4 ms·
rationals, because they are continuous (in that you can always get closer...) You sort of can't get arbitrarily close. And that's the whole reason calculus doe
by nerdponx 7y ago
rationals, because they are continuous (in that you can always get closer...)
You sort of can't get arbitrarily close. And that's the whole reason calculus doesn't work for rationals.
Rationals fundamentally have "gaps", and correspond 1:1 with integers.
- jpmattia 7y ago> You sort of can't get arbitrarily close. Is there an obvious concrete example? I've never spent proper time studying Real Analysis, and I confess I have the same intuition as OP: That you could use rationals to approximate irrationals to arbitrary precision.
- throw_away_1979 7y agoNo, because that's not true, see e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirichlet%27s_approximation_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirichlet%27s_approximation_th... TL;DR: Every real number can be approximated by rationals. GP was being careless with language.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThe operative words there are "sort of". You can in fact get arbitrarily close. Just as you can with other sets of numbers, like those the form m/10^n (decimal approximations), or the numbers tan(n) where n is an integer.
- gianduja 7y agoYou're right, you can. What's special about real numbers is that, if you have a sequence of reals for which the distance between two consecutive elements approaches zero, then there exists a real number that's the limit of the starting sequence. This isn't the case with rational numbers, eg. the sequence 1.4, 1.41, 1.414 ... (EDIT: these are increasing approximations of sqrt(2)) satisfies the hypothesis but there's no single rational number this sequence approaches. This property is called completeness. The real numbers are a complete topological space, whereas the rationals aren't.
- Someone 7y agoReals have “gaps”, too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number#Overview: ”There are also representations like { 0, 1, 2, 3, … | } = ω { 0 | 1, 1/2, 1/4, 1/8, … } = ε where ω is a transfinite number greater than all integers and ε is an infinitesimal greater than 0 but less than any positive real number.” So, ε is a gap just above zero, π-ε a gap just below π, etc. (The difference is that, when stepping from real to real, you won’t accidentally step on a surreal in the way you’ll frequently hit irrationals when you step from rational to rational)
- alanbernstein 7y agoThese seem like "indefinite" numbers, that don't have a value in the same way as rationals or reals. Is there any truth to that intuition? Can you do calculus with surreal numbers?
- Someone 7y agoArithmetic and even exponentiation are doable (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number#Exponential_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number#Exponential_fun...) I’ve never seen derivatives or integrals, but https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/112492/integral-of-a-function-defined-in-the-set-of-surreal-numbers https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/112492/integral-of-... claims one can define them.
- AimHere 7y agoThe surreals are actually a problem in this context. As far as I'm aware, nobody's yet come up with a satisfying integral calculus that works in the surreal numbers generally. Maybe you have to leave those gaps unfilled.