13 ms·
It's not just about speed but about time. I value my time. Yeah, I may not saturate my gigabit line, but when I only have to wait 1 minute for a 3GB MacOS upd
by jedberg 7y ago
It's not just about speed but about time. I value my time. Yeah, I may not saturate my gigabit line, but when I only have to wait 1 minute for a 3GB MacOS update instead of 20, that's valuable to me. It's worth the expense of having a mostly idle gigabit line.
Also I definitely saturate my gigabit link on download all the time, and sometimes on upload too, but I realize I'm not the average person in that regard.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoLatency makes a big difference too. Using the internet on a symmetric fiber connection with sub 5ms latency is way better than a coax connection split between 1,000 homes with a few hundred ms ping.
- Paul-ish 7y agoThis may just bolster the researcher's point. That more than speed matters. What really matters it the performance of things on the application layer.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoMaybe, but most US households don't even have the "bandwidth" that they say are advertised as getting. Just because Comcast says you are getting 200mbps doesn't mean you are, it's probably just boosting it temporarily and allocating it from other houses in the neighborhood. And the uploads are laughable, try having multiple FaceTime video calls going in the same house, they degrade quite quickly because they barely have a solid 2mbps upload. Also, behind all these NATs and blocked ports, the whole system is designed to not be used. Update it so everyone has strong connections with consistent bandwidth and low latency with IPv6 and perhaps we would see more possibilities with home internet use.
- penagwin 7y agoComcast's 150mbps down includes 10mbps up - it's not terrible for one or two people but as a power user I had to upgrade to 450down/20up. The upload is so pathetic because cable doesn't have symmetric bandwidth, you have to choose if you want more download channels or more upload channels. Most households don't need much upload, thus the ratio. 10mbps up is a minimum requirement for me though IMO.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIf it's not fiber to the home, I don't believe the advertised numbers. Most households don't need a garbage coax connection that can't provide a consistent bandwidth, but imagine if households had decent connections. Then you can create hardware and software that let people host their own media and backup their own devices, instead of handing it over to giant corporations with government backdoors.
- penagwin 7y ago> Then you can create hardware and software that let people host their own media and backup their own devices, instead of handing it over to giant corporations with government backdoors. Actually low upload bandwidth makes it harder to give 3rd parties data :P Question, does AT&T fiber do fiber all the way to the home? Because I know one of my family members has their fiber offering, but they have serious bandwidth issues around normally busy hours - suggesting even with fiber they're over provisioned.
- sseveran 7y agoThey do have installations of Fiber all the way into the box in your home. I don't know if that is uniform although I assume it would be. And of course they are over provisioned.
- vel0city 7y agoFTTH != dedicated fiber. Most residential fiber is a shared service based around passive optical networks which will turn one fiber line into many endpoints for residential customers. Poorly managed PONs can give poor performance. That said, AT&T has been selling their U-Verse FTTN (fiber to the node) service as "fiber home internet" for many years now. This is still based around DSL technologies but have fiber terminated much closer to the house than at a central office. If they're not on a Gigapower plan with a true optical network terminal inside their house, they probably don't actually have fiber.
- compsciphd 7y agoi had comcast 250mb down package for years. I could easily download 2TB a day for multiple days straight without a problem. In fact, there were times I did.
- eloisant 7y agoNot sure how it works in US, but in France when you get FTTH, you actually get GPON which means that you don't have your own fiber between your home and the central office. The central office is connected by a single fiber to a spliter that services up to 64 homes. So when you buy 1Gpbs internet, it actually goes through a 2.5GBps fiber shared with up to 63 other houses.
- Phenomenit 7y agoMy regular 100/100 line downloads 3Gb in five minutes. The difference in my life is miniscule compared to a gigabit line. Also the gigabit line requires hardware all the way to achieve the promised speed.
- pathartl 7y agoWhen you're talking about 3GB, sure. If you look at video games, a lot of your AAA games are coming in at 12-70GB or even 100GB. Certain games (I'm looking at you PUBG) also don't optimize their updates, so some updates can be upwards of 10-15GB. Once you get into that realm time really does become a factor. I'm on 400/25 and I always dread installing Battlefield 4 after a fresh install. I think it's around 60-70GB right now and takes around 45 minutes to get everything downloaded.
- montecarl 7y agoToo bad steam has trouble hitting even 100mbit/s on my gig fiber connection. In fact I find that many services seem to throttle at exactly 100mbit/s, e.g. Dropbox.
- penagwin 7y agoI had this exact issue then found out either my cable or port on my router was bad, and was only initiating a 100mbps link. Steam can hit 40MBps (over 300mbps) regularly for me. I find what you say to be true though, most services can't saturate my link - but I'd double check because exactly 100mbps is suspicious. Also don't use speedtest.net, try fast.com (run by netflix) - ISPS are known to "cheat" on speedtest.net (they can host a speedtest server inside their network) but fast.com downloads actual movie fragments from netflix's cdn.
- pathartl 7y agoMight need to check something out. I saturate my 400mbit connection. Now PSN on the other hand... last time I used it Sony artificially limited it to something like 20mbit.
