6 ms·
I think people, possibly including me, get irked with Demand Media et al more because they're more successful than we think they deserve to be rather than becau
by patio11 16y ago
I think people, possibly including me, get irked with Demand Media et al more because they're more successful than we think they deserve to be rather than because they actually decrease the value of the SERPs. For SERPS where DM ranks well, the results prior to DM existing generally pretty much sucked. Maybe that is a Google issue, maybe that is an Internet issue (memo to Internet: middle aged women exist, please write for them, kthxbye), but for whatever reason, if you routinely Googled for [how do i make a blueberry pie] every week for the last ten years I don't think you ever had an awesome search experience.
DM pages are adequate for much of what they rank for, in much the way that USA Today is an adequate newspaper, your local state school provides adequate degrees in history, etc etc. They're adequate in a scalable manner, though, and they understand Google much better than the average publisher, which means they get visibility in excess of what some people might expect.
P.S.
Demand Media: http://www.ehow.com/how_2933_make-blueberry-pie.html http://www.ehow.com/how_2933_make-blueberry-pie.html
Virtuous publishers on the Internet: http://www.pickyourown.org/blueberrypie.php http://www.pickyourown.org/blueberrypie.php
If I wanted to bake a blueberry pie, I'd go for that second page every day of the week, but it is highly non-obvious to me that it is a better result qua search engine result than the DM page. I love this example because I think Google fundamentally doesn't think [how do i make a blueberry pie] is looking for a blueberry pie recipe. Most searches will not actually convert to pies. For the 98% of searchers who merely want to satisfy their pie voyeurism need, the DM content may well be better.
- stcredzero 16y ago(memo to Internet: middle aged women exist, please write for them, kthxbye) Many years ago, when I was working at Joseph Beth Bookstore (where I suspect Borders stole a lot of their ops manual ideas from) management there told me that the primary demographic there was middle aged women. Middle aged women often have disposable income. Many of them are married homemakers and have tons of spare time. I suspect much of Oprah's success is built on that demographic. If I were Oprah, I'd position her cable channel as just a part of her latest "new media" venture -- just one outlet for Oprah branded content. In her shoes, I'd make diverse investments in mobile and in TV-integrated platforms. I'd offer advertisers packages for reaching all those different outlets simultaneously. If Oprah does this, I'd recommend working with her. If she can't see this path clearly, then I'd recommend disrupting her.
- PaulHoule 16y agoMy mother-in-law used to be an Oprah fan but she recently 'cut the cord' with the cable company. Personally I think people like her could really enjoy an experience like Digg or Reddit if all the stars aligned correctly.
- stcredzero 16y agoMaybe something like reddit, but presented through things like Google TV and Apple TV. If someone can morph social media viewing/browsing into something that emulates channel surfing, then that idea will easily be worth 100's of millions. EDIT IDEA: If Oprah doesn't have someone doing the following for her, then some group with the right CV items should hop on it! Start finding or putting key moments from shows followed by middle aged-women up on YouTube. (Oprah will make up a lot of this content.) At the same time, launch a social media site tailored for middle-aged women and create APIs so that it can be integrated with TV convergence devices. Not only will Oprah make more money on her own content this way, she will become the middlewoman for a big chunk of the other content aimed at this demographic.
- eitland 16y agoGood point. On the other hand it took google more than a couple of weeks to get rid of kods.net, too. Where ehow is readable, kods was, as far as I could tell, just a lot of computer generated oracle words mixed from other sources.
- awongh 16y agoI think I see where you're going, but I disagree. To me, link #2 is superior even if I just want pie voyeurism. (mainly, it has instructional pictures) I would click on #2 every time. However, if #2 is buried on the 3rd page of results like it sometimes is, then I would not.... There is however, a definite gradation of google spam. ehow is somewhere near the top... domain squatters somewhere near the bottom...
