13 ms·
Calculus Is Deeply Irrational
- wodenokoto 7y agoIrrational has two meanings: “Not logical”, which by definition does not apply to math. “Not a ratio”, e.g., a number that cannot be written as the division (ratio) of two whole numbers. It should be no surprise to anyone, that calculus deals with the latter, but the title would allude to the article dealing with the former.
- jonsen 7y agoWhich the author explains near the end of the article.
- richardwhiuk 7y agoBut uses to drive traffic in a deeply unappealing way.
- hcarvalhoalves 7y ago"Illogical" is a synonym of "Irrational" because... > Greek mathematicians termed this ratio of incommensurable magnitudes alogos, or inexpressible. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irrational_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irrational_number
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 7y agoYes, and in fact the ancient Greek term, of those who invented the thing, was neither ("illogical" or "not a ratio"). It was "alogos" (later "arritos"), with the meaning "inexpressible", "which cannot be spelt out" - in the sense that you can never fully write out e.g. the square root of two the way you can a natural or a rational number like 2/3 or 1/4. Unfortunately "alogos" also meant "illogical", so that's where the confusion stems...
- perl4ever 7y agoWell, maybe the point is that "illogical" should mean inexpressible and the whole issue is the wrong connotations of it.
- spsoto 7y agoLooks like the intention of the author was to play with that word game in order to get an appealing title, but even for people familiar with the topic it can have the "not logical" meaning first.
- hprotagonist 7y agoWhy does calculus involve so many irrational numbers? Because there are uncountably many more irrational numbers than there are rational numbers.
- roywiggins 7y agoThere's uncountably many more noncomputables than computables too, but the noncomputables hardly crop up, even though they come along with the reals also.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoWell, you might reasonably expect that a theory describing how to compute numbers will give you more computable numbers than uncomputable ones, no?
- jerf 7y agoIt's worse than you make it sound, though: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TkIe60y2GI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TkIe60y2GI In short, it isn't just that we have more computables than non-computables; there are categories of numbers like "normal" that nominally contain "all the numbers" but we can barely even name a handful.
- wiz21c 7y agoreally interesting video.
- AceyMan 7y agoThis YT link is to a recent (2019) video on the Numberphile channel with Matt Parker as presenter, just so people know what level of quality to expect (14m26s runtime). And, yeah, that's one of my favorites in the STEM genre. I can't wait until my son (now nine) is ready to watch along with me.
- 7y ago
- tempsolution 7y agoI don't like clickbait... The article starts to suggest that calculus is hard to reason about and "irrational". In the end all it is really saying is that calculus requires irrational numbers, well doh! And guess what, you even need complex numbers. And the question is not about "shopping" numbers, there is a history to all of that. If you want something universal, use complex numbers. Try to teach that to a pre-schooler and you will find that you might wanna start with something simpler.
- ColinWright 7y ago> ... In the end all it is really saying is that calculus requires irrational numbers, well doh! That's really not the point, it really isn't. In the middle it says: "The theorems of the calculus that work for the reals but fail for the rationals, despite the very different claims they make, are all equivalent to each other!" There's something quite deep going on with the reals, and it may be that you don't realise it, that you do realise it and don't care, or whatever, but it's not as simple as you seem to be implying.
- JackFr 7y ago> And guess what, you even need complex numbers. That's not true, and that is the point. To prove the main theorems of calculus, you don't need complex numbers, but you do need irrationals. When you first learn calculus, you do one or two epsilon-delta proofs, and then your teacher gets a little hand wavy about limits and you move on to the real work of derivatives and integrals, cause the limits stuff intuitively makes sense. When you continue on in Real Analysis or Topology of the Real Line, you discover that your intuition lied to you, and concepts like open and closed sets and intersections and accumulation points are important and are in general non-obvious. Counterexamples In Analysis https://www.amazon.com/Counterexamples-Analysis-Dover-Books-Mathematics/dp/0486428753/ref=asc_df_0486428753/?tag=hyprod-20&linkCode=df0&hvadid=312168166316&hvpos=1o1&hvnetw=g&hvrand=1608085467130596869&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=c&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9067609&hvtargid=pla-514661979117&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/Counterexamples-Analysis-Dover-Books-... (Pdf version) https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/a4e7/eb352e4c44bf75d8fabaf7594494151cb322.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/a4e7/eb352e4c44bf75d8fabaf7...
