4 ms·
Quoting "https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/6278613/The-Weight-of-Silence-Reflecting-on-D-I-at-Google.pdf" https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/62
by neilv 7y ago
Quoting "https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/6278613/The-Weight-of-Silence-Reflecting-on-D-I-at-Google.pdf" https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/6278613/The-Weigh... (which I prefer to the vice.com article):
> As I went to pack my bag, I noticed that my co-workers had stopped working long enough to stare at the television screen, which showed thousands of protestors filling the New York City streets just blocks from where we sat. Suddenly, one of my teammates spoke up: "Ugh. This is getting a bit ridiculous," she said. "I'm sorry. Does anyone else think this is ridiculous?"
> My hands stopped zipping up my backpack, and I turned my head far enough to see her in my periphery -- sitting behind me with her head shaking and arms folded in exasperation.
> "These protestors aren't going to solve anything," she said. "Like, what are those people even trying to do? Seriously. What are they trying to do? Make people mad about getting stuck in traffic? Piss people off because they can't get to Grand Central? It's annoying. I just can't stand it."
I think this could be a problem of sensitivity or awareness, rather than heart being in the wrong place.
The person speaking might have felt they were aligned with the goals and intended message of the demonstrators, and was only expressing frustration with what they thought were ineffective or unwarranted methods, but...
I suspect that the speaker wasn't in that moment being sensitive to the anguish and sense of urgency some people might've felt, over brutality and related injustice. The demonstrators might've been crying "pay attention to this", and then a coworker seemed to dismiss that.
It's too bad that the writer of the piece couldn't speak up in the moment. Though they alluded to some of why, and I think I understand.
(I probably wouldn't have spoken up then, either, even with lesser stakes for myself. I learned this from a workplace incident, when I was walking up to a group of (presumably straight) coworkers chatting casually about some gay issue in the news (this was before the first US gay marriage), and one of them, who was normally thoughtful, started riffing glibly on how "it's unnatural". I doubt this struck me as deeply as the writer had been, and I hadn't really felt part of an oppressed group, nor had to fear anything around that -- but I was still shocked in the moment, and speechless, as I felt like my face flushed, and I walked away quickly. In hindsight, they were probably within earshot of another coworker, who I knew to be secretly lesbian or bi, but I don't recall whether that registered in my mind at the time. Elsewhere in life, I try to do what I can, but I couldn't speak up in the moment.)
- will4274 7y agoI'm sorry, I don't understand. What's the problem with what OP's co-worker said. She didn't think the protests were effective or useful. Surely she's entitled to feel that way? Edit: the gist of your post seems to be that expressing political opinions at work is only acceptable if you agree with them. That's obviously nonsense. Either everybody can do politics at work, and you have to accept that some people will disagree with you, or nobody can do politics at work.
- dmamills 7y agoI imagine from his position it's very disheartening to see his coworkers have a strong opinion about the protests, and the horrible injustice that is an unexpected traffic jam. But have nothing to say about the wrongful death of a human being. A human being who was murdered and the murderers saw now consequences.
- manfredo 7y agoRight, and I'm sure there are plenty of anti-abortion activists that genuinely see terminating a pregnancy as murder and are disheartened by the lack of response for what they are was widespread, systemic violence. I have as much sympathy for those people as I do for the author: not much, because regardless of how strong one's convictions are in a given political opinion the fact that one's coworker do not share that opinion does not amount to disparagement, racism, harassment, etc.
- dmamills 7y agoTo be fair, I don't believe anywhere in the author's memo does he accuse anyone of being racist. The only time the term racism appears is in reference to his parents struggles during the civil rights movement. The only time the term racist appears is in reference to the President, in a section where he is suggesting Google it's efforts to provide better mental health support for their employees. The way it came across to me was a individual sharing their anecdotal experience being a minority in a large and very well known company. It was a reflection on how he felt about their experiences. Personally though, in response to your comment. I believe the abortion issue is a bit more nuanced than the police killing an man and facing no repercussions. But I'm not here to change your mind sir, it's cool to have no empathy for your fellow humans.