5 ms·
> [how do i make a blueberry pie] You know very well that this is not how search works. You don't "ask a question" to the search engine like you would ask your
by bambax 16y ago
> [how do i make a blueberry pie]
You know very well that this is not how search works. You don't "ask a question" to the search engine like you would ask your grandmother.
You type in words that you expect to be in the pages you're looking for, and the search engine lists pages that actually contain ALL of those words.
One of the main improvements of Google in the very early days was that it used the AND operand by default, whereas competing search engines used OR by default, resulting in an incredible amount of noise.
In essence, searching for "how do i make a blueberry pie" (with quotes) should return only spam, because only spammy and SEO optimized sites would contain the phrase as such. A real recipe would maybe contain the phrase "how TO make a blueberry pie" but not "how do i..."
- - -
I think your point was that "middle aged women" don't know any of this.
It would be arguable (probably wrong, but still) that people who don't know this, who didn't make the effort to understand a little how all of this works, deserve the spam they get.
There is a good way to discriminate between good and bad content, and that is to know a little about what you're searching in order to search for words that will be present in good quality content and NOT in spammy pages.
For example, it's reasonnable to expect a good recipe to give instructions in metric system as well as imperial; if you add "celsius" to the search then the second (informative) recipe arrives first:
http://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+make+blueberry+pie+celsius http://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+make+blueberry+pie+cel...
- patio11 16y agoI think your point was that "middle aged women" don't know any of this. No. That is overbroad, untrue, and would be very injurious to my professional reputation. I said that the Internet is skewed away from producing content responsive to their needs, which is about as controversial as saying that they are slightly underrepresented on HN relative to, I don't know, twenty-something males. Non-technical users frequently use natural language search. The experience for natural language search is fairly poor. There are many classes of search which offer poor experience, but it is the one which leaps to my head first because I deal with non-technical users every day. people who don't know this, who didn't make the effort to understand a little how all of this works, deserve the spam they get. Words cannot express the depth of my distaste for this position. I will accept that "Google screwed up" or "I screwed up" if one of my users has a suboptimal Internet experience (which starts at Google because Google is the Internet and ideally ends at my site), but I cannot accept that she is responsible if she has a poor user experience. We've got the teams of PhDs, the highly paid SEO consultants, and the lifetime of building an accurate mental model of how the devil box works. She wants to teach kids to read, not learn magic incantations. It should -- "should" in the sense of "would be optimal for the business", "would be optimal for society", and "as a moral imperative for computing professionals" -- just work for her.
- bambax 16y ago(I really don't understand your first/second sentence (what's injurious?) Also, I'm 40.) > I will accept that "Google screwed up" (...) if one of my users has a suboptimal Internet experience I respect that, and from a business point of view you're very right. The problem is, how do you improve her experience without screwing up mine? Why can't I search for pages that actually contain all the words I'm looking for, as I typed them, and not words "that were present in the page linking to this page" or words Google think I want although I didn't type them in? From a "moral" point of view (which you brought up), if she "wants to teach kids to read" maybe she could start by learning how to spell?
- bambax 16y agoI don't know why the above comment is being downvoted, but I'm guessing it's because it sounds "elitist" (which is apparently a very great crime). To elaborate, then: I agree with the parent comment that it's Google's job to make everyone's experience optimal (and not the user's), and it's certainly in the best interests of Google (or any business) to cater to the needs of as many of its customers as possible (although in the case of Google, as has been pointed out many times before, users are in fact the product). But I would argue that the real elitists are people who think "middle aged women" shouldn't be expected to actually learn how to use machines. "Middle aged women" (why single them out?) use machines all the time, whether at work or at home. They're expected to know how to use a spreadsheet, a word processor, a food processor. And they do. But somehow this expectation is lifted for "the Internet". Why? A search engine is not a person; it's certainly not a mind reader. A search engine is just a machine.
