4 ms·
And is it not true?
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
And is it not true?
- goatinaboat 7y agoAnd is it not true? Consider that Hollywood is unionised even though the pay differential between an extra and a star is far greater than in tech. They can make it work, why can’t we?
- pjmlp 7y agoWe surely can. Many European countries have unions for the whole company, and there are several factors as part of the wage. Collective agreement is just one of the pieces. Nothing prevents the existence of bonus tied to performance.
- bonaldi 7y agoNo. There is nothing about “higher-skill” workers that means management interests or values automatically align with theirs, or that collective power isn’t greater than individual at higher levels of compensation. The results we’ve seen when such workers realise this (see Googlers more-or-less ept attempts to change management policy) is the test for this. A strong union would stand them in much better stead.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoSkill levels are widely varied at the higher levels. Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) So there's a downside. As a highly-skilled contracting worker, I care nothing about changing my client companies policies. Their values are a curiosity to me. I negotiate my rate, do the job, submit my invoice and move on. So maybe I'm not the person who can appreciate the advantages in a full-employee situation.
- dllthomas 7y ago> Skill levels are widely varied at the higher levels. Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) Isn't SAG an existence proof that this isn't necessarily the case? (This shouldn't be read as an endorsement of all things union, or of SAG in particular, just that it doesn't seem to fit the claim.)
- moate 7y agoYes, it is. There's so many different rights that a union could argue for. SAG or professional athletes unions are some great examples. There's still large ranges of contract options available, tailored to an individual. But there's also a ton of hard fought guaranteed working conditions that might not exist otherwise. It's weird that people have this idea that all unions always look/work a certain way when they're so varied from field to field (never mind country to country). Off the top of my head, you could very easily have a union that says "These are the specific job requirements and expectations for this job. Here are the tiers of skill in this job type. Here are the floors for compensation at each tier. Here are the guaranteed rights and working conditions that the owners must maintain (PTO, Health coverage, overtime, etc). Any grievances will first go through mediation with a Union Rep/Lawyer available." and call it a day. That covers about 90% of what most pro-union supporters actually want to happen.
- ahoy 7y ago>Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) This is a misconception spread by capital to make you think unions are going to hurt you. The media company I work for recently unionized. I assure you the junior staff still makes less money than the senior staff. What the union bargaining got wasn't flat wages. What it got was a higher wage floor for new hires, better PTO, more flexible working hours, and a consistent yearly raise/compensation schedule, things like that. No senior employee's work is devalued. The tradeoff isn't between senior and junior workers. It's between workers and owners.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI'm talking the disparities between 'senior workers'. Putting them all in one hat is exactly the issue. I negotiate my own rate now, and its pretty good.
- danaris 7y agoOK, so you can negotiate your own rates, and get a good deal. That suggests that you're a pretty good negotiator. But are you really the best (non-managerial) negotiator in the entire company? Statistically speaking, the odds of that are low. And with a union, you could have the very best negotiating on your behalf. Yes, you'd have to give them all the information—but you have to do that now with your managers, in an adversarial setting, and you could instead do it with the negotiator in a friendly meeting where they're actively working to help you get them the information to get you the best deal. Or, maybe you really are the best negotiator in the area. Wouldn't you like to get some extra pay from the union to be that guy above, and use that negotiating skill on behalf of the rest of the senior workers? (Don't think they'd pay you extra for that? Well, you're the best negotiator around—make it happen!) Or maybe you not only genuinely believe there's no one who could possibly be better than you at negotiating your compensation, but also genuinely don't care that other people have the opportunity to be paid what they're worth, too. In that case, all I can say is I Don’t Know How To Explain To You That You Should Care About Other People.
- 7y ago
- maximente 7y ago> Skill levels are widely varied at the higher levels. Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) you seem to be inferring that skill level should influence compensation, and since unions are primarily in the business of bargaining on wages, the downside is that they introduce some ceiling or whatever but, that's not how all unions operate. many are focused on working conditions/presence of work/benefits alongside. your average SWE doesn't care about these things because their job is physically and mentally easy, plus they are wooed with free food/working conditions/intellectual challenges etc. so average software guy is sated and doesn't have much incentive to rock the boat. but, let's run with your example. suppose there is probably a large amount of variance in ML engineers. suppose some have a skill set 1x (average ML engineer) and a few have a skill set 5x average the 5xers like yourself (maybe) probably feel great, they have tons of disposable income and don't feel any particular pressure because their work is intellectually fulfilling etc. so no need for collective bargaining. don't hold me back! you say as you cash check after check but, in the case of ML engineers, one thing they are creating is self driving trucks which is a market worth hundreds of billions of dollars! management throwing them $500k, $1mil etc. a year is absolute pennies relatively despite being a large absolute salary were you to pipe up about this as a contractor, you'd just get run out of town. but unions may be able to take the collective and say "we are an insanely talented group of specialists worth 10x what you're paying us, so pay us... or we quit" there are unions like screen actors guild that mandate membership but function as a sort of "loose" union insofar as they have extremely talented people alongside entry level people (high skill variance) vis-a-vis more manual labor (e.g. nurses, coal miners) whose variance in "output" is way more narrow
- Mirioron 7y ago>were you to pipe up about this as a contractor, you'd just get run out of town. but unions may be able to take the collective and say "we are an insanely talented group of specialists worth 10x what you're paying us, so pay us... or we quit" And if these ML experts fail to create an automated trucking system then will they be the ones to pick up the tab? Of course they won't. This means that the money spent on them still matters, because you're not guaranteed success.
