7 ms·
Do that in farming, and you'll be dealing with bread riots. Avoiding bread riots is why every single developed nation on Earth heavily subsidizes its farmers,
by vkou 7y ago
Do that in farming, and you'll be dealing with bread riots.
Avoiding bread riots is why every single developed nation on Earth heavily subsidizes its farmers, even when they produce at a loss. The ones that didn't got regime changed by hungry, angry people.
Optimized systems tend to become non-resilient - fragile to external shocks. The last thing I want is a fragile system of food production and distribution.
It's better to pay extra into an inefficient system than deal with famines.
- EdwardDiego 7y agoNZ stopped protecting its farmers and we're a large exporter of food and the 3rd most obese nation - all those damn famines huh?
- vkou 7y ago1. NZ has 3 times more arable land/person than, say, the United States. It could probably use the same farming methods as China did in the famine of Great Leap Forward, and still have enough food to go around. 2. Driving without a seatbelt, or car insurance works, until it doesn't. 3. You'd probably be producing even more food/person, and be more resilient to market failure/drought/crop failures/etc were it subsidized.
- EdwardDiego 7y ago3. Nope. We were producing less food when our farmers were subsidized. 1. According to my googling, the USA has 0.38 hectares of arable land per person, NZ has 0.14 per person. You're aware only 2% of our land is arable compared to the USA's 16% right? Lots of mountains and hill country here.
- pm90 7y agoNZ is nowhere near the size of the US though. If you face a famine in NZ, you import from Australia, China, India etc. If you have a famine in US... millions of people will be without food, it would be an insanely crazy situation (consider how many firearms are held by ordinary Americans). The modern American life is very strongly predicated on cheap, abundant supply of _some_ kinds of nutrition (unhealthy for most, but still, something that prevents starvation even if it increases the chances of heart disease etc.)
- iamshs 7y agoSo stopping subsidies for corn will impact other crops too? Isn’t nutrition diverse nowadays? Edit: Answered. Corn is used as a cattle feed and hence beef prices will be impacted. It will have a chain reaction pulling down just corn subsidies. Tangent: India used to have famines and import grains until Punjab ushered a green revolution with record wheat and rice harvests in 1960s. My grandma told me how before wheat barley used to be the nutritional source, and I for nostalgia sake asked for a barley dish. Nearly threw up.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Marsymars 7y agoHuh. I like barley quite a lot. Doesn't seem like it really has enough flavour to be offensive enough to induce vomiting though.
- wott 7y agoPerhaps it is not the taste but the shape/size and consistency of the boiled grain. For those who don't know, it looks like Kellogg's Smacks, but more chewy, and it can feel a bit strange to chew or to swallow. I like it as well, nevertheless.
- iamshs 7y agoSorry, should be Bajra. Pearl Millet.
- petre 7y agoFamines are closely correlated with weather and solar output disruption. I pretty much doubt subsidies can counter something like the Dalton minimum.
- Mtinie 7y agoUnderstandable, and in the same vein of why it is so important for the United States to retain industrial manufacturing capacity (i.e. auto and heavy machinery makers) because you never know when you’ll need to rapidly ramp up production. Would there be a benefit if we could support and subsidize commercial farms up to a certain size, and no larger, removing the compulsion for ultra-large, mass-industrialization of our agriculture industries?
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> Would there be a benefit if we could support and subsidize commercial farms up to a certain size, and no larger, removing the compulsion for ultra-large, mass-industrialization of our agriculture industries? I like it a lot. We might add a bit of an incentive for non-monoculture agriculture - different strains of wheat, for example. (There's some of that already, and we don't want all the smaller farms to do that, but some doing it might be a good idea.)
- arkades 7y agoI don’t understand the downvotes. No one wants just-in-time, no-redundancies production of critical-to-life resources. You would be willing to subsidize a healthcare market to ensure hospitals didn’t have the exact supply of antibiotics on hand required “on average.” You wouldn’t want water purification plants to produce a market-optimum amount of water with no room for variation. Why would you want that for your food supply? Don’t get me wrong, there are other issues on hand - lack of diversification, oligopoly, etc. but the fundamental argument of “we subsidize critical resources because people die if there’s a shortage” isn’t a terrible idea.
- twblalock 7y ago> “we subsidize critical resources because people die if there’s a shortage” That's not the argument, though. Government subsidies are intended as welfare programs for farmers. Far more food is currently produced than would ever be needed in the case of a shortage. We could produce a lot less and still be fine.
- nhorob67 7y agoAfter the 2019 corn crop is harvested, the USDA is projecting 51.5 days of excess stocks in the United States
- Retric 7y agoYou can store food for 20 years. Actually having a 3+ year supply of food would cost less and provide more security than current subsidies. Also, 51.5 days of excess stocks is not 51.5 days of food on hand.
- petre 7y agoStorage is already at a premium since the US-China trade war. Not enough storage facilities. Maybe the US should cut from the productiob subsidies and subsidize short term storage?
- deleted 7y ago
- Fjolsvith 7y agoThere won't be bread riots in the US. Too much corn and wheat. We'll just eat cheap for a while.