- 7y ago
- ska 7y agoIt would ruin the "joke", but probably should have be deeply transcendental... The real numbers are much stranger than they first appear, and a lot of early pedagogy is designed so that you don't look at this too hard. After all, almost all reals are transcendental (but interestingly we only have proved a small handful of them). Most numbers people have used in "regular life" are algebraic, obviously, but they are a countable subset so occur almost never, in the set.
- hyperpallium 7y agoWhen do the reals start making sense (beyond hand-waving explanations)?
- opencl 7y agoTo me at least it was when I took a real analysis course. Very difficult material but once it all 'clicked' I felt like it gave a lot of insight into the fundamentals of math and as a bonus finally offered a rigorous non-hand-wavey explanation of the fundamental theorem of calculus.
- stephencanon 7y agoMost people who say the real numbers make sense doesn't know what they're talking about. The real numbers are pretty bizarre no matter how much mathematics you've studied. You can learn to prove things about them rigorously, and memorize a lot of properties, but very few people will ever develop an accurate intuition for them.
- selimthegrim 7y agoThere’s a famous story of a seminar on p-adic numbers at Princeton where Harish-Chandra was in attendance and one of the audience brings up some intuition from ordinary primes and the speaker replies with a joke about the degenerate case of the real numbers.
- ska 7y agoPart of any good introduction to real analysis is going to be walking you through a bunch of this stuff until you first understand how much you had glossed over the details, then than the details are strange, and finally that you have a working understanding or at least comfort with techniques to reason about this. Is that the same as making sense? Well to paraphrase a physicist, you don't so much understand it as get used to it. One of the fun things about teaching this material is that usually students have been through years of calculus prior to it, and you get to watch the moment when they realize all of this stuff has been "hiding in plain sight".
- dnprock 7y agoI think the reason is infinitesimal. Calculus touches infinities. And infinities are related. So we end up using infinities to describe each other.
- rq1 7y agoFor completeness’ sake, yes.
- hyperpallium 7y agoI always thought calculus should work equally well with rationals, because they are continuous (in that you can always get closer...)
- Hermitian909 7y agoThe problem is that under the hood calculus is all about limits (or methods with a certain equivalence, we won't get into that). Take a derivative? that's a limit. Take an integral? That's a limit. And limits of seemingly rational expressions are sometimes irrational, case and point the limit of (1 + 1/n)^n as n approaches infinity is euler's constant, e. So if you're taking limits with rationals you're going to find yourself with undefined limits (because irrational numbers are no longer defined) breaking things constantly. Formally, the irrationals are dense but not complete.
- Hermitian909 7y agoer, too late to edit but the rationals are dense but not complete (well, the irrationals too, but that wasn't what I was getting at)
- sseth 7y agoI thought they were dense in the reals, but disconnected as between any two rationals there will always be an irrational number.
- mjcohen 7y agoBut between any two irrationals (actually, any two reals) there are an infinite number of rationals.
- nerdponx 7y agorationals, because they are continuous (in that you can always get closer...) You sort of can't get arbitrarily close. And that's the whole reason calculus doesn't work for rationals. Rationals fundamentally have "gaps", and correspond 1:1 with integers.
- Koshkin 7y agoSo, TL;DR:, one cannot build a meaningful calculus using the rational numbers alone. Not unexpected, judging by its history... A more interesting (to me, anyway) fact is that one can build (or "model") any number system - all integers, rationals, reals, etc. - using just the set of natural numbers (i.e. positive integers).
- Jaxan 7y agoWell building the reals from rationals is not easy at all. It took a few decades to get a reasonable definiton. And in constructive mathematics, there are several competing (non equivalent) definitions of the reals. It's a very deep topic, yet we seem to understand (at least in calculus) what real numbers are.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> try to measure both a side and a diagonal of a square using the same measuring-stick, you’ll run into trouble Because you never end up with whole numbers both ways?
- mjcohen 7y agoCorrect. Incommensurable - lacking a common measure. The side and diagonal of an isosceles right triangle are incommensurable - there is no length that goes into both an integer number of times. There is a proof of this in Euclid.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoEudoxus! A Pythagorean mathematician who studied under the philosopher-king Archytas and Plato. He also put forward a compelling argument for hedonism, preserved by Aristotle.
- scarmig 7y agoNaive question: Can you build something like calculus on a number system weaker than the reals, but stronger than the rationals? What's the weakest you could go?
- sverona 7y agoIt's unclear what precisely you mean by 'weaker', but if you mean with regard to completeness - the reals are the so-called completion of (that is, the smallest complete metric space containing) the rationals; so you're kind of stuck.
