6 ms·
I don't know why SF is so popular. It smells bad and is always cold. Atlanta, for instance, has way more culture (rap, hip hop, country, hollywood) and diversi
by echelon 7y ago
I don't know why SF is so popular. It smells bad and is always cold.
Atlanta, for instance, has way more culture (rap, hip hop, country, hollywood) and diversity (of race, wealth, background, career, etc). The food scene is phenomenal - I follow people on Instagram to find out where the trendiest midnight pop-ups are. Music is everywhere. Art permeates. It's about as far from a monoculture as you can imagine.
I own a huge home in the city and pay less on my mortgage than people in SF pay for rent. It's a cool hipster place too - 1800s cotton mill with 20 foot ceilings. A couple of my coworkers have fairly large machine shops in their homes. Space is practically unlimited here.
Food is cheap, rent is cheap, but the experience and lifestyle exceeds expectation.
I work for a tech company and make the same wages y'all do.
The only thing that sucks here is transit, but I live on the Beltline and walk/bike everywhere, so it's not so much a problem for me.
I feel like tech needs an exodus from SF. A lot of the money for innovation is just being handed over to landlords.
- pj_mukh 7y agoTech isn’t a constant pie. For Atlanta to grow, SF doesn’t need an exodus. In fact, the destruction of SF’s tech scene will be a giant blow to North America’s tech sector for a generation. The forced de-agglomeration of tech cities is not an experiment China or India are running. If you want Atlanta to grow, pray SF (and New York, and LA and Vancouver and Toronto) fix it’s real-estate problems.
- inflatableDodo 7y ago>Tech isn’t a constant pie. Is that why it makes wierd spirals?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- notyourwork 7y agoSF is popular because the weather is incredible. The bay area has cultural diversity beyond what most cities aside from New York can offer. If you can afford it, SF is a wonderful place but it does have problems big cities with large homeless populations have. When you say "I work for a tech company and make same wages y'all do", I'd be interested in what that number is. edit: To clarify on wages, I'm not trying to have a pissing contest. I'm curious what you consider wages that are same as SF. Frankly, I wouldn't stay here if I didn't make what I make but I also know you won't make the same in most tech companies. I'd leave if compensation was sub $200k.
- SomeOldThrow 7y ago> SF is popular because the weather is incredible. The weather is polarizing, to say the least. Some of us like feeling change, as in through seasons. I fucking hate feeling cold in August. There's about three good weeks of warmth in the year and the rest of the year you need layers.
- scruple 7y agoI grew up in the Midwest and spent half a decade between Texas and Georgia. Some of us are also sick of the hot summer heat. And I say that as someone who lives in the Santa Ana foothills in Orange county (it's regularly flirting with 100 degrees in my backyard during the peak of summer -- at least it's dry).
- joelrunyon 7y ago> but it does have problems big cities with large homeless populations have. NYC and Chicago do not seem to have the vast homeless issues that SF does.
- notyourwork 7y agoThey also have winter and humidity. The Bay Area climate is so average it’s a perfectly place to live outside. Try sleeping on a street in December in New York or Chicago. Similarly San Diego and Seattle have homeless populations.
- phil248 7y agoThe contemporary homeless problem is vast, growing and almost exclusively along the West coast where climate permits year-round outdoor living.
- outworlder 7y ago> SF is popular because the weather is incredible Well.. it's more like the weather is constant. It's always foggy, with random periods where the "marine layer" is not present. However, drive 30 minutes and you can get away from the annoying fog.
- davinic 7y agoYou're also dealing with a hostile state government in the bible belt, and surrounded by far red areas. I'm leaving Missouri and wouldn't consider Georgia for that reason, although I have always enjoyed Atlanta.
- big_chungus 7y agoSo you can't stand to live in a place where many people don't think the way you think, yet you'd probably appreciate a more "diverse" city? You appreciate places like San Francisco because while others may look different, they think the same. That's fine, people are more comfortable around those who agree with them; but quit kidding yourself.
- phil248 7y agoThe comment you are replying to explicitly mentioned a "hostile state government", none of the ax-grindy stuff you're bringing up.
- jdavis703 7y agoThat's an uncharitable interpretation of the OP. It's not that people think different, it's that people are actively discriminated in Atlanta (well it's less an Atlanta problem and more a Georgia problem). For context I write this as an African American living in the Bay Area with family that's based in Atlanta. For example as a Black person I know my vote won't count for much in Georgia, and that the state is actively working to disenfranchise it [0]. I also know that I won't have the ability to plan my family [1]. I know I might get weird looks if I'm in a non-heteronormative relationship [2]. So the problem most people have with "red" states isn't that people love God, love cops and love pickup trucks, it's that these areas actively working to restrict our "blue" freedoms. 0: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/aug/14/stacey-abrams-voter-suppression-campaign-states https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/aug/14/stacey-abram... 1: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/07/us/heartbeat-bill-georgia.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/07/us/heartbeat-bill-georgia... 2: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/20/us/tennessee-internet-ministers-gay-marriages.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/20/us/tennessee-internet-min... (Note, this is about Tennessee, but similar attitudes pervade the South)
- flagfeedingusa1 7y agoBut in atlanta can you march down the street naked and flash your penis at children under the guise of a "parade"? Check-and-mate atlanta!
