5 ms·
I don’t get it - the media companies didn’t create these bad situations - they’re reporting people trying to do the best they can with the hands they’re dealt.
by chrisseaton 7y ago
I don’t get it - the media companies didn’t create these bad situations - they’re reporting people trying to do the best they can with the hands they’re dealt. What should they do? Criticise people trying to help because it could be better elsewhere?
Home Depot employees can’t change national attitudes to healthcare but they can build someone a walker, so they’re bad people?
- snek 7y agoWell if you read the article, they say that the media should take these stories as opportunities to discuss pressing social issues instead of skating around them. Reporting is about bringing cohesive context to information, and these stories do the opposite.
- whatshisface 7y ago>Reporting is about bringing cohesive context to information Policy discussion is about bringing cohesive context to information. Reporting is about reporting information.
- ggggtez 7y agoDo you really think reporters just state facts and call it a day? How do they know which facts are the important ones to say? Why not list the shoesize of everyone they interview, along with the name of their dog? Obviously, I'm making a point: Facts tell a story. The reporters for these stories are choosing what facts tell the narrative they think people want (triumph over adversity) without mentioning the facts that they think people don't want (acknowledging that the healthcare system in the US is broken for most Americans).
- whatshisface 7y agoThere's a subtle difference between sorting based on priority and compiling facts to suit a narrative. If you start with a narrative, you will fall prey to things like confirmation bias. There's nothing wrong with prioritizing the most important information, but it's very bad to say "today I am going to prove that XYZ" before going around prioritizing all the facts that would make XYZ seem real. It's a fine line between journalism and opinion pieces. To get a better perspective of this, imagine a reporter that earnestly believed something you disagreed with. You'd probably want them to stick to the facts instead of tying every world event to their favorite policy.
- adamisom 7y ago"Some Home Depot workers built a walker". That's information. That is not (all) reporters do.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Well if you read the article It’s against site guidelines here to accuse people of not reading the article - please don’t do this.
- sbhn 7y agoYour not supposed to talk about ‘not reading the article’, because HN doesn't want people to catch on that HN knows if you read the article. it’s a remarketing/cookie thing. HN knows what you did last summer.
- unreal37 7y agoBut you're not arguing against the point made in the article but something else. So...
- chrisseaton 7y agoI think I am - the article describes people trying to help as a 'reprehensible story treated as heroic'. The people trying to help can be heroic, even if they shouldn't have to help. Isn't that the situation for most people trying to help anyway? Ideally they wouldn't have to help. But they can still be heroic, not reprehensible.
- kaitai 7y agoIt seems to me you're confusing the grammar. The people are not reprehensible: reprehensible refers to the situation, instead. The situation in which two-year-olds are left without proper medical care and parents are left without any safety net is reprehensible. One should not paint the situation as wonderful when it is bad. Of course the people involved are simply trying their best, and trying to "make the best of a bad situation".
- chrisseaton 7y agoBut all situations that need help are reprehensible! Otherwise they wouldn't need help.
- droithomme 7y ago> they say that the media should take these stories as opportunities to discuss pressing social issues instead of skating around them That does happen sometimes and as a result the poor do-gooder that was just minding his own business and trying to help a family member or friend ends up being vilified and receiving threats. Even just saying hey here's a person that did a nice thing brings out haters. It gets much worse if the action is associated with a political viewpoint that significant numbers of people oppose for any reason. I would never ever ever want any of my good deeds to be highlighted in some media article. It would be no end of trouble. Don't talk to cops. Don't talk to reporters.
- mlyle 7y agoIt's a fair complaint, but often is over-stretched to situations where it doesn't fit well. e.g. Those kids who came up with a creative solution for a disabled 2 year old to play and be entertained deserve to be commended. Yes, it's horrible there's a disabled two year old, but...
- goldcd 7y agoThe point is that in most Western countries (US aside), the idea that the folks down the local hardware store made a medical device is simply bizarre. My NHS is most certainly not perfect, but provides a decent safety net. They'd have provided a walker, and maybe the local DIY store might build a playground for local kids in the park.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> the idea that the folks down the local hardware store made a medical device is simply bizarre Well yeah it was bizarre enough in the US to be a news story as well.
