8 ms·
I completely agree on your general point. We elect leaders, not functionaries. I don’t really buy the expertise argument. Who gets to choose the experts? For
by simonh 7y ago
I completely agree on your general point. We elect leaders, not functionaries.
I don’t really buy the expertise argument. Who gets to choose the experts?
For me it’s about accountability. If you want to get a job done, vote for a party that has that thing in their manifesto, and hold them to delivering on it. The problem with direct democracy is, who is responsible for delivering the policies? How can they be accountable for the outcome, if they didn’t formulate or even agree with the policy?
Choose a government and then let them govern. Scrutinise them, challenge them, hold them to account on the things they committed to. That’s how our (British) democracy should work. The reason we’re in this mess is because parliament is being coerced into implementing a policy most parliamentarians disagree with, and even the interpretation of what the referendum meant is up for grabs.
If we can’t agree anything else, can we at least agree not to do anything this way again?