4 ms·
I think your point was that "middle aged women" don't know any of this. No. The web (and computers) should adapt to us, humans. Not the other way around. If pe
by rmc 16y ago
I think your point was that "middle aged women" don't know any of this.
No. The web (and computers) should adapt to us, humans. Not the other way around. If people want to search for a question, then that's the correct way to search.
The reason 'spammy' sites show up high for that query is because they are better at knowing what people are searching for.
- bambax 16y agoBut that is not true of any other human activity. Every human activity is learned. The correct way to eat is not to throw handfuls of food towards your face, hoping that some will end in your mouth. That is how toddlers eat, until they are taught otherwise. The correct way to write is not to scribble on a table with the wrong end of the pen. Etc. Yet you argue that the correct way to use a search engine should be "how you do it when you first try it and don't know anything about it". This is inconsistent with what you have been doing since you were born.
- rmc 16y agoThe examples you cite are mostly about physical actions (e.g. eating), your advice to adapt yourself to the world is sound because we can't change how the world and physics and matter work. However a search engine is a totally non-physical thing. Software has no body and essentially no limits like a pen does. We can make software do anything we want (almost). We can try to make software that understand how people ask questions. That's what we should do. A better example would be languages. They are entirely intellectual and change all the time. Don't like speaking a certain way? Then change it, and it might take off! No reason to limit us all to Latin, we've invented all the other languages.
- bambax 16y ago> We can make software do anything we want (almost). We can build new software to do anything we want (if we know how to program). But some individual somewhere cannot have Google behave in some specific way. In that sense Google is very much a physical object of the world.
- oostevo 16y ago> We can build new software to do anything we want ... I'm being really pedantic here, but you actually can't. There are actually uncountably which are impossible to solve with an algorithm. There's a (by necessity) incomplete list of examples at: [1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_undecidable_problems http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_undecidable_problems [Edited for clarity.]
- shpxnvz 16y agoBut that is not true of any other human activity. Every human activity is learned. And most of those learned activities are eventually replaced by better ones. People learned that the right way to portion food was by tearing with their hands until someone invented the knife. People learned that the right way to draw was with a stick in the dirt until someone invented paper. What you think is the right way to do anything is only that because you haven't discovered or been taught a better way to do it, and that includes searching the internet. Yet you argue that the correct way to use a search engine should be "how you do it when you first try it and don't know anything about it". Actually, I think the argument is that a good way to be successful in business is by offering your customers more perceived value than your competitors. In search engines, it's more valuable for your users to not have to learn how your algorithm works in order to craft a search query that will satisfy their needs. It's valuable to be able to use natural language to search. Right or wrong, the business that refuses to provide that value because they disagree with it is going to fail miserably.
- bambax 16y agoI totally, completely and unconditionaly agree with your last point: it is absolutely in the best interests of Google to respond to every query with relevant results, however it's formulated. If 99% of Google users ask Google questions like they would a person, then Google should be able to provide answers; that is true even if only 10% of users used it that way. My point however is not about Google: it is about the user. The user would gain from learning how search engines work, and formulate their queries accordingly. It's often stated that users shouldn't be bothered to learn how to use your service, because "they have more important things to do" and "there are other services to choose from". This is good advice for businesses (common sense, really); it is bad business to expect users to dedicate time and effort to use your system. But I have a hard time accepting that this is an excuse for users to ever learn anything. At the same time as it is Google's responsibility to serve users as best it can, it is each user's responsibility to try to improve their mastery of such tools.
- tripzilch 16y ago> In search engines, it's more valuable for your users to not have to learn how your algorithm works in order to craft a search query that will satisfy their needs. Well, yes. But in this case it's not an algorithm. You just ask it for documents containing your search terms. It's about as straightforward as it gets. It's not computer programming, it's not even doing long divisions or whatever. You can't seriously assume that method of searching is going to completely stump anyone. > It's valuable to be able to use natural language to search. Maybe you're forgetting here that not the entire world speaks English. Unless your natural language search engine is able to understand nearly every language in the world, you're still forcing the users to formulate a query in English. And I'm willing to argue that for, say, your average middle-aged German, formulating a query in English is going to pose a much bigger problem than doing a conjunctive term search, as the latter carries transparently to most languages in the world. (not all of them--I should check which ones btw--but even in those cases it's not nearly as difficult to find a fix for that than it would be to somehow port your brilliant semantic context analysis engine to be able to speak yet another completely different language). Give it a couple of decades, maybe we'll have usable NLP then, but before that time, I am convinced that even for the layman, searching for documents to contain certain terms is a lot more straightforward, likely to yield desired results and in quite a few ways actually easier to use than what has to pass for NLP currently.
- tripzilch 16y agoI'd agree with you, if we were talking about something that is even slightly complicated. But it's not. Searching with the old-school Google syntax is asking the question "what documents contain these words X Y Z?". It's not that hard, in fact very easy, to wrap your head around that. It's easier than looking up a phonenumber in the phonebook, or a business in the Yellow Pages. It's even easier than using the term index in the back of a book. While asking a question might be easier than that still, it also has disadvantages. It's impossible to ask an exact question on a very specific subject. Try it in real life. You'll find you need context, or at least a series of back and forth questions to arrive at the answer you want to have. If a search engine would implement the same method, any advantage from using questions over a conjunction of terms is negated. People would get tired of typing long question phrases, and unless the natural language processing of the search engine is absolutely perfect, they'd get pretty frustrated quickly because the search engine would interpret some of the questions wrongly. For simple queries like "where can i find a recipe for blueberry pie?" or "what is the capital of Denmark?", we already have seen search engines can do this pretty well. For anything more complicated, they fail sometimes, if not most of the time. It's not that hard for people to search "recipe blueberry pie" or "capital Denmark" as you think, either. People can get used to barking commands like this quite easily. Look at Star Trek ("earl grey, hot") or many other scifi series featuring a semi-intelligent computer. People almost expect it to communicate in terse phrases like that. The big advantage, also for the layman, is that a conjunctive term query will nearly always yield the result they were expecting, because it doesn't leave much room for ambiguity. And if it does, it's when query terms hit a range of documents that weren't intended, but still match, again I refer to scifi, as well as fantasy, it may be frustrating, but it's also somewhat endearing (putting the user in a position of superiority) in the sense of an intelligent robot taking a request too literally. Or a genie in a bottle. Or an ET alien. Or commander Data. Or whatever. On the other hand, if the computer interprets a full question in the wrong way, people get more annoyed, because the "too literal" explanation doesn't work here, after all, you typed a complete sentence, it should be obvious what you meant, right? So instead, people get the idea that the computer is simply not listening. And that makes it a lot harder to come up with a "better" question that would give them the answer they need. Now, of course, as soon as search engines are able to do perfect language processing, as well as guessing a whole lot of additional clues from whatever bits of context they can get, typing questions into a search engine might be the better and easiest way. But natural language processing isn't really going there any time soon. Just look at the search engines that try this, how well they are doing now compared to how well they were doing 5 years ago, and there's not much progress made. On the other hand, in the area of text-query processing, organising of data, cataloguing data, we have made tons and tons of progress. There's tagging, social network friends recommendation, and vastly superior methods of indexing large amounts of text documents for logical queries.