2 ms·
This is one of those cases where I would have guessed this would be the case, but it's nice that somebody else spent their time to verify, since I'm unwilling t
by rossdavidh 7y ago
This is one of those cases where I would have guessed this would be the case, but it's nice that somebody else spent their time to verify, since I'm unwilling to spend my time to do so. Also nice that they shared their experience with the rest of us.
If it worked, it wouldn't be published, or at least not until it stopped working.
- lucb1e 7y ago> Also nice that they shared their experience with the rest of us. Except they didn't share the results with the rest of us. I know you said "experience" not "results", but when disproving papers, the least you can do is write down three sentences about each paper as you go along reproducing them, noting what you are seeing, perhaps with a snapshot (just a zip file or so) of the code. This is calling a whole field nonsense (that everyone expects to be full of nonsense) without giving enough evidence for anyone else to dispute your claims.