4 ms·
FTP has some pretty serious quirks. Active-mode FTP is probably the craziest one by modern standards -- the client opens a port and asks the server to connect t
by duskwuff 7y ago
FTP has some pretty serious quirks. Active-mode FTP is probably the craziest one by modern standards -- the client opens a port and asks the server to connect to it to send a file. Needless to say, this is effectively unusable on the modern Internet. Its replacement, passive-mode FTP, has the server open a port instead; this configuration is merely incompatible with most load balancers.
- iforgotpassword 7y agoActive ftp is dead. I wouldn't be surprised if browsers don't support it out at least don't default to it since as you said it would break things for 99% of users. Running a server that's not configured properly for passive transfers is effectively a server that's useless. So if it would make someone sleep better at night I'd be fine with removing active transfer support from browser clients. Switch to filezilla if you're a power user or want to do some 1337 FXP tricks.
- dmix 7y agoIt's not much different than old versions of TLS.
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoOh, absolutely! I said it was ugly/stupid from personal experience:) But it's a form of stupid that can be condensed into a single state diagram that would fit on half a sheet of paper, so I'm not super concerned about it.
- hedora 7y agoIn ftp, the ftp server is designed to act as the load balancer. (Just have the firewall point each port to a different IP.) Also, this enables linear scale out, since not all ftp data nodes (not sure what the correct term was) need to store all of the data that’s being served, and you can store multiple copies of each file. Come to think of it, I’m not sure why HDFS exists, given that you can just use a ftp server cluster for the same effect.