3 ms·
This is a complete moscharacterization of what happened. The elected representatives of the EU and the UK agreed to a deal. A deal in which the EU compromised
by addicted 7y ago
This is a complete moscharacterization of what happened.
The elected representatives of the EU and the UK agreed to a deal. A deal in which the EU compromised a lot (the backstop applying to the entire UK was a UK demand, insisted upon by May to retain DUP support).
That agreed upon deal was then ratified by the EU parliament, but rejected by the UK parliament.
Considering the UK is the party that is rejecting the deal, one would imagine they would be the ones responsible for at the very least stating what they want. But they cannot do that because there is no version of Brexit that has majority support. If they move in one direction away from the deal, they lose left wing votes while gaining fewer right wing votes. If they move in the other direction, they gain a few right wing votes, while losing more left wing votes.
That’s why the UK has constantly insisted the EU compromise, without ever explaining what that compromise should look like (other than, no backstop, which then raises the impossible desire to both maintain an open border between Ireland and NI, while the UK insists on controlling its borders and having a different customs regime on one side of that border).
It’s stupid, and the UK’spoliticians are entirely at fault here. The EU has been compromising to a fault, honestly. They should have listened to Macron and not extended the deadline. At least you wouldn’t have an incompetent lying charlatan leading the UK during Brexit. You’d only have an incompetent leading the UK.
- makomk 7y agoYou sure about that? As far as I know the European Parliament never actually ratified the deal. They'd cannily scheduled their vote after the UK parliament's vote and last I'd heard they hadn't bothered going ahead with the vote after the UK rejected it, though that may have changed. It's possible that the EU parliament would've rejected it. Perhaps unlikely, as we saw with the copyright directive it's pretty hard to convince them to ever block something, but it's certainly possible - especially when it involves something that's so different from what the EU normally does.