5 ms·
> so long as someone is speaking their opinion respectfully and in good faith, it matters not what that opinion is; and that the defense of this necessitates a
by taneq 7y ago
> so long as someone is speaking their opinion respectfully and in good faith, it matters not what that opinion is; and that the defense of this necessitates a generous presumption of good faith
Isn't that the point of a discussion forum such as HN?
> I think it's reasonable to suggest that certain viewpoints are simply not welcome on Hacker News
I disagree that contrary viewpoints "no matter how eloquently stated" should be purged. Let them stand or fall on their merits.
- throwaway2048 7y agoWhat about calls to kill all jews, very reasonably and eloquently stated, still welcome? How about calls to have sex with children, still ok with you? What about support and calls for mass shootings, executions and genocide? What happens when supports for these views grow by virtue of them being in people's faces a lot? Plenty of internet communities have been hijacked by these mentalities, usually in some misguided idea about free speech. Giving disgusting bullshit a platform almost axiomatically elevates it, legitimizes it and creates support for it, pretending things are just a marketplace of ideas, and all we have to do is "be civil" is an almost total abdication of responsibility. Edit: how about the people down voting this answer if conversations, conducted civilly and in good faith, should be allowed about topics like this, if you are going to have a stance that nothing should barred, you better be able to think about and discuss what about the worst of the worst, not live in some fantasy land where people don't seriously believe some truly horrific things.
- sittingnut 7y agodo you understand the difference between calls for violence (such as "kill all jews", "have sex with children", etc), and non violent opinion, which may include hateful, racist, sexist speech(such as "jews control media and government", "average iq of various ethnic groups differ", "men and women have different abilities", "trans women are not women", "abortion is murder",etc )?
- taneq 7y agoAre you saying that there are reasonable, persuasive arguments in favour of any of those things you describe?
- throwaway2048 7y agoThere have been "reasonable" persuasive arguments that have convinced millions of people. Its especially relevant as China is committing a mass imprisonment campaign against an entire ethnicity, should defense of that be welcomed as just another point of view, equally valid and encouraged?
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoThe problem comes to distinguishing genuinely held beliefs from subversive comments designed to manipulate the HN audience. The fact that an idea comes from your peers is a powerful one. The average commenter on HN is not so different from you, after all, if they independently came to a conclusion then it might have some merit. However, if they came to that conclusion because they will be rewarded for expressing it or punished for expressing a dissenting opinion, the value is much less. Some people make it easier - on many occasions you'll see someone discussing a subject but first disclosing their relationship, such as an ex-Google employee commenting on a Google-critical article. If a Chinese party official came to HN to express their views and disclosed themselves as such, I would welcome them to express their opinion here. What I'm concerned about is commenters with undisclosed affiliations writing manipulative comments which help prop up an oppressive state.
- dang 7y ago> The problem comes to distinguishing genuinely held beliefs from subversive comments designed to manipulate the HN audience How do you propose to do that? Clearly one must look for evidence. When evidence shows such abuse, we ban the account. Far more often, though (and I'm understating things when I put it that way), evidence shows the opposite: the user was expressing their genuinely held beliefs. Should others be allowed to denounce them as astroturfers, shills, or spies, based on nothing but how strongly they disagree? On HN the answer is no. That follows from the values of this site, and we have a rule in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html saying so.