6 ms·
I was skeptical of unions. Then I joined one
- programminggeek 7y ago"It's a trap!" -Admiral Ackbar
- i_am_proteus 7y ago> A union isn’t just right for Vox Media, but for everyone. At least the author sets the hyperbolic tone up front.
- egypturnash 7y ago> I saw unions as a balancing act to corporate interests, offering protections to lower-skilled workers who, without collective action, didn’t have much power over their bosses. [...] But not high-skilled industries like digital media, where workers could, on their own, use their skill sets as leverage over their bosses. This is every dismissive comment about unions on HN ever, right here.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAnd is it not true?
- goatinaboat 7y agoAnd is it not true? Consider that Hollywood is unionised even though the pay differential between an extra and a star is far greater than in tech. They can make it work, why can’t we?
- pjmlp 7y agoWe surely can. Many European countries have unions for the whole company, and there are several factors as part of the wage. Collective agreement is just one of the pieces. Nothing prevents the existence of bonus tied to performance.
- bonaldi 7y agoNo. There is nothing about “higher-skill” workers that means management interests or values automatically align with theirs, or that collective power isn’t greater than individual at higher levels of compensation. The results we’ve seen when such workers realise this (see Googlers more-or-less ept attempts to change management policy) is the test for this. A strong union would stand them in much better stead.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoSkill levels are widely varied at the higher levels. Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) So there's a downside. As a highly-skilled contracting worker, I care nothing about changing my client companies policies. Their values are a curiosity to me. I negotiate my rate, do the job, submit my invoice and move on. So maybe I'm not the person who can appreciate the advantages in a full-employee situation.
- dllthomas 7y ago> Skill levels are widely varied at the higher levels. Collective bargaining means, valuing them about the same (a common agreement means the same outcome for all?) Isn't SAG an existence proof that this isn't necessarily the case? (This shouldn't be read as an endorsement of all things union, or of SAG in particular, just that it doesn't seem to fit the claim.)
- moate 7y agoYes, it is. There's so many different rights that a union could argue for. SAG or professional athletes unions are some great examples. There's still large ranges of contract options available, tailored to an individual. But there's also a ton of hard fought guaranteed working conditions that might not exist otherwise. It's weird that people have this idea that all unions always look/work a certain way when they're so varied from field to field (never mind country to country). Off the top of my head, you could very easily have a union that says "These are the specific job requirements and expectations for this job. Here are the tiers of skill in this job type. Here are the floors for compensation at each tier. Here are the guaranteed rights and working conditions that the owners must maintain (PTO, Health coverage, overtime, etc). Any grievances will first go through mediation with a Union Rep/Lawyer available." and call it a day. That covers about 90% of what most pro-union supporters actually want to happen.
- devoply 7y agoNo... it's not true. In the end I have heard employees be terminated for all sorts of frivolous reasons. Unless you are a very senior developer, the chances of you being replaceable especially at a well funded company are very high... In fact all businesses are set up to make all their employees replaceable. > Isn’t that just smart? Why would I, the hypothetical investor risking my money on a venture, tie that money to a specific employee? That’s putting all of your eggs in one basket. Similarly, why would as a hypothetical employee work without the protection of a union? > 1) Payscale -- a professional is in a better position to have a substantial emergency fund, to get through a sudden layoff. It would be higher yet with unions. > 2) Demand -- Some professional skills are also in high demand, which makes changing employers easier. Easier, yes, but not easy. > 3) Upward and lateral mobility -- In a union shop, mobility is often rigidly defined by seniority, whereas in many professional services, the employee can be more in control of their career. Contrast this to something like the airline pilots union, where a pilot has to start over as a rookey if they change airlines. When I started my last job, I was able to negotiate more weeks PTO because of my years of experience in the field. Yes except in tech you are an old man by 40, so yes enjoy your 5-year senior developer status... And enjoy your retirement at 40. It's a mythology that you are better off in tech because of the lack of unions because of the super high salaries, etc., which are only to be found in a small segment of the industry.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoBut then you get a better job somewhere else. Highly skilled, remember?
- devoply 7y agoAs everyone here will tell you hiring in tech is broken. It will take you a significant amount of time, months to find another job... after having to practice to get that job with things you don't usually do -- i.e. pass code interviews and other bullshit.
