3 ms·
I believe Facebook is overvalued. I cannot provide hard evidence since I cannot look into their finance books, but from what I understand their yearly revenue i
by IgorPartola 16y ago
I believe Facebook is overvalued. I cannot provide hard evidence since I cannot look into their finance books, but from what I understand their yearly revenue is about 4% of their latest valuation. I also do not see how their business model can sustain itself, let alone grow exponentially. Yes, they have a ton of users, but they manage to extract precious little money out of them.
Getting back to my original point: I believe FB is overvalued, but apparently someone out there is willing to buy their shares at these prices. Eventually, it will come to light that while FB is profitable, etc. they are not going to grow much and their stock will plummet. Until then, the FB stock craziness will continue.
- tptacek 16y agoTwo things. First, have you really done the math on how much money Facebook earns for each penny it extracts from end-users? Do you use Facebook today? I do, and I couldn't tell you what they're really making money on. They don't appear to have turned on the money spigot yet. Second: When you cry "bubble", you have to be talking about the market as a whole. It makes less (some, but less) sense to me to talk about there being a "Facebook bubble". With that said: it's not just about how much money Facebook gets; it's also a question of what Facebook does with the money. During the Internet bubble, companies went public and spent the cash on Super Bowl ads with no revenue, or go-for-broke ship-free-hardware-to-all-of-America schemes. But Amazon was also a product of the Internet bubble. Were they a bad investment?
- IgorPartola 16y ago> First, have you really done the math on how much money Facebook earns for each penny it extracts from end-users? Do you use Facebook today? I do, and I couldn't tell you what they're really making money on. They don't appear to have turned on the money spigot yet. No. I was talking about revenue, not profit. From the OP: $50B valuation vs projected $2B revenue this year. No idea what they do with what they get to keep. > When you cry "bubble", you have to be talking about the market as a whole. It makes less (some, but less) sense to me to talk about there being a "Facebook bubble". FB is a private company. The distinction is that it's a huge company that now major players on Wall Street are trying to invest in. These types of dealings could potentially put Goldman in a compromising position with another bailout just over the horizon. Also, could this trigger a bunch of inflated valuations of other companies in this industry?
- tptacek 16y agoYou are the first person I've heard that objects to what Goldman is doing because it might harm Goldman.
- IgorPartola 16y agoI'm not objecting. Most of this is not affecting me at all. Just pointing out that Goldman did not increase FB's fundamental value. It's only trying to set up favorable conditions to offload FB on someone else and make out on the profits. The "someone else" may end up getting burnt. In fact I believe that they will get burnt sooner or later. Or possibly, it may be Goldman, who is then going to ask for a second bailout. In either case, it's not my money.