- ghshephard 16y agoThe objective is Clarke's third law: "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." The winner in search will be the one who strives for that. If _I_ were presented with "How do I cook a blueberry Pie" - I would immediately do the following search: http://www.foodnetwork.com/search/delegate.do?fnSearchString=Blueberry+Pie&fnSearchType=site http://www.foodnetwork.com/search/delegate.do?fnSearchString... Plus a few other pre-eminent and trusted food-networks (Allrecipes) - searching for "Blueberry Pie" on each one, I'd then scan the quality of the comments - looking for insight into other chefs (cross checking their history to see if they, in turn, can be trusted) who clearly have tried out the recipes, and have made relevant comments. I would then identify the recipe that looked most likely to work for me. I would expect no less from a sufficiently advanced search engine in this, and all other domains.
- andrew1 16y ago> You type in words that you expect to be in the pages you're looking for, and the search engine lists pages that actually contain ALL of those words. It's not as simple as that though is it? Otherwise how would those GoogleBombs or whatever they're called work where searching for 'warmongering idiot' or something turn up George Bush's biography on whitehouse.gov. I think search result quality is a bit more involved than just testing whether a page contains a set of words.
- bambax 16y ago> I think search result quality is a bit more involved than just testing whether a page contains a set of words Google bombs work because Google includes in the words of the current page, words in the links leading to the page (inside the anchor), and even, I believe, words in the page linking to the current page, outside of the link itself. And then fields are weighted to calculate relevance. Those long, long urls with the title of the page in the url started to appear and proliferate when people noticed that words in the url were given an important boost factor by Google. This broke the Internet a little, by the way. That's why we need links shorteners now, with urls containing whole goddamn paragraphs.
- brc 16y ago"You don't "ask a question" to the search engine like you would ask your grandmother." It doesn't matter one jot 'how search works'. What matters is how the majority of their users think it works. And they think it works by asking a question. So publishers need to work with that.
- bambax 16y agoYou're right, and yet I disagree with you (which I guess means I'm wrong). Your position is the path of least resistance: indulge users in their ignorance. It's optimized for the short term, and in other contexts leads to great catastrophes (fast food, for example).
- Waywocket 16y agoI wish I could find a link to an article I was reading a while back, which pointed out that most users who actually use search engines beyond typing 'facebook login' every morning work out how to search within a couple of weeks at most. Given that, it seems like a bad idea to optimise for the first week at the expense of every day for the next few years. Sadly, I have no idea where I found that and don't recall if they had any factual data to back it up :(.
- rmc 16y agoI think your point was that "middle aged women" don't know any of this. No. The web (and computers) should adapt to us, humans. Not the other way around. If people want to search for a question, then that's the correct way to search. The reason 'spammy' sites show up high for that query is because they are better at knowing what people are searching for.
- bambax 16y agoBut that is not true of any other human activity. Every human activity is learned. The correct way to eat is not to throw handfuls of food towards your face, hoping that some will end in your mouth. That is how toddlers eat, until they are taught otherwise. The correct way to write is not to scribble on a table with the wrong end of the pen. Etc. Yet you argue that the correct way to use a search engine should be "how you do it when you first try it and don't know anything about it". This is inconsistent with what you have been doing since you were born.
- rmc 16y agoThe examples you cite are mostly about physical actions (e.g. eating), your advice to adapt yourself to the world is sound because we can't change how the world and physics and matter work. However a search engine is a totally non-physical thing. Software has no body and essentially no limits like a pen does. We can make software do anything we want (almost). We can try to make software that understand how people ask questions. That's what we should do. A better example would be languages. They are entirely intellectual and change all the time. Don't like speaking a certain way? Then change it, and it might take off! No reason to limit us all to Latin, we've invented all the other languages.
- bambax 16y ago> We can make software do anything we want (almost). We can build new software to do anything we want (if we know how to program). But some individual somewhere cannot have Google behave in some specific way. In that sense Google is very much a physical object of the world.
- halostatue 16y agoI am reasonably search-savvy, and when I am starting to research something out of my comfort zone, I often start with a "how do I…" search. I sometimes find exactly what I need with it, but more often I get enough information to perform other, better searches. Your assumption that people don't search that way is dead wrong, though: I've seen many non-technical people do just that sort of search. My mother being one. I know: the plural of anecdote is not data and all, but I'm fairly certain most people don't think of search the way you suggest.