5 ms·
Having a system that tells malware authors precisely what behavior triggered an alarm is also not great. There is no solution.
by UncleMeat 7y ago
Having a system that tells malware authors precisely what behavior triggered an alarm is also not great. There is no solution.
- baroffoos 7y ago"Your app has been removed because it was found to be malware. Please reply to this message if you believe this to be a mistake." Doesn't help malware authors at all.
- bcrosby95 7y agoApparently he had zero trouble with antivirus apps fixing his situation. But I guess Google is so special it can't accomplish what companies with a fraction of Google's budget or manpower can do.
- kace91 7y agoThat doesn't seem to be a problem in any other field of security in the world. If you steal a shirt from a shop you'll get told whether they hace security footage of you stealing, an alarm went off or a security guard saw you. It might be more convenient for google to not say, but it's pretty disrespectful towards clients that choose their platform to make a living and might get caught as a false positive.
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoThere is a very simple solution. Have a competetent reviewer look at the code and decide whether the intent is malicious or not. If the intent is clearly not malicious and no rules were broken, the reviewer should file a bug report to fix the virus scanner and reinstate the developer account. No further explanation required. If rules were breached but it may have been done in good faith, issue a warning to the developer and explain in general terms how to fix the problem. Charge a review fee high enough to deter any abuse of the review system.
- cmsj 7y ago"Have a competent reviewer" - requires humans, humans don't scale, proposed solution is not Googley. (this is sarcasm, but from talking to Googler friends over the years, I doubt it's far from the truth)
- fauigerzigerk 7y agoIt scales just fine if they charge enough to discourage abuse. Also, the law should frankly require them to offer proper conflict resolution if they run one of two commercially viable app stores.