3 ms·
Yawn. This article is three years old, and even in 2005 was mostly trite, recycled trash (X11 sucks on a line with 200ms latency? Do tell...). And big chunks
by ajross 18y ago
Yawn. This article is three years old, and even in 2005 was mostly trite, recycled trash (X11 sucks on a line with 200ms latency? Do tell...). And big chunks of it are just plain wrong (no, stdin and stdout are not always pipes, are not forced to be unidirectional, and yes you can tell the difference) or incomplete (the author apparently has never heard of the scatter/gather I/O using readv/writev, nor kqueues/epoll, and doesn't seem to know much about signals either).
Basically everything in this is either wrong or disingenuous. Stay away, it's just flame bait. If you want to read a good flame about unix, "The UNIX-HATER's Handbook" did all this much, much better. Read that. The linked article isn't worth your time.
- iron_ball 18y agoAlso, you can see most of these criticisms handled quite impartially in Eric Raymond's "The Art of Unix Programming," which I'd say is required reading for any would-be "hacker."
- tptacek 18y agoExcept that everything in that book is cribbed from better primary sources, not the least of which are Kernighan+Plaugher's "Software Tools", Stevens APUE, and "The Unix Haters Handbook".
- tptacek 18y agoscatter/gather, kqueue, and signals: finish your argument. How do these rebut the article? (Also: where are you still using readv/writev? "THIS PROGRAM NEEDS BUFFERING").
- msg 18y agoThe other problem is, Unix is the worst operating system ever devised, except for the others that have been tried from time to time. http://www.jwz.org/doc/worse-is-better.html http://www.jwz.org/doc/worse-is-better.html Google and Amazon seem to have post-Unix operating systems in some sense, but a lot of it's trade secrets to us proles.
- olefoo 18y agoBut their post unix, multi-machine, massively parallel, data-centered operating systems are built using unix building blocks... If you really want to play with a cloud OS, you can find all the parts out there. But wiring them together is not trivial. places to start: http://hadoop.apache.org http://hadoop.apache.org http://www.cfengine.org/ http://www.cfengine.org/