5 ms·
I get why certain keywords (e.g. "crisis actors") are ranked down, YouTube has rightfully been under fire for actively promoting this crap. What I don't get is
by mschuster91 7y ago
I get why certain keywords (e.g. "crisis actors") are ranked down, YouTube has rightfully been under fire for actively promoting this crap.
What I don't get is why the author whines about rating content by source. Anyone basing a statement on Alex Jones, Breitbart or RT should be removed from any promotion (i.e. search, "next video") features, there can only be crap as a result of relying on these "sources". As long as Youtube doesn't remove the videos outright there is no censorship and frankly I wouldn't have any problems with removing them either.
Social media platforms need to wake up and realize they have a responsibility to society - just like "classic" media - and that is to further democratic discourse instead of helping to destroy it. Allowing lies and propaganda fabrications to spread is nothing less than destruction of democracy.
- rhabarba 7y agoHow is it "democratic discourse" to ignore statements of certain people? Last time I read a dictionary, democracy did not make a difference between citizens.
- mschuster91 7y ago> Last time I read a dictionary, democracy did not make a difference between citizens. To quote Karl Popper: "Unlimited tolerance must lead to the disappearance of tolerance. If we extend unlimited tolerance even to those who are intolerant, if we are not prepared to defend a tolerant society against the onslaught of the intolerant, then the tolerant will be destroyed, and tolerance with them." Democracy needs provable facts to work, it ceases to work when the electorate gets flooded by destructive lies.
- rhabarba 7y agoIf Google only shows provable facts in the future, Google is pretty much useless in the future.
- FakeComments 7y agoGoogle calls mainstream conservatives, including Jewish ones, Nazis in their internal documents. [1] Antifa attacks the elderly and journalists routinely, but face no censorship on Google. Google employees have repeatedly testified that Google is intentionally trying to steer public perception, and that they knowingly lied about doing so to Congress. [2] Google is not on the side of tolerance. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noHtKljPgJc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=noHtKljPgJc [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_XzcTINGOg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_XzcTINGOg
- agsilvio 7y agoTolerance leads to intolerance, and we don't want that so we better not tolerate some stuff. Karl Popper sounds like a real winner.
- andrepd 7y agoYes, that's his point. Tolerating "Jews should not be able to vote" as an opinion will ironically lead to a less tolerant society. You must be intolerant with the intolerant.
- tux1968 7y agoYou literally just said "Jews should not be able to vote" and the world did not explode. Words are much more nuanced than you seem to want to believe. We are not equipped to properly censor them without doing much more damage than we do good.
- ftr45 7y agothat doesn't change the fact that tolerance should be limited
- loraa 7y agoTolerating if it doesn't line up with my personal ideology, it should be banned because I said so.
- goatinaboat 7y agoDemocracy needs provable facts to work I’m OK with this if Google takes full responsibility for the veracity of its search results and liability for any consequences of someone being misled. They won’t do that of course, they want the power without the responsibility.
- 34679 7y agoIs Google not "the intolerant" in this scenario?
- provolone 7y ago>provable facts Yet the human experience is subjective and fallible.
- toss1 7y agoHow is treating lies as if they were truth any form of legitimate discourse? Especially when the lies are specifically crafted to undermine democracy? Any durably functioning society has means to shun & shed liars & those who work to destroy the society. Treating rules as absolute rarely works well.
- syshum 7y agoThe biggest problem we have over Fake new and "lies" is too many people associate opinions and feelings with facts, and if anyone opposes those opinions or feelings then they are "Denying their reality" or "Their Truth" Further even factual "truth" should always questioned, debated, and explored, no one gave Google the power to say what is "Truth" and then to expel any other idea that challenges said "Truth" that is dangerous for society
- toss1 7y agoIndeed, far too many confound feelings vs facts. Of course truths should be debated, there is a difference between useful debate and shouting or deceit. To paraphrase Asimov, we should well remember that democracy does not mean that Alan's ignorance is equal to Bob's truth. It has been well demonstrated that trolls can easily and consistently derail even sound scientific discussions, destroying the discussion and even the forum, if allowed. One only need to look her at HN to see how much filtering & moderation work is required to maintain a valid discussion. Individuals have better discussions than mobs. There is no basis to think that large scale discussions need less filtering & moderation than tight communities, yet even this obvious concept is fought here...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- close04 7y agoThere's no democratic principle that forces you to listen to all opinions#. They just ensure you're free to have a voice (within the limits of the law) but they won't force anyone to listen to that voice or to amplify it. YouTube is an amplifier and while they give anyone a voice they're not forced by any law lo amplify its reach. Just like you won't go share my opinion with all your discussion partners. #is it anti-democratic if someone flags or downvotes a comment on HN? Are you or HN acting in an anti-democratic fashion by hiding and censoring that opinion? (obvious answer: no) Freedom and democracy are seriously misinterpreted these days.
