3 ms·
Is that really the thing keep people from making their own rockets? Red tape? > This action would also enable flexible timeframes, remove unnecessary ground s
by SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
Is that really the thing keep people from making their own rockets? Red tape?
> This action would also enable flexible timeframes, remove unnecessary ground safety regulations, redefine when launch begins to allow specified pre-flight operations prior to license approval, and allow applicants to seek a license to launch from multiple sites.
I feel as though we do want careful and deliberate launches. After all, this IS rocket science.
> remove unnecessary ground safety regulations
Hmm.
- aidenn0 7y agoThere is a cost-benefit trade-off for any regulation. If the non-regulatory costs of rocket launches are decreasing significantly, then it is worth revisiting the regulatory costs; what makes sense for 5-6 launches per year might not make sense for 50 launches per year.
- bkor 7y agoRegulation and regulation costs are different things. Further, comparing costs incurred for business vs regulation costs seems odd. Regulation should be there for a reason. Just skimping on that because some other cost changed seems arbitrary. Further, I fail to see why you cannot optimize on the regulation cost; you can do this without changing the regulations. Another way of looking at costs: eased regulations vs long time investigations and associated costs when something goes wrong due to eased regulations.
- aidenn0 7y agoI don't know what the FAA regulations are, but here's an example of how a regulation can incur unnecessary costs: If the regulation requires hand-inspecting part X and someone invents a machine to inspect part X, you are now incurring costs solely due to regulation. The above is somewhat orthogonal to my main point. If you inspect something 10 times, then it is marginally safer than if you inspect something 9 times, and so on and so forth. Everything can be made more expensive and safer or less expensive and less safe. If there are benefits of increased spaceflight that exceed the downsides of the reduced safety, and lowering the costs will encourage such increased spaceflight then it makes sense from a policy point of view to reduce the safety. This is in addition to the point that regulatory compliance tend to increase costs by more than the amount needed to increase the safety (my example of hand-inspecting a part that could be machine inspected is one example; paying someone to check up that the regulations are actually being followed is another).
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoYou'd think once you scaled up to 50 launches per year your process would as well.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoWhen the critical path of your process is a government agency that is doing 10x more work than it used to (with only 50% more staff), there's only so many ways you can optimize your process without making compromises in other areas like schedule.
- imglorp 7y agoThe FARs seem to follow a consistent philosophy. Prime directive is don't hurt innocent people uninvolved with your adventure. In the case of rockets this has to mean launch windows that don't intersect with air traffic and plans to avoid dropping burning boosters full of fuel into playgrounds. Second directive is try not to kill your friends and employees. After that, if it's just you, you can have a lot of leeway as long as the paperwork is in order.
- londons_explore 7y agoI'd actually like to see it even slacker than this. Do what you want, but if you kill someone, you're gonna have to pay a big fine to the government, and you're going to have to have insurance to pay that fine if you go bankrupt. Then the only question is how big should the fine be - and the FAA should set that to trade off safety vs progress. Let's start at $250M per life lost. Insurance for that would probably work out to ~10 million per launch, given current accident rates.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoSo now it becomes a cost / benefit analysis, and the loss of life is just the cost of doing business? Apparently a SpaceX launch is $57 million dollars. Given that you've massively reduced the regulations - if the red tape is in fact large enough to be a pain and the FAA is justified in reducing it to spur innovation, I bet you've saved that $10 million right there - totally worth it. Keep the deaths to a mostly low number, adjust insurance as needed, and you're golden! No more letting the price of a human life get in the way of private enterprise!
- rwcarlsen 7y agoIt is always possible anywhere in uncountable ways to spend money to save lives. Whether you like the idea or not, we all make trade-off decisions about money vs lives every day.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
- Rebelgecko 7y agoThere's a lot of busywork in the regulations. For example, the requirements for expendable and reusable rockets were written very independently, so if you want to re-license an existing expendable rocket to be reusable you basically have to start from scratch. The desire from a lot of the smaller launch providers is to have a set of generic "rocket" requirements, with specific addendums for where expendable and reusable vehicles differ. There's also a lot of redundancies when you want to launch a vehicle from multiple locations. If you want a second launch site, there's reasonable things you have to do like showing the FAA that your flight termination system won't rain flaming hydrazine into someone's backyard. However, you also have to expend effort re-explaining things that are totally location independent, like your software development methodologies.