2 ms·
> Where is "here"? For reference, in America, the best private schools can cost almost as much as the salary of a minimum-wage worker. That's part of how they m
by alkonaut 7y ago
> Where is "here"? For reference, in America, the best private schools can cost almost as much as the salary of a minimum-wage worker. That's part of how they maintain such high staff-to-student ratio and such individualized curricula.
"Here" is Sweden in this case, but there are similar examples.
> You said "publicly funded", not "run by the government".
That's a detail of implementation for both schools and healthcare. Interestingly, Sweden has a lot of private schools in 1-12 but few private higher educations. In both cases the funds are coming from public money, so the 1-12 schools are voucher based.
> That's part of how they maintain such high staff-to-student ratio and such individualized curricula.
My kid's school (6y atm) is private. But I can't pay any more to get higher staff-to-student ratio in another school. The school gets the voucher for my kid so they have the same funds as every other school, public or private. If I want to spend money on my kids primary school I could buy an evening tutor of course (no one stops me) - but I basically you can't start a school where you accept money from parents to provide a more expensive education. The law says no fees can be charged for the education, nor for applications. Further it says that donations to schools are allowed but cannot influence education nor applications.
> That kind of thing isn't justifiable from a "societal investment" point-of-view
It's a fine balance. I want to spend tax money on having a varied group of people educated in arts etc.
I think it's fine to pay tax money for someone else to study arts with absolutely no possibility of ever "repaying" society economically.
The alternative is that those who can afford to study stuff that doesn't pay (i.e. those with family money) are those that can study those subjects. I don't think that's an objectively better situation to be in.
> You're looking at people who attend college and enter the upper half of society, and attempting to say, "If everyone goes to college, everyone can enter the upper half of society!" Unfortunately, it's just that - a half. There are only so many jobs of that sort; college makes people more competitive applicants. You won't necessarily create more by creating more people who go to college.
Sure, but this is a political and ideological choice, such as "kids to low income parents should be as likely to end up with MD's as kids to high income parents". This isn't a practical choice. When I argue that publicly funded higher education is good, I'm arguing ideologically, not "practically". It won't be a more efficient society. It might improve our Gini but it won't necessarily improve our GDP, and so on.
Also: it's not like half the population has to du menial jobs and half can do white collar jobs. We used to have effectively 100% farmers just a century ago. Then an industrial society just 50 years ago. Not everyone can have a high tech job, but the variation of jobs in society is fluent and very much depends on the education level of the population.
It's not a zero sum game where the number of qualified jobs is fixed.
> And you are somewhat looking to establish "freedom from want"
Because the drive to provide healthcare and education for myself and my family is somehow a positive "force" that drives society and the economy (perhaps I misunderstood)?
Shouldn't that be evident in statistics, e.g. that happiness/quality of life indicators are somehow higher the more "want" there is?
All I can see is that they seem...lower
- big_chungus 7y ago> Sweden Again, how do you propose to spend as much money as the best private schools, per-student? It would actually be more, as public schools are vastly more inefficient. > That's a detail of implementation The right actually supports something like this with "school vouchers": you can choose where your child's tax dollars go to work. The left is for some bizarre reason opposed to this. > basically you can't start a school where you accept money from parents to provide a more expensive education Why? If I've got money to burn, why? Who cares what some one does with his money, if he's already payed taxes? What right have you to dictate how I spend my money? It's mine, not yours, you have no say how it's spent. > I think it's fine to pay tax money for someone else to study arts with absolutely no possibility of ever "repaing" society economically. All right, you think it's okay. I don't; that's not how I want to spend my money. Instead of trying to force me to do it too, why don't you just contribute to a charity that provides scholarships? Also, most college students spend a lot of time partying, drinking, etc. Why on God's green earth ought I to pay for that? > I'm arguing ideologically, not "practically". Ok, let's discuss ideology. At the end of the day, if you do not pay your taxes and do not show up in court, a bunch of guys will pull up in a black van, bust down your door, and haul you off to jail. If you resist, they might shoot you. This sort of force ought to be reserved for only serious cases. When you force someone to contribute tax, you force him to set aside any possible moral objections or personal issues with the threat of a gun. That threat underlies all the government's day-to-day authority. Such authority ought not to be used to force me to pay for someone spending four years skipping class and binge-drinking. In other words, the basic function of government is to protect my liberties. Forcing me to pay for the college of another does nothing towards this end. > it's not like half the population has to du menial jobs and half can do white collar jobs No, but all of the menial jobs must get done. You claim you want a society where a poor kid is just as likely as a rich one to become a doctor. How do you propose to achieve that? Even with "free" college, you will not achieve that. Poor kids do worse in school, worse in college. > It's not a zero sum game where the number of qualified jobs is fixed. No, but the number of qualified jobs will not expand nearly as much as the pool of qualified applicants. This is because by taxing people more to pay for this free college, you will reduce their income, giving them less to spend. This means you probably won't see much growth in the number of jobs, as the people who pay for things made by these "white-collar" jobs are the ones who you will be most taxing. You will have a large pool of college grads and a smaller pool of jobs; wages will tank. > Because the drive to provide healthcare and education for myself and my family is somehow a positive "force" that drives society and the economy (perhaps I misunderstood)? Shouldn't that be evident in statistics, e.g. that happiness/quality of life indicators are somehow higher the more "want" there is? All I can see is that they seem...lower You're not, say, seeking an extra job to get more for your family. You're trying to vote yourself other people's money to get more for your family. That's theft. With respect to statistics on quality of life: 1. You just said your argument was ideological, not practical. 2. The job of the government is not to make you "happy". It is to safeguard a few basic liberties, roughly outlined by our constitution.