4 ms·
It may be off the mark to compare to a Civic, but I've spent some quality time in a Model 3, and the only folks who think it compares favorably to a BMW/Merc/Au
by rootusrootus 7y ago
It may be off the mark to compare to a Civic, but I've spent some quality time in a Model 3, and the only folks who think it compares favorably to a BMW/Merc/Audi are diehard fans.
Is there a single competitor to the Model 3 on the market yet? They should be doing really good with the lack of competition.
- jakubp 7y agoIf Model 3 doesn't have a competitor yet, why is anyone worrying about the potential of the competitor to win through fit and finish? When that competitor comes, what is to stop Tesla from releasing Model 3 Mk II with better design??!?!!?!
- jjeaff 7y agoWhy would it have a competitor from any big makers? To them it's still just a niche market.
- giarc 7y agoWhat cars are they comparing? BMW has i3 and i8, Mercedes doesn't have an electric car yet and Audi has e-tron. The only car you could say is in the same category is the i3 and those are totally different cars.
- rconti 7y agoThe i3 is being discontinued in favor of a CUV thing in 2022: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1114966_todays-bmw-i3-to-evolve-into-lower-tech-higher-volume-2022-bmw-ix1-suv-report https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1114966_todays-bmw-i3-t... Mercedes is debuting Real Soon Like Now (I think it's out in Europe as of.. the past few days?) the EQC electric GLC-looking SUV thing. Jag has the i-Pace, which is still uncommon here in the bay area, though I saw quite a few in Norway. The new Audi e-tron was all over Norway, and I just saw my first 3-4 here in the Bay Area this week. (but they had permanent CA license plates so they must have been out for at least a month or so).
- giarc 7y agoMy point was more to the OPs comment that his friends are comparing Tesla 3 to Audi/Mercedes/BMW. I was pointing out that they don't share vehicles in the same category so a bad comparison.
- detaro 7y ago"electric cars" is not the only category a Tesla might fall in.
- clouddrover 7y ago> Mercedes doesn't have an electric car yet The Mercedes EQC is here now, maybe not in your region yet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTew1D5Tk8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTew1D5Tk8
- zaroth 7y agoThe actual sales numbers of BMW and Audi vs. the Model 3 tell a different story. In the US the BMW 3-series sales fell of a cliff since the Model 3 was announced, and Model 3 Q2 sales in the US are 3,000 shy from beating the BMW 3-Series, Lexus ES, BMW 5-Series, and Mercedes C-Class (those are the #2-#5 in that segment)... combined. [1] - https://cleantechnica.com/2019/08/10/tesla-model-3-outsold-bmw-mercedes-audi-lexus-competitors-in-2nd-quarter-in-usa-by-a-landslide/ https://cleantechnica.com/2019/08/10/tesla-model-3-outsold-b...
- jjeaff 7y agoBut compare BMW ICE sales of similarly priced vehicles to Tesla and it's not even close. BMW and the rest of the big makers have no reason to push electric car sales and increase electric R&D over the more profitable ICE models. Same goes for the dealers. They are the ones stealing sales and they make their money on service. Which will be less with electrics. Right now, if you want the best electric car all other factors be damned, you get a Tesla. But the miniscule amount of sales that Tesla has compared to the large manufacturers indicates that market is still exceedingly small. What incentive does BMW have to compete with Tesla? At the very best, they build an electric that blows the Tesla out of the water and take 100% of Tesla's sales. That amounts to about one month of their current revenue. Perhaps when demand for electrics at that price points really takes off, they will be caught flat footed without a competitive product. But that day is yet to come and the full weight of their R&D apparatus and sales force remains to be seen when it comes to electrics. Same goes for all the other big manufacturers.
- zaroth 7y agoTesla Model 3 outsold BMW 2, 3, 4 and 5 series combined. What BMW that is similarly priced to a Model 3 am I missing? The only BMWs that are still selling well are the SUVs. I think your narrative is 3 years out of date. BMW is dying at the hands of Tesla in the US right now, along with all the other “premium” carmakers. When the Model Y starts shipping, I imagine X3 and X5 sales will likewise be hit quite hard.
- 7y ago
- luckydata 7y agoI spend quality time every single day in a Model 3 and the only people that think there's a sport sedan as good as it is in the market right now are diehard fans of the brands you mentioned. My previous car was a BMW M3 and my Tesla has been a breath of fresh air along any possible imaginabile axis except the ergonomics of the air conditioning system that I'm not fan of.
- jmpman 7y agoEvery time I take someone for their first ride in the Model 3, it’s the AC controls which wow them the most. Living with it is different, but it’s a great selling feature of what you’re selling is “Why hasn’t anyone else done it that way? - this is the future”
- Fins 7y ago...and this is how we end up with people driving through fire trucks. I haven't sat in the 3, but I did drive Model S and also played with the e-Tron's controls while waiting for an oil change (which ids pretty much the only advantage of an electric car I could possibly think of). Controlsd in both are very "neat". As long as you are sitting on a showroom floor. The very thought of actually trying to live with either while driving makes me pine for my very first car, a rusted through Chevy Citation that I paid $300 for. Just because it is a good selling point for a certain subset of population that likes new and shiny and does not mind mowing people over in the process does not make it a good thing.
- jmpman 7y agoI’d prefer a physical knob too, but with adjusting temp controls, I don’t find myself fiddling with it while underway.
- Fins 7y agoThat's certainly a valid approach, but most people (me included) actually want to adjust the climate control while driving, for various reasons. Really, once I was quite happy with a car that had roll-down windows and no a/c, but when we are talking about a premium-priced car in 2019 expectations are somewhat different.