- feanaro 7y agoBut discriminating certain videos negatively by removing them from certain features (such as search results) is still amplification, just with a factor < 1.
- close04 7y ago> with a factor < 1 How so? The video is there and it can be viewed. That is 1. That is your voice. It just gets no amplification while other voices do. Did you ever see Breitbart putting an anti-Breitbart opinion on the front page? Are they being anti-democratic by doing this? So I'll ask again, if you downvoted/flagged my comment thus making it less readable (factor < 1) did you act in an anti-democratic way? And if so how do you reconcile your actions with your words?
- feanaro 7y ago> So I'll ask again, if you downvoted/flagged my comment thus making it less readable (factor < 1) did you act in an anti-democratic way? And if so how do you reconcile your actions with your words? No, because I only have a limited amount of power in this regard. If I was HN the platform and I systematically silenced your comments simply on the basis that they were coming from you (and you were not rude and/or an obvious spammer), then I would be censoring you. While this is not necessarily anti-democratic since HN is not a government institution, it does get unsavoury rather quickly. And like it or not, it is more unsavoury the larger the entity (in terms of audience) doing it.
- cameronbrown 7y agoI don't understand why you're so comfortable having a giant corporation decide what's true. HN is so bizare sometimes.
- high_derivative 7y agoCynically, because he believes them on his side?
- koolba 7y ago... for now.
- sametmax 7y agoGoogle is not a public service. They are a for profit company. They are not our friends, their youtube ranking algo is not designed to be fair and improve the life of human kind. It's designed to make money. I don't get the outrage: we warned people for 15 years this would happen. Now people put all their eggs in the same basket and cry when things go wrong. Well, good. It's a learning opportunity.
- cameronbrown 7y agoThere is a massive, massive difference between a trillion dollar company optimising for money and optimising for "the truth". I prefer my corporations greedy instead of virtuous, it's much more trustworthy.
- PavlovsCat 7y agoThere is a lot of money and power in shaping what is considered to be true.
- pjc50 7y agoThe alternative is having a giant corporation heedlessly promote lies which will get people killed. "You shouldn't be able to poison the well" is not invalidated if the well is owned by a corporation.
- syshum 7y agoI see so only those with "correct opinions" should be allowed to talk Only those on the Authoritarian left should be allowed access to the Social Media Publishers (as they are not platforms) Libertarians and conservatives should be shut out of the conversations because of our wrong think... Nice position you have there comrade
- mschuster91 7y ago> I see so only those with "correct opions" should be allowed to talk No, exactly opposite: those who repeatedly and knowingly distribute lies to manipulate people (e.g. "crisis actor" crap) should be silenced, for they are not interested in furthering democratic discourse, but rather in destroying discourse.
- syshum 7y agoYou can point to extreme examples to supply support for your Draconian position, however the road to hell is paves with good intentions. For example I 100% oppose the Death Penalty, not because I want to protect the life of a serial killer, no it is because I want to protect the life (and rights) of the innocent guy that was not able to prove innocence to a biased jury... Similarly I do not support Free Speech because I want to defend conspiracy theorist that talk about crisis actors, no I do so because I want to defend the guys that talking about Government spying on everyone years before Snowden released the documents, I want defend the scientists that has the balls to say the Earth is not flat when everyone else says it is. Giving a corporation or government the power to silence anyone that they say is "wrong" is far far far too dangerous
- DuskStar 7y ago"only those with correct opinions should be allowed to talk" and "people with incorrect opinions should NOT be allowed to talk" are essentially equivalent. I'm really not sure how you don't see this.