- derekp7 7y agoIs that true everywhere, or is it mostly a West Coast web dev shop cultural item? In systems engineering / operations / devops / architecture roles in the MidWest, I have never experienced any of that BS.
- ahoy 7y agoNo, it isn't true.
- roywiggins 7y agoThe next paragraph: > even in a company that genuinely does try to be the best in digital media, things can slip through the cracks, and a bad manager can make a world of difference. I had always gotten along very well with my bosses at Vox, but that could change in one corporate reshuffling. I also started to worry about the future: What if, in a very volatile journalism industry, I’m laid off, or Vox is sold off to another company? Who’s to say the next owners would be as good as the current ones?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI didn't consider a journalism employee to be in the highly-technically-skilled category. Sure they have a reason to want some security.
- moate 7y agoWhoa whoa whoa there chief. Don't move the goalposts. The article's author stated "High Skilled" not "highly-technically-skilled". He feels he's part of a highly skilled trade which was his reason for opposing unions. Journalism isn't the same thing as "writing listicles for Buzzfeed", and even that isn't always as easy as it might seem to be to laymen.
- roywiggins 7y agoWell, he did. That's why he didn't think he needed a union.
- mikestew 7y agoIf it were true, a lot fewer places would have an open office layout, as just one counter example.
- umvi 7y agoMy only question with unions is: what checks and balances will be in place this time around to prevent unions from: - Rampant corruption (i.e. Teamsters in the 60s is the most egregious example, but probably even a lot of current unions are rife with corruption) - Racketeering (i.e. like what happened when Theranos tried to move offices) - Protecting bad/lazy workers (i.e. impossible-to-fire poor performing employees that do nothing yet collect a paycheck every week) - Blocking strategic decisions in the name of protecting employees (i.e. "Sorry, we won't let you automate X; too many people would lose jobs") I see how unions benefit workers in the case of terrible corporations that exploit workers, but as a small business owner I'm afraid a union would morph into a parasite that hinders the business and engages in all sorts of undesirable activity (in the case of industry-wide unions). Like I read a few years ago at some convention in NYC some organization couldn't get their booth up and running because they weren't allowed to plug in their own equipment because "that's union work" and they had to wait for a card-carrying union member to come plug in their TV or something ridiculous.
- wastedhours 7y agoI think the main checks and balances should come from the union members themselves, however, often times it's the "loudest voice" that wins over. It's difficult as an individual to make an argument against striking for increased pay for example, even if you believe the long-term impact of that decision will ultimately be worse (i.e. it could lead to increasing the speed with which the employer investigates automation to stop the impacts of you striking). Am almost wholeheartedly in favour of organised labour, but am not convinced most unions have the right organisation (although something is often better than nothing in the case of workers rights).
- devoply 7y ago> - Rampant corruption (i.e. Teamsters in the 60s is the most egregious example, but probably even a lot of current unions are rife with corruption) > - Racketeering (i.e. like what happened when Theranos tried to move offices) RICO act which pretty much destroyed unions in the US... the ones which were left and were pretty corrupt. > - Protecting bad/lazy workers (i.e. impossible-to-fire poor performing employees that do nothing yet collect a paycheck every week) Union contracts or collective bargaining agreements lay out these sorts of things, and they have to be negotiated in that contract. > - Blocking strategic decisions in the name of protecting employees (i.e. "Sorry, we won't let you automate X; too many people would lose jobs") If all companies were set up with unions then they would all oppose altogether which would not effect the competitiveness of a company... but the entire industry. So such a move would have to be an industry move. This then makes a key industry beholden to not just the shareholders but also the employees when the government goes to set policies for that industry.
- commandlinefan 7y agoI have a tough time with this one myself. My father was a police officer and, as he rose through the ranks, he had to deal with police officer union corruption at every level - he can tell you horror story after horror story of the problems driven by the police officer’s union. On the other hand, now that I’m working myself, in the very non-unionized field of computer programming, I can at least see why people began to realize that collective bargaining was so important.
- cagenut 7y agoThere are a bunch of reasons why police unions are somewhat of a special case. Enumerating them can get dragged into a lot of disagreements, but its important to remember they're an outlier and not the common-case for labor unions.
- umvi 7y agoWhat makes police officer unions so different from the others?