- bambax 16y ago> [how do i make a blueberry pie] You know very well that this is not how search works. You don't "ask a question" to the search engine like you would ask your grandmother. You type in words that you expect to be in the pages you're looking for, and the search engine lists pages that actually contain ALL of those words. One of the main improvements of Google in the very early days was that it used the AND operand by default, whereas competing search engines used OR by default, resulting in an incredible amount of noise. In essence, searching for "how do i make a blueberry pie" (with quotes) should return only spam, because only spammy and SEO optimized sites would contain the phrase as such. A real recipe would maybe contain the phrase "how TO make a blueberry pie" but not "how do i..." - - - I think your point was that "middle aged women" don't know any of this. It would be arguable (probably wrong, but still) that people who don't know this, who didn't make the effort to understand a little how all of this works, deserve the spam they get. There is a good way to discriminate between good and bad content, and that is to know a little about what you're searching in order to search for words that will be present in good quality content and NOT in spammy pages. For example, it's reasonnable to expect a good recipe to give instructions in metric system as well as imperial; if you add "celsius" to the search then the second (informative) recipe arrives first: http://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+make+blueberry+pie+celsius http://www.google.com/search?q=how+to+make+blueberry+pie+cel...
- patio11 16y agoI think your point was that "middle aged women" don't know any of this. No. That is overbroad, untrue, and would be very injurious to my professional reputation. I said that the Internet is skewed away from producing content responsive to their needs, which is about as controversial as saying that they are slightly underrepresented on HN relative to, I don't know, twenty-something males. Non-technical users frequently use natural language search. The experience for natural language search is fairly poor. There are many classes of search which offer poor experience, but it is the one which leaps to my head first because I deal with non-technical users every day. people who don't know this, who didn't make the effort to understand a little how all of this works, deserve the spam they get. Words cannot express the depth of my distaste for this position. I will accept that "Google screwed up" or "I screwed up" if one of my users has a suboptimal Internet experience (which starts at Google because Google is the Internet and ideally ends at my site), but I cannot accept that she is responsible if she has a poor user experience. We've got the teams of PhDs, the highly paid SEO consultants, and the lifetime of building an accurate mental model of how the devil box works. She wants to teach kids to read, not learn magic incantations. It should -- "should" in the sense of "would be optimal for the business", "would be optimal for society", and "as a moral imperative for computing professionals" -- just work for her.
- pvg 16y agoI don't know what a 'SERP' is but I don't think anyone shows up at Google bright and early in the morning with the burning desire to deliver the 'USA Today' quality of search. In fact, we had it before Google came along and it left much to be desired. I don't know much about blueberry pie searches either or if the quality of Google results is really in decline. It seems pretty reasonable to expect original content (StackOverflow) to show up before copies of the same content. Or the top search engine to aim for a quality standard above 'USA Today'. Otherwise we can just use USA Today instead of Google.
- newman314 16y agoSERP = Search Engine Result Page
- nervechannel 16y agoThe StackOverflow scrapers ranking higher than SO is the thing that most irks me about the big G at the moment. That and all the sites like wareseeker that just act as pointless aggregators of FLOSS download sites or forum sites. Last time I tried Bing though they weren't any better, and DuckDuckGo had really low coverage. Maybe it's time to try again.
- eru 16y agoI use DuckDuckGo as my main search engine, since I figured out the bang syntax. If I don't like the results, I just resend the same query with !g prefixed (!google works, too, and so does !bing).
- epi0Bauqu 16y agoI've been trying to clean those out, but if you see more big ones feel free to send them my way.
- true_religion 16y agoPicking Virtuous over Demand Media is your opinion. Personally, I've been using eHow's results for cooking for about half a year now. I don't need pictorial aids for cooking--I know how to cook. What I need is a recipe, and a series of concise steps to follow. It's easy to toss it up on the laptop or table, then glance at every so often to make sure you haven't strayed too far from the recipee. Demand Media is like a virtual cookbook, Virtuous is like calling your parents for help and having them hold your hand through every step.
- jpwagner 16y agohttp://www.cookingforengineers.com/ http://www.cookingforengineers.com/