5 ms·
I fail to see the comparison with Groupon. Most people who have used Groupon have mixed reviews about the product, it worked sometimes but most of the times it
by baby 7y ago
I fail to see the comparison with Groupon. Most people who have used Groupon have mixed reviews about the product, it worked sometimes but most of the times it didn't.
WeWork on the other hand seems like they have a solid product?
Maybe they are not profitable, and maybe the business model makes no sense and will never be profitable. In that sense then maybe you are right?
But in the mean time, the product they are selling works for their customers and there is high demand at the current price point (which is already insane imo).
- netsharc 7y agoTo expand on your 3rd paragraph, maybe that's the Ponzi scheme, with big investors playing along: 1. Start a shiny business that attracts customers. Never mind that you're losing money per customer. 2. Get some big investors. You are now valued at 2-digit-billion dollars. 3. Talk about IPO. The general investing public has heard about your shiny service/product because the news talks about how shiny and hip you are (are MSNBC just idiots so easily distracted?) and the public are about to bite! 4. IPO. Big investors cash out. Mom-and-Pop investors lose money. 5. Profit! For you and your big investors.
- baby 7y agoThis makes me wonder, how many companies in a similar position (great product with a good demand) have failed and shut down to the misfortune of its customers? I see similar talks about Uber, and yet I can't imagine such a product failing due to the number of happy customers.
- striking 7y agohttps://thehustle.co/Doughbies-cookies-shut-down/ https://thehustle.co/Doughbies-cookies-shut-down/ is one that I know quite a few people feel strongly about.
- baby 7y agoIt sounds like it was mostly about the founders not wanting to continue maintaining a business that was not a unicorn. There was someone else on HN that posted about a similar company but decided to buy back equity and continue maintaining it.
- csande17 7y agoSee also: MoviePass, which failed somewhere between (2) and (3) because they were a little too obvious about doing (1).
- enjo 7y agoIn a Ponzi scheme you commit fraud. You make false claims about returns, and then use downstream investors money (enticed by those false claims) to pay off upstream investors to keep the scheme going. This is a stock sale. The "mom and pop investors" buy into it with full knowledge of what they're buying. It might be a bad investment, but I don't see where the fraud comes in? I'm not convinced that WeWork is a sustainable business which is why I won't invest in it. Others might disagree.. we'll find out down the road who is right.
- wpietri 7y agoI think that's why they said "modern ponzi scheme". And no, mom-and-pop investors don't have full knowledge, not like insiders do. The fraud would come in if the insiders are being anything less than perfectly honest about current condition, future prospects, or their expectations. Of course, this might not rise to the level of criminal fraud. But when you look at something like Groupon, which fell 90% quite quickly, and which had insiders taking money out early on, it's reasonable to suspect that at least some insiders knew what they were selling to the public was dubious, but did it anyhow.
- wpietri 7y agoThe comparison is that Groupon was exciting and hot at the time of the IPO, allowing investors and insiders to hype it and make a very profitable exit. But it turned out not to be great long term for a variety of reasons, so the stock price quickly fell (it's trading at something like 90% off peak). Groupon is still a functioning business, of course, with something like $2bn/year in revenue. And WeWork might end up a functioning business as well, just like its competitors. But I think its best case is to end up like those competitors, which all have thin margins and look like regular old businesses, not profit fountains like Google, etc.