- throw0101a 7y ago> Skill levels are widely varied at the higher levels. Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) The middle-ground could be guilds like SAG/ACTRA: base requirements for working conditions and benefits, but clauses for independent compensation (but perhaps with a floor). Tom Cruise and the guy playing Taxi Driver #2 are both card carrying members, but it doesn't stop Cruise from making more given that he's less replaceable than John Smith.
- throw0101a 7y ago> Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) Plenty of places have wage schedules: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Schedule_(US_civil_service_pay_scale)#Grade_and_step_structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Schedule_(US_civil_ser... Throw a "Senior" or "Level II" or III in the position, and it can move someone to a different level. I've also seen places allow for an extra boost via a "market allowance" mechanism.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI bargain my rate by the job, not by some bucket you put me in. You need this task done? I can do it; you'll pay for that. You need it sooner? The rate goes up. You want a fixed bid? I'll have to pad that, to cover for eventualities. Not a lot about 'Level III' in that discussion.
- pdkl95 7y agoAnybody interested in a practical example of this should watch this[1] outstanding report about the problems in the video game industry and how the "higher-skill" workers are starting to unionize. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TSB5YQqDiY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TSB5YQqDiY
- devoply 7y agoNo... it's not true. In the end I have heard employees be terminated for all sorts of frivolous reasons. Unless you are a very senior developer, the chances of you being replaceable especially at a well funded company are very high... In fact all businesses are set up to make all their employees replaceable. > Isn’t that just smart? Why would I, the hypothetical investor risking my money on a venture, tie that money to a specific employee? That’s putting all of your eggs in one basket. Similarly, why would as a hypothetical employee work without the protection of a union? > 1) Payscale -- a professional is in a better position to have a substantial emergency fund, to get through a sudden layoff. It would be higher yet with unions. > 2) Demand -- Some professional skills are also in high demand, which makes changing employers easier. Easier, yes, but not easy. > 3) Upward and lateral mobility -- In a union shop, mobility is often rigidly defined by seniority, whereas in many professional services, the employee can be more in control of their career. Contrast this to something like the airline pilots union, where a pilot has to start over as a rookey if they change airlines. When I started my last job, I was able to negotiate more weeks PTO because of my years of experience in the field. Yes except in tech you are an old man by 40, so yes enjoy your 5-year senior developer status... And enjoy your retirement at 40. It's a mythology that you are better off in tech because of the lack of unions because of the super high salaries, etc., which are only to be found in a small segment of the industry.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoBut then you get a better job somewhere else. Highly skilled, remember?
- devoply 7y agoAs everyone here will tell you hiring in tech is broken. It will take you a significant amount of time, months to find another job... after having to practice to get that job with things you don't usually do -- i.e. pass code interviews and other bullshit.
- derekp7 7y agoIs that true everywhere, or is it mostly a West Coast web dev shop cultural item? In systems engineering / operations / devops / architecture roles in the MidWest, I have never experienced any of that BS.
- ahoy 7y agoNo, it isn't true.
- roywiggins 7y agoThe next paragraph: > even in a company that genuinely does try to be the best in digital media, things can slip through the cracks, and a bad manager can make a world of difference. I had always gotten along very well with my bosses at Vox, but that could change in one corporate reshuffling. I also started to worry about the future: What if, in a very volatile journalism industry, I’m laid off, or Vox is sold off to another company? Who’s to say the next owners would be as good as the current ones?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI didn't consider a journalism employee to be in the highly-technically-skilled category. Sure they have a reason to want some security.
- moate 7y agoWhoa whoa whoa there chief. Don't move the goalposts. The article's author stated "High Skilled" not "highly-technically-skilled". He feels he's part of a highly skilled trade which was his reason for opposing unions. Journalism isn't the same thing as "writing listicles for Buzzfeed", and even that isn't always as easy as it might seem to be to laymen.
- roywiggins 7y agoWell, he did. That's why he didn't think he needed a union.
- mikestew 7y agoIf it were true, a lot fewer places would have an open office layout, as just one counter example.