3 ms·
From watching these sites for years, I think you can see whatever bias you want to see. Some sites/authors do have clear bias, but a lot of it is just time pres
by toast0 7y ago
From watching these sites for years, I think you can see whatever bias you want to see. Some sites/authors do have clear bias, but a lot of it is just time pressure.
Often, review parts are shipped to sites with a review embargo until a certain date -- if you don't ship your review on that date, you lose out; if the shipment is late because of the vendor, or the shipping service, or the reviewer is sick, or out of town, or the shipped firmware isn't great and interim firmware makes a big difference the choices are:
a) take the time to do a full review, but publish late
b) do a cursory review, apologize and publish on time
c) do b, but follow up with a full review as time permits
If C happens more with AMD than Intel, it could be bias, it could be bad luck, or it could be Intel has been delivering more finished things to reviewers.
- close04 7y agoAT shouldn't get worse treatment than any other review site. If all the others can post detailed benchmarks or cover an event and only AT has consistent issues and bad luck at some point a pattern emerges. I get that I can also be biased. But bias should be like noise, taking all of the articles together should average it out. In AT's case it's more like the signal rather than the noise. What really capped it off for me was not covering a public event that every other website covered, like the 2017 Threadripper launch. The signal was that they are even willing to ignore one of the most interesting launches in years to post articles about trivial motherboard announcements. I would never mind if Intel launched some awesome new CPU. Then the confirmation came the following year, coincidentally also during a Threadripper event when they wrote multiple articles touting Intel's new 5GHz 28 core CPU. They missed the fact that it was a massive overclock chilled by an (admittedly hidden) 1HP chiller and their experience raised no red flags where even the comments did. But worse, when the bubble burst unlike every other publication AT's response was an anemic piece excusing Intel and with the literal conclusion that "the 28-core announcement was not ideally communicated". I understand Intel's shenanigans to try to steal some of the attention that TR is getting. But as a journalist being played like that should trigger a more visible reaction. Consistently painting them in a good light just raises suspicions for me. And while I still read their articles I no longer take them or the conclusion at face value unless another big site confirms it.
- ksec 7y agoYes I totally understand that, and you could literally count with one hand how many people are working in Anandtech. But sometimes I just want 2 Sentence on their Frontpage. Like 1) Today is the launch of AMD Threadripper, here are the Spec. It is exciting to test ( hype ) and we intend to publish a full review within 2 weeks. Rather than just stay silent on the issue. 2) Today there is a new Intel threat called X, as published here ( Intel Official Documentation ) and here ( Likely the Bug have its own webpage now ). We may cover it with more details in the future. I understand they have timing and staff issues. But two sentence will show they knew of the issue / press/ release rather than staying Silent on it. May be Anandtech wants to be a pure review site, but then it is not has a section called News Pipeline. Staying silent on anything at Intel's disadvantage makes me question if they have slight bias towards Intel.