3 ms·
I suspect that the effective techniques are known (or "known") to some practitioners, but buried among a pile of ineffective techniques, with different people s
by lmm 7y ago
I suspect that the effective techniques are known (or "known") to some practitioners, but buried among a pile of ineffective techniques, with different people swearing by different techniques based on their experiences. Similar to how traditional medicine can be a mixture of genuinely important treatments for local medical circumstances and completely ineffective treatments that happened to be (spuriously) correlated with good outcomes.
You're quite right about how it looks from the outside; the possibility that I'm just experiencing my own set of spurious correlations is real and worrying. But ultimately there's only so far that I'm willing to overrule my own lived experience.
I wish I shared your confidence about future progress. There have been good and bad managers, and good and bad communicators, for decades, but we don't seem much closer to a generally understood method that can be applied by everyone.