- 7y ago
- owenmarshall 7y agoHave you amortized the value of that time over 24 hours? I'm probably not going to apply that MacOS update until the weekend, so I can download it at 3AM. I don't care if it takes 2 minutes or 20 minutes (or, heck, 200 minutes!) to download season three of The Wire as long as I can start episode one "quickly enough" because the rest will follow.
- jedberg 7y agoThe point is I don't want to wait. For example, Firefox broke in update 5, and I really need Firefox to work for some testing. So I can't put off that update until night. That's just a small example, but not having to plan my life around large downloads is in and of itself a benefit of the fast connection.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoOn-demand is a term for a reason.
- gfo 7y agoI don't disagree with you, but I think most HN readers are power users. In the context of this article, I feel like most readers don't fall into this category and probably aren't getting that amount of return on their higher speed investments. Though, your comment brings up an interesting point - I wonder if internet speeds would play a factor in getting more users to run their updates? In general they're disruptive so there are other issues, but it could be part of the overall frustration. Personally, I have a fast connection so I rarely have this specific problem.
- mrguyorama 7y agoAnyone who plays video games on computer, ps4, or xbox one also regularly saturates their connection. Game updates are a daily occurrence on Steam for me (mostly because I have hundreds of games) and giant updates are normal on console
- zelon88 7y agoI'd beg to differ, especially if your console or PC is networked wirelessly. 802.11n can only do 600mbps in the best conditions. Residential gig pipes are not uncommon anymore. I've seen some ridiculous download speeds from Steam, but never enough to saturate my gig pipe even during a full game installation. I just can't see Steam providing that kind of bandwidth to it's users when the filesizes can get upwards of 50gigs. They would DDOS themselves.
- kcb 7y agoI regularly see consistent 80 - 90 MB/s from Steam downloads. CDNs are powerful things.
- vel0city 7y agoThe Steam client starts to throttle its network throughput based on disk performance these days. I've got games installed on SSDs and on spinning rust, and I'll see download speeds back off on the spinning rust while it unpacks files despite there being plenty of resources to cache files otherwise. This is very different from the times where it would attempt to download everything first and then begin to unpack files.
- nothrabannosir 7y agoNot sure if this matters for your overall point, but mac os updates are downloaded asynchronously, it's their installation that locks up your computer for 20 minutes. Sounds like an inconsequential detail, but I can't readily think of any recent experience where I actually did have to wait for a download to finish before I could continue doing anything. Most things are either streaming or background, nowadays. Perhaps Steam?
- CydeWeys 7y agoI find that most updates silently download in the background, then I just choose when to install them. So I don't actually notice my downlink speed.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoThis is why we should not be paying for speed/bandwidth, but be paying for data usage. Internet carriers should deliver traffic at the fastest speed possible all the time, and then just charge us for how much we use their network. What we've become accustomed to in home internet pricing goes by another name for mobile carriers: throttling.
- goda90 7y agoPaying for bandwidth is simple and straightforward. You don't accidentally exceed your bandwidth and suddenly have to pay out the nose because some application wasn't behaving like you expected. I can imagine a lot more ways that ISPs can get tricky with pricing on data usage as opposed to bandwidth involving peek time pricing, zero rating some usage(as opposed to "fast lanes")etc. It just feels dystopian and bad for consumers.
- ryanmercer 7y ago>You don't accidentally exceed your bandwidth and suddenly have to pay out the nose because some application wasn't behaving like you expected. Just think of all the crypto mining out there for example, imagine how many people could accidentally allow crypto mining software to be installed and all of that data being transferred for half a month and then BAM big bill. Or someone makes malware that just transfers junk data purely to rack up data charges for kicks, or worse someone at an ISP does it to boost earnings or because they hate their employer and want them to eventually get 'caught doing it'.
- xur17 7y ago> Just think of all the crypto mining out there for example, imagine how many people could accidentally allow crypto mining software to be installed and all of that data being transferred for half a month and then BAM big bill. Not to deride your point, but crypto mining typically uses very little data since you only need the data contained in the block header, and don't need all of the transactions.
- rolltiide 7y agoYeah I have mixed experience with that. I get some surprisingly fast downloads on my 1 gbps line+wifi But then redownloading a non-new game from playstation network goes only a few mbps, and my playstation 4 is the only wired connection I maintained Some of the services that you would think have highly connected CDNs or could leverage multi participant torrent like downloads just... dont? Games are like 40gb+ these days but I still expected it to take 20 minutes Any way thats what I’m paying a premium for Spoil me
- rhino369 7y agoHow much time do you think the average person actually spends waiting for a download? Most of my software updates run in the background. Xbox/Steam is the only thing I notice downloading and I usually just play a different game if it needs a big update. Work is the only reason I pay for 300mbps. Otherwise, 100mbps would be more than enough for me. Upload is where I really feel the lack of bandwith. I don't have fiber avaialable at my new apartment, and the cable companies only offer 20-25 mbps upload. Hard to run a plex server for my parents and inlaws with that little bandwidth.
- raldi 7y agoI bet you sometimes drive your car at less than the maximum speed, too.
- egdod 7y agoI guess, but how often are you really sitting there waiting for the update? It downloads in the background.