5 ms·
Why do people say antifragile instead of robust?
by mywittyname 7y ago
Why do people say antifragile instead of robust?
- DuskStar 7y agoIMO it's the difference between a really strong piece of ceramic that happens to not break when you whack it with a hammer, and something like safety glass that shatters yet stays intact. The ceramic is robust, but with a big enough whack it'll shatter into a million pieces - but the fragility of the safety glass is known and prepared for to the point where it breaking doesn't lead to a complete failure.
- twic 7y agoSounds smarter.
- rwallace 7y agoBecause they mean different things. A robust system is one that can tolerate stress without suffering much harm. An antifragile system is one that actually benefits from stress.
- kgermino 7y agoDuskStar is pretty close. Anti-fragile describes systems that improve from disorder. Robust describes ones that resist disorder. The ceramic plate is robust: it’s very strong, and unlikely to break when things go wrong (e.g. it gets dropped). But it’s not anti-fragile, it will never be made better by dropping, at best it won’t get worse. The petrol market in Puerto Rico is anti-fragile because the disorder of small power failures made it better, they added backup power so that the system would be more robust next time the power went out.
- mywittyname 7y agoI discovered that this is the titular concept behind a popular self-help/philosophy book.