- goldcd 7y agoThe point of the article is that "These DIY staffers built this handy contraption" - but also that the stories they reference seem to consider it entirely normal that if they hadn't this child would have been shit-out-of-luck. It's incredibly strange visiting/talking to Americans how many (of all backgrounds) have this aversion to "socialism" If somebody steals your wallet, you're fine with calling a Police force. If your house is on fire, you'll call the fire brigade. If somebody attacks your country, you'll invoke your military. If your child is sick, you'll dig out some insurance paper-work and see if you're covered for treatment - as god-forbid you could just consider "getting sick" something you might want resolved by your government as an acceptable use of your taxes. The normal pushback when I raise this is some weird idea that this would in some way force sub-standard treatment on all (tax can't pay for great treatment for everyone). This isn't the case. I have private healthcare insurance in the UK from my employer (like many of us do) - but it tends to be used for the little things. Sports-injury clinics, elective surgery at the time of our choosing etc. If anything serious happens to us - then the NHS is the preferred option (private healthcare doesn't even provide A&E, trauma etc). If your need is great, then you'll be triaged to the top of everything and get whatever you need.
- harperlee 7y agoGive it less spin and using the opportunity to denounce current status of healthcare in the biggest economy of the world? The social function of the press (“the 4th power”) is to coordinate attention of the people. Spinning those stories as uplifting porn is disfunctional; at least, missed opportunities; at worst, opium that numbs social change.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> using the opportunity to denounce current status Err that sounds like more spin not less?
- harperlee 7y agoJust giving broader context of the news in question, and how e.g. it is exceptional for a first world country to have children working in order to pay for their brother’s health treatments (an example in the linked article), would be very effective, and IMHO not spin at all. I’m aware though that discussing reality is sometimes “too political”...
- throwaway2048 7y agoThe media can change national attitudes by the way a story is presented. Presenting tragedies like this as a situation where you just need to be strong, work hard and pray for miracles, rather than bothering to broach the root issues causing the tragedy to begin with very much helps to ensure they keep happening.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- netsharc 7y agoI think the article briefly mentioned it: that the news stories could use these heroic struggles to highlight the inadequate system that caused them to be on that struggle. Several paragraphs to say that in first world countries these people wouldn't be needing to do whatever they painstakingly did would shape a public opinion of "hey, government, you're sort of failing us..?". But maybe that would be propaganda, or activism? I suppose one function of the fourth estate is to challenge the government, and when the sort of mentioned shit is happening in the richest country in the world...
- heydenberk 7y agoI think there are two related issues. First, the tenor of these articles betrays a general middle-to-upper-class bias in the media. For people who are poor, these stories are more traumatic than inspiring, which means that these are stories by rich people for rich people about poor people which don't take into account the actual lived experiences of poor people. More importantly, though, these stories rarely criticize the systems that cause these horrors — America's broken healthcare system which revisits injuries upon the poor and sick, zoning and development practices that breed homelessness, cruel school lunch programs that punish poor kids for having poor parents.
- bobwaycott 7y ago> ... these are stories by rich people for rich people about poor people which don't take into account the actual lived experiences of poor people. I think the article means to take it a step further—these are stories by rich people for [mostly] rich people about poor people that build and reinforce a narrative and expectation that the context of the perseverance isn’t the real story. By crafting/telling/writing/broadcasting perseverance porn, media are objectifying and fetishizing perseverance in a manner that enables the audience to ignore the context and enjoy the “good stuff”—all while normalizing the horrific circumstances of each story. Perseverance is not only possible, it’s the goal! Meanwhile, viewers can sit back and blame those who didn’t persevere for their outcomes. > The problem with perseverance porn is not the brave subjects of the articles, but the lack of any journalistic scrutiny examining the failings of society that placed them in such desperate circumstances to begin with. > What these articles highlight so clearly is not only the grim, inhuman and unnecessary conditions so many Americans are forced to live under, but the degree to which mainstream corporate journalists have completely internalized them as unremarkable, inevitable facts of life, rather than the consequences of decades of neoliberal policies that have robbed Americans of dignity and basic human rights.
- wayoutthere 7y agoIt's a bit disingenuous to criticize neoliberal policy without also criticizing the neoconservative policies that aggressively privatized and defunded the delivery of any social benefits -- thus ensuring a significant portion of the funding ended up on corporate balance sheets rather than to provide actual services to people. Neoliberal policy may have built a house out of dry wood, but neoconservative policy lit the match.
