4 ms·
Wake me up when I can use such a statement as a means to legally coerce corporations into compliance with existing laws, to say nothing of the exigent environme
by AtlasBarfed 7y ago
Wake me up when I can use such a statement as a means to legally coerce corporations into compliance with existing laws, to say nothing of the exigent environmental threats facing the world.
Literally every CEO would laugh at this statement in the privacy of their office, while they engineer stock manipulation to trigger their stock options and retire in 5 years.
It's like an ethics in business class at MBA schools. It's window dressing.
Of course the political donations of the signers of this document, which is in all likelihood:
- non-binding
- has no monetary commitments
- involves no policy commitments contrary to their revenue streams
- addresses no previous examples of bad behavior by the companies, nor any pledges to ameliorate those impacts
The political donations from these entities most assuredly will point to the exact opposite motivations.
- rectang 7y ago"Self-regulation" like this always fails. The marketplace is unforgiving: a company which does not push externalities onto wider society will be put at a competitive disadvantage to one which does. This statement is a bunch of malarkey designed to present the appearance of reform in order to avert the reality of reform.
- civilized 7y agoI think this can explain why individual companies don't go out of their way to behave better when it hurts their bottom line. But why don't companies come together to advocate for better standards overall, so that no one in particular is put at a disadvantage? Seems like a culture issue, not just the iron laws of economics and competition.
- rectang 7y agoVoluntary groups coming together like that creates a prisoner's dilemma, and thus an unstable alliance. Only externally enforced rules, evenly applied, create a level playing field where individual companies can have confidence that they are not harming themselves by adhering to the rules.
- mlyle 7y ago"Literally every". I don't think it's fair to tar every business owner and executive with this brush. Yes, there's unethical people, and it's way too common in this business environment. But there's also plenty of businesses that do their very best to treat customers, employees, suppliers, and shareholders with respect and fairness.
- riku_iki 7y ago> Yes, there's unethical people, and it's way too common in this business environment. It is survivorship filter, good guys have much smaller chances to climb the ladder.
- throwaway2048 7y agoThe issue is the more prevalent this stuff becomes, the more the bad drives out the good. Its the same argument about corrupt police departments, all the good cops either leave, or are forced out by their corrupt co-workers.
- mlyle 7y agoThat's a different argument and doesn't rely upon hyperbole. Yes, I've felt pressure in the business environment to do questionable things because my competitors were doing them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gist 7y ago> Literally every CEO would laugh at this statement in the privacy of their office, while they engineer stock manipulation to trigger their stock options and retire in 5 years. It's coming from (see the members) presumably the most secure and profitable corporations out there. While perhaps some have issue most are not anywhere near the 'every man for himself' thinking that gets companies into trouble. Look there are many things a super profitable corporation can do to enhance their image in the eyes of employees and customers. But the truth is if you are going to take an airline flight or buy a dishwasher most consumers (or most business customers if a business sale) will not decide based on values such as this. Ditto for most stock investors. They will go for the best return not the best company values. And you know if you need someone to operate on your brain or a Physician very generally you want the best results not someone with the best personal values.
- echelon 7y ago> Literally every CEO would laugh at this statement in the privacy of their office, while they engineer stock manipulation to trigger their stock options and retire in 5 years. While this may be true of some, I don't think all CEOs want to stop working. Nor are all of them principally concerned with wealth. Can you not imagine a CEO driven to satisfy their customers and employees? I can think of several.