- Communitivity 7y agoAs a child of two news people I grew up hearing union horror stories, such as typesetters in a newspaper that spend almost all day playing cards because their job has gone but the union still forces the paper to keep them on. Then I married my wife, who worked in a union at a college library, and I learned I had only heard one side of the story. Initially we had a few interesting, and heated, debates about unions. Over time though I have slowly come over to the idea that unions as a concept, and in many implementations, are a good thing. I still think some unions wind up getting too much power and abuse that power, but they are generally a good check in a world that resembles more and more the world of the Cyberpunk 2020 game I used to play [1]. Curiously, this is the second time I've been reminded of Cyberpunk 2020 this month. The first time was the 'Satoshi' reveal last week, which brought up memories of Hal Finney [2]. I always equated with Spider Murphy [3], the top digital rights activist/info broker/info breaker in Cyberpunk 2020. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyberpunk_2020 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyberpunk_2020 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Finney_(computer_scientist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Finney_(computer_scientist... [3] https://cyberpunk.fandom.com/wiki/Spider_Murphy https://cyberpunk.fandom.com/wiki/Spider_Murphy
- RugnirViking 7y agoUnions can be bad or corrupt or too large in exactly the same way companies can be bad or corrupt or too large. The existence of such bad actors however does not mean that the very concept of companies or unions is bad.
- hackeraccount 7y agoUnions are just monopolies. I don't really have a huge problem with that - as long as they are not given the backing of state power. Having a law that enforces closed shops is not something I'd support. That and government sector unions. Those things are toxic because the unions end up supporting providing political support for the people they're employed by i.e. that's like me and my co-workers voting on how much we'll be paid.
- cagenut 7y ago> i.e. that's like me and my co-workers voting on how much we'll be paid. thats bad?
- ahh 7y agoIt is when they're voting on how much a third party (I.e. you) will be required to pay them. See: the Chicago, California, and general us public pension crisis.
- Fordec 7y agoUber etc. raise millions and billions in the idea that if they scale enough they can capture a market and monetize it once captured. A market monopoly. Why can't industry workers do the same? Once software has eaten the world, what's to stop software people monetizing the employment market they have captured?
- taffer 7y agoThat is why there are anti-trust laws, and we should apply them much more rigorously against companies like Uber.
- mcguire 7y ago"...that's like me and my co-workers voting on how much we'll be paid." You mean like every C-level manager at every corporation in the world?
- zajio1am 7y ago
- selimthegrim 7y agoWhat about the unions at that Shell plant where Trump spoke and the workers had to stay unpaid at first? Why did they roll over? https://twitter.com/spettypi/status/1161360126361710592 https://twitter.com/spettypi/status/1161360126361710592
- throw0101a 7y agoThey had a choice: * go to work * not go to work It's just that their 'assigned duties' for that day, if they went to work, were to attend an internal company-sponsored function. If the company wants to pay people to mill about, that's its prerogative. I'd file a grievance for the lunch thing though.
- moate 7y agoThat is a bad faith, gross oversimplification of what happened. Their employers used them as part of a political optics campaign and threatened to dock their pay if they didn't play along. Saying "I'm going to shoot you if you don't leave your desk" and "Tomorrow we have a scheduled weapons test that will be concentrated around your desk area" are technically describing the same event. The illusion of free will doesn't mean there's a choice. These people didn't have "attend political campaign rallies" as part of their job description.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoUnions are like companies and other organizations of humans. Some are fantastic, some are terrible, with most in between. It's unfortunate so many push to brand them all with one description for ideological reasons.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoThis might be a naive union question: Competition is good, and we always want a choice of where to shop. I imagine the same goes for unions. Is there anti-monopoly and antitrust law around unions? E.g. protecting consumers against there being only one union for widget makers. I would guess that unions would be less controversial with a healthy ecosystem of competition on both the employer and labor sides, but I don't know much about unions.
- rhinoceraptor 7y agoIt seems like that kind of defeats the purpose of the union: to create a unified bargaining entity for the workers. If there are two or three unions for the same type of work, then their negotiation power isn't as strong.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoI imagine it as a spectrum. One union has all sorts of power. Two or three unions have less, but still have way way more bargaining power than one union per worker, which we have today. There should be a balance.
- ido 7y agoIn Israel school teachers have 2 competing unions.
- samd 7y agoThis post got flagged off the homepage almost as soon as it made it there.