WebKit mandatory.
- hnhg 7y agoWhat about privacy regulation? Why is that not also feasible?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThere are a lot of things that make that hard. The first is how many industries are against it -- Google's not the half of it. Google would still make a mint if all they could do was show ads for car insurance when people search for car insurance and so on. But meaningful privacy regulation would effectively prohibit the likes of Equifax, and then you would get huge pushback from the finance industry and realtors. Then there's the fact that a lot of politically powerful government surveillance agencies want all your stuff to be in The Cloud instead of on your own device where they can't read it, so they'd fight it too. And the biggest problem is that you need the rules to be good rules that are at the same time effective without destroying small entities and entrenching the incumbents, which is really hard and there is a high probability they'll screw it up (especially with the aforementioned constraints), but doing it wrong can easily be worse than doing nothing. Then you don't get privacy but you destroy the upstart alternatives that might have made it possible for the people who most need it, or could have presented a challenge to the incumbents given more time.
- debatem1 7y agoEquifax may not be a great example here, since Congress already stomped on it explicitly because it was concerned about the privacy implications of digitizing the information they held. That fear led to the Fair Credit Reporting Act, which substantially curtailed many of Equifax's most egregious business practices.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe Fair Credit Reporting Act was passed in 1970, and credit reporting agencies continue to collect personal data on everybody they can, without their consent, and provide it to just about anyone who pays them to.
- debatem1 7y agoYep. The difference is in what they don't do anymore. Once upon a time they literally collected rumors and sold them, and took great pains to ensure that you couldn't see what information had been collected or sold about you or to whom. Those practices were curtailed by Congress; given that, it seems foolish to assert that current practices, hated as they are by the electorate, might not also be curtailed through legislative action.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Those practices were curtailed by Congress; given that, it seems foolish to assert that current practices, hated as they are by the electorate, might not also be curtailed through legislative action. The problem is you don't just need some law to be passed, it also has to be a good law, which is the really hard part. And it's a lot easier for Equifax than tech because if Equifax would dry up and blow away it would only make the world better. Their entire business is doing the thing nobody should be doing at all. No part of what they do actually needs to be saved. The problem with Google is that they also make a search engine. We need search engines and email providers and video hosts to continue to exist even if their funding source changes. So it's no help to pass a law that just makes them impossible, or makes it so that nobody can do it unless they're a multibillion dollar corporation. That makes it worse rather than better, because competition is the greatest practical method of thwarting corporate misbehavior. Laws alone can't do it -- see also pre-breakup AT&T, post-breakup AT&T and Comcast, various failed attempts at totalitarian communism, etc. Especially if you make rules that cause the incumbents to get so big and entrenched that it becomes inevitable that they capture the regulators. The best thing laws can do is to ensure that competition is thriving. But most of them in practice do the opposite.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoIt won't even get that far. This proposal will be watered down and will be implemented in such a way that Google, Facebook etc will be protected from any harm and this law will only serve to hamper new entrants and protect the incumbents position. At this stage of the election cycle a few presidential elections ago Obama was promising socialized medicine if elected, what we got from a democratically controlled house and senate was Obamacare. This is what always happens.
- methodover 7y agoUhh, he never campaigned for a single payer model.
- aaronbrethorst 7y agoCorrect! At least not when he was running for the presidency. https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2009/jul/16/barack-obama/obama-statements-single-payer-have-changed-bit/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2009/jul...
- favorited 7y agoPeople forget that his healthcare proposal as a candidate was to the right of Clinton's.
- fuzz4lyfe 7y agoIn what way is a "public option"[0] not socialised medicine? > In the 2008 Obama-Biden health care plan on the campaign’s website, candidate Obama promised that “any American will have the opportunity to enroll in [a] new public plan.” [0]https://thinkprogress.org/flashback-obama-repeatedly-touted-public-option-before-refusing-to-push-for-it-in-the-final-hours-380cbf31b6e0/ https://thinkprogress.org/flashback-obama-repeatedly-touted-...
- b_tterc_p 7y agoOr they could just give stable dividends and stop growing which is honestly completely reasonable for a company that makes most of its money on super passive activities like google. Google is growth oriented because it has so much money that it can experiment with things. Maybe that’s dumb?
- magduf 7y agoNo, that's completely impossible. Publicly-traded corporations in America simply can't operate that way these days, they have to be constantly growing or else they implode.
- derefr 7y agoThey would still have business relationships with the other entities they were split from; they'd just be only business relationships, done in public and appearing on the balance sheets, and able to be regulated "between." An example of the type of business relationship Warren probably wants to encourage: the way Google pays Mozilla to keep Google Search as Firefox's default search provider. So, if Google were split up into Google-the-search-engine and Google-the-ad-agency, Google Search's main source of revenue would still be from ads—but it'd be via the separate company of Google Ads, paying Google Search for ad placement.
- dcolkitt 7y ago> Google Search's main source of revenue would still be from ads—but it'd be via the separate company of Google Ads, paying Google Search for ad placement. This would almost certainly lead to less privacy. Google Search, instead of just sourcing ads from Google Ads would have to open bidding to a wide variety of ad networks. That means your personal search history wouldn't just be accessed by Google, it would be publicly available to any upstart ad network that wanted to bid for Search ad placement.
- derefr 7y agoYes, by default. But opening that interface exposes that previously company-internal leak of information to the government-as-regulator to step in and clamp down on. If they say both that Google must not run its own ads but must rely on a third-party for ad placement, and that Google isn't allowed to show its search data to third-parties, then that has a meaningful impact on how Google operates as a business.
- utopian3 7y agoI don’t have as much faith in the system as you. And I wouldn’t want to wait a decade for it to be fixed.
- icebraining 7y agoHoping that companies won't explore every possible avenue for cash just because they have a lot is not a good plan. Google and FB are already aggressively going after advertising dollars.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoOne does not exclude the other. We can break up these companies and restrict what they are allowed to do in terms of tracking users. That would make it harder for them to misbehave and easier for governments to do something about it if they do.
- yumraj 7y ago> then they would have to more aggressively go after advertising dollars to ensure they are growing revenue Aren't you assuming that they are not already giving it all they've got?
- mattnewton 7y agoI think personally Google gets a bad rap by a media industry jealous of their success, and that the majority of customers are sending their data to Google's servers for good services. But, saying that breaking them up would only make them invade privacy more in your view, that's the view of someone in an abusive relationship. Whether or not Facebook and Google are violating your privacy rights should be a separate question that calls for other regulatory action, regardless of the entity's size. We need to have both conversations. Disclaimer: I work as a lowly grunt for Google, but my opinions are my own and do not represent them.