This seems to be a review of Julia as a general-purpose programming language. For example the reviewer points out early that the review is not targeted at peopl

This seems to be a review of Julia as a general-purpose programming language. For example the reviewer points out early that the review is not targeted at people who like Matlab's syntax. So this reads a little bit like yet another review of a math DSL, written by and for people who don't need or like math DSLs. Not surprisingly, it comes out negative.