3 ms·
And yet some people manage to whip themselves in to a righteous frenzy over someone collecting welfare or immigrants getting a microscopic bit of state aid. Su
by pmoriarty 7y ago
And yet some people manage to whip themselves in to a righteous frenzy over someone collecting welfare or immigrants getting a microscopic bit of state aid.
Such people really need to get a sense of proportion.
The destitute, despised, downtrodden guy who slaves away to support their family by mowing your lawn, picking apples for you, driving you somewhere, or serving you your burger is not your enemy.
- davinic 7y agoLast week I saw a person on Facebook sharing an anecdote patterned after the "welfare queen" trope and arguing against food stamps. I noticed from her Facebook page that she owned a ranching operation, so I searched her name in the EWG Farm Subsidy Database and saw that she and her husband had received $18k in subsidies in 2018, and nearly $250k since 1995.
- adventist 7y agoI'm against people living off of food stamps also, and if there is a subsidy out there for the taking, then i'm going to take it. I agree that government should not be involved in either of those things, but promoting certain kinds of businesses might be worth the subsidy for some people.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoWould you be against other people getting the subsidy? I'm just trying to figure out if it's hypocrisy or selfishness.
- nerdponx 7y agoWhy not both?
- dlp211 7y agoThanks for wanting to make sure I didn't have dinner on my table as a child while my mom took care of my brother with leukemia.
- refurb 7y agoIs your logic that a dollar is a dollar and it doesn't matter why the government gave it to them? If so, I don't agree.
- ausbah 7y agoWhat are you trying to say? He is remarking on the ignorance / hypocrisy of the woman, who laments when other people receiving government subsidies as "welfare queens" disregarding the fact that she is also receiving government subsidies. Likely due to her own biases, that her subsidy is worthwhile while another person's isn't for whatever reason.
- refurb 7y agoNot all government subsidies are the same. Someone could say farm subsidies are good while welfare is bad. That's not hypocritical.
- HNcantBtrustd 7y ago> not my enemy But we have an adversial relationship. If they are successful, they take our money, and get it for nothing. So if they win, I lose. Compared to a company, who's trying to create new useful products and services. Everyone wins with this interaction. There is multithousand year old history on the effect of subsidies. They hurt at least as much as they help.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"Everyone wins with this interaction." There is ample evidence about who is winning in the current system: a tiny minority of extremely wealthy people. Nearly everyone else is turning in to their servants, and nearly everything is coming to be owned and controlled by them. Is that the world you want you, your children, and their children to live in?
- SketchySeaBeast 7y ago> There is multithousand year old history on the effect of subsidies. They hurt at least as much as they help. Citation needed. I assume you're cool with all government subsidies stopping then? No more farmer bailouts, or fossil fuel subsidies? No more emergency relief? Next time wall street tanks, it tanks hard?
- Spellman 7y agoNot to mention most are paying taxes as well (via ITIN) and aren't qualified to receive certain benefits.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]