2 ms·
I think there's significant equivocation going on here regarding the word "reasoning". Automated theorem proving is no more like human reasoning than a steam en
by perl4ever 7y ago
I think there's significant equivocation going on here regarding the word "reasoning". Automated theorem proving is no more like human reasoning than a steam engine was like John Henry.
All the stuff you talk about is rigid and omits the thing that makes human "reasoning" valuable - context switching.
I think technical people are often blind to this because they don't do very much of it themselves, but it's the fundamental thing that makes people different from machines, and complementary.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoApologies for the confusing terminology. When I say "reasoning" I mean it in the way it's used in logic-based AI where it basically means the automation of propositional and first-order theorem proving. I would say that we do have that down pat, as per my comment. I'm not sure what you mean by "context switching" but I will agree with you that following rigid inference rules is not how most people think most of the time. However, we do have the ability to think in this way and this way of thinking is very useful for certain problems where we can't just intuitively come up with a good solution. For instance, scientific thinking is of this kind. Historically what's really been missing from most attempts at simulating human reasoning is "common sense"- background knowledge about the way the world works. If we could successfully encode even a ten-year old's worldly knowledge, we could probably build an automated reasoning system that would appear much smarter than a ten-year old, by dint of it being a) much faster, b) much more accurate and c) much more, well, logical. But, we have so far failed to instill common sense to our programs and models so they remain at best idiot savants; if not simply idiots :/