- baddox 7y agoIt definitely smells bad. For me it's not at all cold: it's very consistently nearly perfect weather for me. To me, Atlanta summers are comically, miserably hot. My favorite thing about SF is that it is rarely hot and it's relatively close to incredible mountains. I'm certainly not here for the nightlife, food scene, or art/creative scene, but more power to those who are.
- JshWright 7y ago> always cold. I realize this is subjective, but... What? I don't think I've ever been there when the high temperature was under 55.
- yks 7y agoThere is an art culture in the Bay Area and not everyone likes hip hop or country culture either.
- munificent 7y agoI agree with you. Atlanta is a really interesting, underrated city. It feels both southern and urban in ways that few other cities do. My impression is also that it has not just a lot of racial diversity, but at all economic levels. I grew up in the South in cities with many black people, but Atlanta was the first place where I got a sense of what it felt like to be around a significant number of middle-class and wealthy black people. Problems with the surrounding culture of the state are real, though. Being in a progressive city in a regressive state sucks, because those state laws still affect you.
- scruple 7y agoWithout trying to be inflammatory, and I truly mean that... One interpretation of what you're saying is that poor blacks are regressive. But, I assume what you really meant is that poor whites are regressive? I've also lived in Georgia, and not in Atlanta, but in Augusta and Macon with a sprinkling of Savannah, as a relatively poor person (average white male) during their early 20s, if you want some context behind what I'm saying...
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoI'm from the south and interpret that comment in a very different way. Poor blacks are much more easily disenfranchised, especially in small towns. Educated people are more likely to be able to have id and get registered to vote, especially if they are a minority.
- munificent 7y ago> One interpretation of what you're saying is that poor blacks are regressive. Sure, but by that same interpretation, ice cream sales cause summer temperatures. I think there is a correlation that politically regressive areas also feature worse poverty rates for minorities. My strong hunch is that the causation goes in the opposite direction of what you imply. Places that care less about civil rights and equality are less likely to work to address the systemic racism that leads to relatively greater poverty for blacks than whites.
- jtmcmc 7y agoI escaped the south 16 years ago and I never want to fucking go back. Further the bay area is home to many unique cultures that are sadly seriously distressed thanks to the housing situation, yet tenaciously persist as best they can.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoHumidity makes life way more miserable than temperature.
- powvans 7y agoAs someone who lives just down the street from you in Grant Park... uh, please shut up. The talking point should be: the heat in Atlanta is terrible, the traffic is terrible, it's miserable here, please don't move here and make it worse. In all seriousness though, I agree with you on all points except the weather. What I fear is that the word gets out even more than it already has and we ruin a good thing. The Beltline is a transformational project and I've been rooting for it since the beginning, but lately, with all the growth, I'm starting to get a little concerned that the infrastructure really isn't in place to handle what's coming.
- siekmanj 7y agoInteresting, lots of people say the exact same things about Portland. I would guess every booming city is facing this dilemma.
- rolltiide 7y agoyes, the locals just blame it on procedurally generated things which are totally hotswappable with the things people in another city blame. "I'm mad at those people with money (but would buy here at market rate if I could afford it)" Marginally fascinating. The irony being that if you get to travel enough to notice this, you are practically already exempt and privileged in some way.
- qes 7y ago> make the same wages y'all do As SF? Are you making, say, over $400K in Atlanta?
- babesh 7y agoSeveral Asian people I know who moved to the Bay Area seemed to be traumatized by the racism they faced growing up in the South. Don't know if it is different now. Parts of SF do smell but most of it and most of the Bay Area don't. Likewise, part of the Bay Area is foggy but I would say 80% of the Bay Area isn't. There is definitely a growing monoculture here. Not sure Atlanta doesn't though. If you look deep enough most places do in at least one aspect. Traffic is bad most places in the Bay Area though. Prices are high for many things beyond housing. I think tech is definitely spreading itself a bit more geographically. Its overall a good thing. The concern is how many of these places have enough tech diversity to be self sustaining. The Bay Area is just much, much deeper technically than these other places.
- oppositelock 7y agoSF is popular because it's the only place near a huge number of jobs on the peninsula that's not a generic bedroom community. If someone dropped you on El Camino Real anywhere between San Jose and San Francisco, you would have a very hard time telling which city you're in. They're all basically the same. (For those who don't know, El Camino is a major street which passes through most city downtown areas, and goes up and down the peninsula). The bay area cities tried to maintain their "suburban" image, and ended up all being the same.