- agsilvio 7y agoYeah. His was a real dumb comment.
- adolph 7y agoIf platforms edit like “classic” media, then they won’t count as distributors under Sec 230. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communications_Decency_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communicati...
- kmfrk 7y agoQuite the irony for people who disagree with you to vote your post down. Apparently that's the approved kind of censorship here.
- mschuster91 7y agoHN is (like Reddit) US-dominated, and with it comes that most of the users follow an absolutist version of "free speech" that is totally ridiculous for people coming from Europe who have learned from the Nazi regime where absolute limitless free speech can and inevitably will end.
- syshum 7y agoYea America should really learn from the EU and start putting people in prison for Twitter Jokes... /s
- andrepd 7y agoThe topic here is not twitter jokes, so refrain from derailing the conversation to your pet talking point.
- syshum 7y agoThe Topic here is censorship and how the US should take a position like EU and regulate the speech of its citizens, which includes things like Comedy
- DuskStar 7y agoDoes this mean we should 1. allow anything to be posted on Twitter, or 2. somehow determine whether something on twitter is a joke with perfect accuracy?
- acollins1331 7y agoWait until the Nazis end up in power anyway and have the powers of censorship you gave them. It'll be game over then, I'm glad to be in America and know I have the right to speak out against a fascist president.
- Amezarak 7y ago> Social media platforms need to wake up and realize they have a responsibility to society - just like "classic" media - and that is to further democratic discourse instead of helping to destroy it. Allowing lies and propaganda fabrications to spread is nothing less than destruction of democracy. There's another word to describe what you get when the ultra-rich and powerful are the ones that decide what's true and what's not: plutarchy. Further, I'm not so sure the classic media organizations see their responsibility the same way you do. The centralization of the media landscape resulting from the invention of radio and television was extremely pernicious: it led to the near-total control of news and information by a few people, who were able to effectively propagandize their interests to millions of Americans. These same media organizations worked hand-in-hand with the CIA and other intelligence agencies to advance falsehoods and propaganda. We have a long and sordid public history of things like Operation Mockingbird, and it never stopped. The same situation goes on today - what do you think all these "anonymous officials" are doing, who end up being cited repeatedly by the media, even after they prove to be lying, and why do you think media organizations actively hire people like John Brennan? The Internet has given us, for the first time in decades, the ability to read information not controlled and filtered by the news media/government establishment. It is difficult to see these efforts on the part of YouTube, Twitter, Facebook, and other platforms as anything other than an attempt under pressure (by the government and the classic media) to get the populace back under control and wholly informed only by government/plutarch approved information sources. For centuries, even millenia, "fake news" and propaganda have been real problems. There were arguments at the Constitutional Convention about how 'designing men' were already spreading lies and propaganda to influence elections. Rumors and propaganda caused all sorts of problems in democratic societies throughout history, which survived anyway. Democratic discourse means yes, letting everyone speak even when it means a lot of people will be misinformed. It means it's your duty to try to convince people otherwise, even if you have to do it a thousand times or a million times. It means that you are not the possessor of ultimate truth and you don't get to dictate the truth to others. Maybe that's not the best way to run a society. Maybe we should be trying to construct Plato's Republic and penalizing people who put out what we decide is harmful. But that's not democratic.
- giantsloth 7y agoThe fact is that, while the mainstream media pays attention to the far right outcry of censorship and demonetization, the left alternative media is also censored and demonetized on YouTube. YouTube is actively promoting the content of mainstream corporate sources that are inoffensive to advertisers with no say from its creators, it’s employees or its viewers/subscribers. And this is truly the fundamental problem. YouTube has zero accountability to anyone accept its advertisers, it’s major shareholders which there are few, and its board which there are few. YouTube being the only game in town, makes it impossible for the free market to allow you to move your eyeballs to another video platform. The fact is we need regulation and democratic oversight over YouTube as it is demonstrably a public good and a monopoly.
- deogeo 7y ago> As long as Youtube doesn't remove the videos outright there is no censorship As long as protests are limited to designated "free speech zones", there's no censorship either, right? Yes yes one is private and the other is public property, but the effect is the exact same. Worse, in fact - at least when you're herded into a free speech zone, you know your speech is being restricted. But when your video doesn't get many views, you have no idea.