3 ms·
You're substantially overestimating China's political and economic stability. Large authoritarian regimes like China's simply do not have a track record of las
by yellowapple 7y ago
You're substantially overestimating China's political and economic stability. Large authoritarian regimes like China's simply do not have a track record of lasting long. Tibet and Taiwan and Hong Kong are just the beginning; the harder China squeezes the sand, the faster it will slip through its fingers. Don't believe me? Ask the Soviets.
Come to think of it, the PRC is right around the same age the USSR was when it collapsed...
- coldtea 7y ago>Large authoritarian regimes like China's simply do not have a track record of lasting long. Compared to what? There have been millennia old authoritarian regimes. Compared to those, democratic states are a flash in the pan. Heck, China itself (pre communism) has lasted and prospered for 5-10 times the duration of most modern nation states, while authoritarian. Not to mention that this "authoritarian" is overblown as it concerns the ordinary billions of citizens. They might persecute religions minorities, but as far as the average Joe and Jane is concerned they never had it better (and they get richer in each generation that their parents, something many places in the west can't say). P Then they see Trump, Macron, Salvini, and co, and don't really get what the fuss with western democracy is all about... >Tibet and Taiwan and Hong Kong are just the beginning The beginning of what? Taiwan is where the non-commies went (and it was a dictatorship of its own, for most of its life, not to mentioned founded by a guy who murdered a million people or so, which while not Mao level, is not shabby a track record). Hong Kong got used to another level of autonomy, especially for elites and businesses (though itself was purchased back in the day by a colonial power that had devastated the main land, yay for democracy). As for Tibet, it's like China's Puerto Rico or Hawaii, only at least they had a slither of a legitimate historical claim to the place. >Come to think of it, the PRC is right around the same age the USSR was when it collapsed... If wishes were horses...
- yellowapple 7y ago> There have been millennia old authoritarian regimes. At the risk of moving goalposts, I probably should have specified "lasting long after the 1700's". Countries in relatively-modern times are generally more likely to move from authoritarian to democratic than the other way around. Once the proletariat has tasted actual freedom and self-determination, going back to being ruled under an iron fist ain't (usually) something done voluntarily. Also, I specified large authoritarian regimes. Small nations can more easily be authoritarian (interference from large democratic nations aside) because it's easy to keep a small population under control. That gets much harder with a large population, and China's population certainly ain't getting any smaller. It's impressive (in a "wow that took a lot of effort" sense, not a "wow that's pretty cool" sense) that a nation as large as the PRC has been able to maintain such an iron fist on such a large population, but it's also pretty young, and time will tell if it'll actually buck the trend of China constantly fragmenting and reuniting over and over again. Speaking of which: > Heck, China itself (pre communism) has lasted and prospered for 5-10 times the duration of most modern nation states, while authoritarian. "China" has a history of constantly fragmenting and reuniting over and over again. It also has a history of expanding and contracting over and over again (though in fairness that had a lot to do with the Mongols and Huns). China's currently in the "large and unified" part of the cycle, but - if history is anything to go by, and I posit that it is - a contraction and/or fracture is inevitable. It probably would've happened already (i.e. during the series of nationwide protests that included the Tienanmen Square protesters that China "didn't" massacre), but China had enough propaganda and censorship tools up its sleeve to sweep all that under the rug (we'll see how long that survives here in the Information Age; China can beef up its Great Firewall all it wants, but people will continue to poke holes in it, making it harder and harder for China to assert its official narratives as the "truth"). > as far as the average Joe and Jane is concerned they never had it better Sure, until the Communist Party decides Joe and Jane don't have enough social credit to be allowed to meaningfully participate in society, and then they're screwed. > and they get richer in each generation that their parents For now, and only because they've transitioned from "complete and utter poverty" to "almost at basic Western standards of living". China's growth is already slowing down (at least as far as numerous economists with way more knowledge than I've got have assessed), so this is decreasingly-guaranteed to hold true for future generations.