- nabla9 7y agoWrite news about the issues causing the situation and do representative sample of these stories. These feel good stories are entertainment. They leave out those success stories that would make people sick in their stomach. Like a woman getting cancer and her mother working as a prostitute every day to get money for the treatments. I would like that story told with chirp voices and beautiful guitar tune in the background with the daughter and the mother smiling. "And we finish with a beautiful inspiring story of love. It's about a churchgoing mother in a small Arkansas town who prostituted herself for three years to save her daughter."
- mistermann 7y agoThis would make a good YouTube channel. Maybe some people would wake up and see what's happening right in front of their eyes.
- netsharc 7y agoThe alternative isn't to criticise the HD employees, in fact, guess who can change said national attitude? How about people whose reporting are read by millions? They can highlight what the employees did, but at how insanely broken the system is, that this needs to be done. Maybe ask their representatives for an opinion, and writing "The area's congressmen and senators did not respond when we contacted them" is enough of a wake up call, to make the public see...
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoIt isn't that these stories exist, but the tone one takes with them. I mean, sure, Home Depot employees can't change everyone's attitudes to health care, but the folks talking about it and giving it national attention could frame it differently. "If we had national health care, our Home Depot employees could spend time helping folks with fun things or growing food instead of building children wheelchairs" You can still pile on the praise of the individual while denouncing the system that made this situation be necessary.
- rndmize 7y agoPieces like this can be read in two ways: as an individual success, or as a societal failure. Making a walker for some poor disabled person can be seen as an individual success because a person in need was helped, and there were others generous enough to make that happen. But it can be seen as a society failure because most likely, they aren't the only one in that position, and the others that never receive help go unmentioned and unconsidered. In focusing on the individual perspective, you could argue that articles like this subtly promote a certain set of views/assumptions - "people get what they deserve", "those that work hard get ahead", "individual charity is better than gov programs", "this is just the way things are". The societal failure perspective is at odds with these and would like to see things approached from a different set of view/assumptions - "unequal opportunity from birth results in people not getting what they deserve", "success in life is mostly luck", "societal problems should be solved for everyone that has them", "we can make things better". Reddit actually has a perfect reflection of this - stories that appear on r/UpliftingNews will sometimes also appear on r/ABoringDystopia, with the different perspectives becoming apparent in the discussions.
- unreal37 7y agoHello straw man. Not one person ever called Home Depot employees "bad people". Not one person ever said the media "created these bad situations". But why is it normal that a 2 year old can't walk and nothing can be done to help him EXCEPT by Home Depot employees? Why isn't part of the story mentioning how there's no affordable or free program to help 2-year-olds walk?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> But why is it normal that a 2 year old can't walk and nothing can be done to help him EXCEPT by Home Depot employees? It's not normal that Home Depot helped. That's why it's a new story. > Why isn't part of the story mentioning how there's no affordable or free program to help 2-year-olds walk? Because that's not news - that's how things already are. News is unusual and interesting things. Reporting that the state of US healthcare is unchanged is not news.
- safeguard77 7y agoIt's because these stories direct the narrative in such way that goes a bad thing happened but it all turned out okay in the end. "Such a terrible {condition/experience/situation} -> But look they {over came/received crowdfunding/received support}. Everything is okay, and aren't you moved by the {courage/support} of this story?" Instead of saying all of that AND then also noting "And this child who clearly needs a walker, would not have been able to get one due to an INSANE cost of {price}, yet when a suitable replacement came about from literally a hardware store costing {price}? Why is our healthcare charging 50x more " etc etc Do you see where thats really fucked up now? All of these stories typically and conveniently skip over the root causes of these issues -> Where did the {tragedy/trial} come from?
- Hendrikto 7y agoThe media could mention that the world does not have to look this dire. These “heroic” actions should not be needed.
- ggggtez 7y ago>Home Depot employees can’t change national attitudes I'd say you're wrong on two counts. The first is that no one is saying it's the Home Depot employees that should be doing it. The article makes it clear that the media should be presenting the story in a way that ties it to the national conversation, instead of ignoring the implications of how these stories keep happening. The second, is that actually Home Depot employees can change national attitudes. There is this thing called Unionizing that allows workers to call for strikes and bargain for better working conditions. Such a union could help contribute to a difficult conversation about the need of our companies and government entities to protect the health of our most vulnerable, which most likely would include a sizeable number of those same workers.