5 ms·
Oh, I totally agree-- this was the point of my earlier comment about it being tactically "good enough" but not perfect. There is no doubt in my mind whatsoever
by wyclif 16y ago
Oh, I totally agree-- this was the point of my earlier comment about it being tactically "good enough" but not perfect. There is no doubt in my mind whatsoever that they knew all about the CCTV coverage in the hotel. I also think you're spot on about the blowback on the British passports. It was all calculated risk. In general, the article underestimates the technical savvy of Mossad-- see Stuxnet.
- varjag 16y agoGoing to take a dive here from Mossad fanboys, but Stuxnet can just as well (if not more likely) be a U.S. product, precisely due to its technical sophistication.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoMore likely a combination of both: Mossad for the details of what is inside Iran's program and deploying the worm, and the US for the technical skills to build it.
- CapitalistCartr 16y agoIsraeli software skills are excellent. Of all the assets the US could provide, that's one Israel doesn't need and likely wouldn't accept. The US could provide electronic surveillance: locations of people, details of local police operations, satellite photos, etc.
- varjag 16y agoWhile technically it can be done by anyone in the world, it takes certain thriving technology culture to ensure that enough smart people penetrate the ranks of employees in government bureaucracies. Israel's overall IT scene is non-remarkable, not any more than one of Sweden or Greece. The USA on the other hand, has decades-long successful track record of industrial sabotage involving computers, and NSA alone probably employs more talent than Mossad could ever afford to.
- forensic 16y agoIsrael doesn't just recruit from Israel. They recruit from Jews internationally. This is a major part of their strength. How many brilliant Jewish software people live in the USA? Those are the people Israel would recruit, along with their homegrown talent. Having said that I agree that the NSA would be more qualified than Israel at creating Stuxnet.
- iuguy 16y agoI hate to burst your bubble but as someone who's gone through stuxnet with a fine toothcomb more than once, there's nothing (as expected with decently written malware) that is directly attributable to a single country or intelligence service. Stuxnet has been heavily sensationalised by the media, who like the idea of intrigue more than the reality that this is a (predominantly) untargeted (it hit more targets in India than Iran when I was looking at it) but highly sophisticated piece of malware, but nothing that couldn't have been written by a decent pen test team in a few months. Is it a CNE (Computer Network Exploitation) act? Possibly, and the presence of Scada exploits indicates the possibility. But bear in mind that there are CANVAS (http://www.immunitysec.com/ http://www.immunitysec.com/) packs that have 0day SCADA exploits in them and they aren't written buy governments.
- wyclif 16y agodirectly attributable to a single country or intelligence service Except that I didn't say that Stuxnet was attributable only to one country, just that it was effective.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- iuguy 16y ago> In general, the article underestimates the technical savvy of Mossad-- see Stuxnet. I'm reading that as implying a link between Mossad and Stuxnet. If that's not what you're implying then I've misinterpreted your comment.