- liuyao 7y agoYou can weaken "completeness" though. In each of its many manifestations, completeness asks for the existence of something for all subsets (sequences, functions, ...) of reals. We can instead ask for the ones that are definable by finite means (aka computable, constructive). To find (=construct) the extreme value, for example, you probably won't be able to find a general procedure; it has to be treated case by case. Now you'll appreciate how easy real numbers are. It gives the assurance that the extreme values exist. I would not have thought it would interest Hacker News readers, but here's more about computable numbers: https://observablehq.com/@neobourbaki/computable-numbers https://observablehq.com/@neobourbaki/computable-numbers
- sverona 7y agoThis is really cool. My advisor is a strict constructivist and will tell anyone with ears about finitism after a few beers, and I've always found it a useful philosophical position.
- tathougies 7y agoHow do you define something 'like' calculus? How do you define 'number' system? If by number system you mean arbitrary ring and by calculus you mean the derivative for example, then yes, but it's not super interesting. For example, the structure of algebraic data types forms a ring, and you can define an operation 'like' the derivative on it. However, given that only two operations (multiplication and addition) are commonly defined here, it's not particularly involved, although the result itself is quite useful (the derivative of the algebraic form of a data type is the type of one-holed versions of that same data type).
- carapace 7y agoSort of a tangent but uh... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surreal_number > ...the surreal number system is a totally ordered proper class containing the real numbers as well as infinite and infinitesimal numbers... Invented by Conway while studying Go.
- eugf_ 7y agoNice bait
- btilly 7y agoOne correction. The root of rational and irrational is the word "ratio". Rational numbers are ratios of integers. Irrational numbers are not ratios of integers. It is a linguistic coincidence that we wound up with words that has another reasonable meaning.
- jonny_eh 7y agoIt's amazing that I went through high school and multiple calculus courses in college without ever learning that. Thanks!
- robocat 7y agoAlso a person that is rational, and a person that is rationalising, are opposite meanings: rationalisations are deeply irrational.
- cshimmin 7y agoThe author notes this in the article.
- smallnamespace 7y ago> linguistic coincidence It's not a coincidence. The root of both ratio and rational come from latin ratio, gerund of reri, 'to calculate, to reckon, to think'. To the ancients, just like us, computation, thinking, and reasoning are linked. Irrational numbers were literally numbers that 'could not be reckoned' in the normal sense. You can even go further with this analogy. The halting function is not computable because there is no finite procedure that tells whether any program halts. But this objection to infinity is also what the ancient Greeks had to continuity (Zeno's paradoxes) and irrational numbers, as there is no finite procedure that results in an exact answer. In fact, there is no bounded algorithm that can distinguish sqrt(2) on all possible numeric inputs.
- xamuel 7y agoNonsense, the digits of sqrt(2) most definitely are computable and there are bounded algorithms that can check, given inputs n and k, whether or not n is the kth digit of sqrt(2).
- Smaug123 7y agoPropp himself (the author) wrote a paper in 2012 called Real Analysis In Reverse, which he links to in the post but doesn't really call attention to. It's a lovely paper, and it talks about precisely what properties of the reals are enough to tell you that you really are dealing with the reals - like his example of the Constant Value Theorem from the post. https://arxiv.org/abs/1204.4483 https://arxiv.org/abs/1204.4483
- geebee 7y agoLove it. I remember reading (might have been here) that math and art both get difficult at the same moment for the same reason. When you're a kid, you live in the rational world. By this, I mean numbers that can be expressed as the ratio of two integers. Human creations are rational. The volume of a square is a neat, tidy equation. So is the area of a square. You can draw them easily, too, using a ruler and clean nifty lines, and they look great. Squares are all over human creation. You can draw a car with straight lines and squares. Wheels and other things bring in this inconvenient number, pi, that is "irrational", but let's just go with three point blah blah and it'll be fine. At least the curvature is constant. So, where are the squares in nature? Hell, where are the circles. Where is the constant curvature. How do you draw a leaf, a tree, a face? How do you calculate the surface volume of a leaf, or the volume of a tree? All of a sudden, you can't measure it with the numbers you know. There is no neat ratio of integers that will calculate the volume of that tree trunk. Or even the volume under an easily expressed mathematical equation on a graph. In fact once you start measuring nature, rather than the things people make, rational numbers aren't anywhere. All of a sudden, you have to deal with limits, sequences, strange numbers that can be made arbitrarily close to zero as other numbers approach infinity. It turns out every number is "irrational", pretty much nothing is rational. So, instead of irrational, let's call it Real. Where do math and art get hard? When you start to describe things as they are, rather than as we imagine the to be. You know, Real.
