4 ms·
They very first version of Reddit used spark lines instead of points. People hated it. We experimented multiple times with removing karma from the equation. It
by jedberg 7y ago
They very first version of Reddit used spark lines instead of points. People hated it. We experimented multiple times with removing karma from the equation. It always reduced engagement.
People just really need that dopamine hit of seeing their points go up.
Honestly I prefer the way HN does it, where only the submitter can see their own points.
- Simon_says 7y agoIn hindsight, maybe optimizing for engagement also optimized for polarization?
- kaonashi 7y agoYou're probably correct, but what product owner is going to take the chance on purposefully chasing lower engagement?
- jedberg 7y agoHacker News. :)
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoAd-supported business can’t solve this problem.
- gordaco 7y agoConsidering that this is also the biggest problem regarding youtube, you may be right. However, if it's true, the consequences are terrifying, if you take into account that engagement is directly tied to the financial success of every company whose money comes from advertising. (And here it is: yet another reason to despise advertising and surveillance capitalism...). EDIT: typo.
- AlexDragusin 7y agoWell, engagement for the sake of karma is likely not a worthy engagement, I would consider reducing that sort of engagement a good thing. Surely it's not a black and white matter though. Without having seen what kind of content really gets moderated, I'd say HN got a good balance.
- wvenable 7y agoI can see that; there are literally thousands of people "farming karma" on Reddit every day. It's definitely engagement but I don't necessarily think it's healthy engagement. Unhealthy engagement is what this article is all about. Measuring engagement seems a bit like Goodhart's law.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoUnless you can show healthy engagement clicks more ads than unhealthy engagement the people who pay the bills won't care what kind of engagement you have.
- eloisius 7y ago>It always reduced engagement. Exactly. All these companies optimize for "engagement," regardless of how vapid, destructive or banal it is.
- philpem 7y agoWhen all the advertisers and investors care about is clicks...
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoThis is also why cancel culture is a thing—pressuring advertisers to remove funding is the only input we really have to what goods and services our society produces.
- eitland 7y ago> Honestly I prefer the way HN does it, where only the submitter can see their own points. FWIW lobste.rs has another interesting take: it doesn't show points on comments until after a while and then they become public. I have figured out the reason is to avoid vote piling while keeping transparency.
- hnzix 7y agoI miss being able to see up vs downvotes per post. With only the total displayed, it feels like only the hivemind opinion wins out.
- mbesto 7y ago> People just really need that dopamine hit of seeing their points go up. In other words, people are naturally vain.
- jvagner 7y agoIt’s hard to notice those who don’t care.
- ALittleLight 7y agoI've often wondered about a reddit like site that just egregiously and unapologetically showed fake metrics to make it look like people loved your comments and read them, regardless of the truth. You might have to do it a bit randomly to keep people guessing or enjoying the tension, but just make a large chance of hitting the karma jackpot from a comment slot machine - it might make people feel happier.
- philpem 7y agoWhat about a variant of shadowbanning? You can't see your real scores, but everyone else can.
- ohduran 7y agoThis makes sense to me, perfect sense. Removing metrics would reduce engagement, and that's all that matters.