3 ms·
The author believes working as a software engineer in a startup is fine so long as you have the title "product engineer" rather than "software engineer", as if
by onion2k 7y ago
The author believes working as a software engineer in a startup is fine so long as you have the title "product engineer" rather than "software engineer", as if your job title actually matters.
- chrisseaton 7y agoThis is an uncharitable reading of the article. They aren’t just suggesting a different title - they’re suggesting doing a different job - shaping the product rather than just implementing it.
- lsaferite 7y agoonion2k was simply pointing out that titles are mostly rubbish. What people do is frequently quite different than their title. What the article was summing up and getting to with a little bit of a click-bait title was that when working in a startup you, as a software engineer (or whatever you prefer to be called), need to prioritize the customer and how the product solves the customers needs. Obviously the article goes into more detail.
- onion2k 7y agoIt's not a different job though. Everyone at a startup shapes the product. That's just what it's like working at a startup. That doesn't mean developers in startups aren't software engineers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ljf 7y agoOK, not a title - a different mentality then - I've seen a lot of a lot of people in general, who just want to do what is asked, and never want to ask why or actually help change things/the product for the better.
- nbevans 7y agoWhoosh. He is saying you aren't seeking software engineering perfection - so forget trying to be an architecture astronaut and all that that entails. You are seeking product perfection - at any given time. And product perfection can only be judged by your customer satisfaction and business growth.
- checktheorder 7y agoAs a Canadian with a lot of iron rings in the family, it's always so weird to see the phrase "software engineer". It just doesn't feel like it's been earned.
- yourapostasy 7y ago> It just doesn't feel like it's been earned. It hasn't. On the other hand, the gravitas of the "engineer" title has significantly eroded to business titles so much that "real engineers" are rarely seen with a seat at the table where power convenes. I don't know if this is just a local minima over the span of history, or the new normal. I hope it is the former, but I have reasons to suspect it will actually get worse. The political power haloed around the "engineer" title, and thus the capacity to affect real, lasting change within organizations, is significantly less than the various equivalent-level management titles. It has eroded to the point that it is a notable anomaly when people remark, "the company is run by engineers". In some circles like some (not all) VC, they use that phrase to damn with faint praise.
- dagw 7y agoDon't they have Software Engineering as an engineering degree in Canada? But I agree that I'm not a fan of using software engineer and programmer interchangeably.
- mikekchar 7y agoAs a fellow Canadian I avoid the title. What's wrong with software developer? I don't do engineering, from the perspective of a P.Eng. I've only worked with one P.Eng to my knowledge and he couldn't do software engineering either (he wasn't even a particularly good software developer). I've heard of people doing things that sound like real engineering wrt software, but I've never actually met anyone who did it. I don't really travel in those circles. However, I've worked with a fair number of really good software developers, who I think have earned that title. An iron ring means nothing to me in the work that I do. I don't suppose that you meant to imply that it did, but there is often some weird idea that an engineer is better than a developer. I'm not sure where that idea came from.
- chasd00 7y agoi didn't read the article but in my experience a title is meaningless until head count is > 50 or so. I know people who have 5 separate business cards all with different titles, they choose which one to hand out based on the audience.