- com2kid 7y ago> So is the area of a square. Try to cut that square in half diagonally and things get irrational really fast! FWIW I thought calculus made a lot of sense and helped make the world make more sense. Algebra is a fancy set of rules to manipulate rather abstract symbols, calculus actually explains how real things work!
- geebee 7y agoGood example. It's amazing how quickly you leave the rationals, even with a square, you almost immediately need numbers that can't be expressed as the ratio of two integers... historically, was that the first encounter with an "irrational" number (Pythagorean theorem applied to a right isosceles triangle)? I do remember the proof from number theory about 20 years ago, though I could never recreate it now from memory.
- bumbledraven 7y ago> To paraphrase Obi-Wan Kenobe: The completeness property of the reals is what gives calculus its power. It surrounds the set of real numbers and penetrates it. It binds the number line together. :)
- ncmncm 7y ago"Thank you very much, but I will buy the Computable numbers, instead. They do not require abandoning my sanity (although I am aware I must still abandon rationality)." In particular, the reals mean you accept measure theory, which in one of its key results says you can build two spheres of radius x from one sphere of radius x, and no holes. The computables don't go there. There are infinitely many computable numbers, but only countably many -- no more than of natural or rational numbers. That turns out to be enough for everything sane you want to do. Of course you need altered versions of the key theorems of calculus, because the computables are not continuous in the "real" sense. The numbers blur a bit, instead, to cover the gaps, much as water manages to behave like a fluid despite being made of nothing but discrete particles. The differences are a PITA but keep you on the straight and narrow. You get the same answers for everything that makes sense, and no answer for things that don't. All the supposedly real numbers you will ever encounter are computable (too). Roots, pi, e, anything representable with a Taylor series. So you don't really give anything up. Reals make a good enough approximation, which means you don't need to go hungry. Pretend you're using reals. Nobody needs to know. Everybody else is, too. The sane, anyway.
- joppy 7y agoMeasure theory also tells you that if you managed to make two solid balls of radius 1 from cutting up a single solid ball of radius 1, then some of the intermediate pieces you cut the original ball into must have been non-measurable sets. Non-measurable sets are known to behave counterintuitively, and are avoided when using measure theory (since they cannot be assigned a volume). Is “garbage in, garbage out” so unreasonable?
- aeneasmackenzie 7y agoWhy use a system where you have to check if you put garbage in?
- joppy 7y agoYou have to check if a number is zero before you divide by it, you need to check if a number is positive before you take its log, you need to check it a set is measurable before you measure it or integrate over it. I don’t really see how any of these are significantly different.
- kavalec 7y agoCalculus: the art of dividing by zero without getting caught.
- perl4ever 7y agoThat phrase makes me think of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renormalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renormalization
- slaymaker1907 7y agoI liked his comment that irrationals really aren’t that unreasonable in the common sense of the term. There are so many questions on Quora which demonstrate people are really uncomfortable with transcendental/irrational constants like pi and e. While you can approximate those as much as you like, the true monsters like Chaitin’s constant cannot be approximated at all.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI am reminded of the ironic irrationality of ancient thinking insisting that rational numbers numbers must exist with things like Pythagoreans murdering over it - apocryphal admittedly. But the same pattern appears for other numbers and systems like the complex and imaginary and non-euclidian geometry which caused "rational" people to be filled with such rage. It is an interesting pattern that anyone who insists upon their "rational" or "sane" systems in the face of reality tends to actually deeply unhinged.
- your-nanny 7y agoMy first inkling that I had no clue about the reals was when I first thought hard about the fact that you can have a bijection between intervals of different length, eg (0, 1) and (0, 10).
- squirrelicus 7y agoThis has nothing to do with calculus and everything to do with the fact that there are an infinite number of irrational numbers between any two rational numbers. Indeed, if you randomly select a real number, you can be almost certain that you will select an irrational number. Of course, almost certain has a specific rigorous meaning: the probability of not selecting (in this case, an irrational number) is greater than zero, but less than all real numbers, i.e. Infinitesimal. Edit: spelling Edit: the infinitesimal belongs not in the real numbers, but in the hyperreal numbers, if you want to learn more