3 ms·
> The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, which appeared in 1900, is widely recognized to be a parable for the Populist campaign of William Jennings Bryan, who twice ran fo
by thaumasiotes 7y ago
> The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, which appeared in 1900, is widely recognized to be a parable for the Populist campaign of William Jennings Bryan, who twice ran for president on the Free Silver platform – vowing to replace the gold standard with a bimetallic system that would allow the free creation of silver money alongside gold.
This is more "crackpot theory" than "widely recognized".
> the Scarecrow represented the farmers (who didn’t have the brains to avoid the debt trap), the Tin Woodsman [sic] was the industrial proletariat (who didn’t have the heart to act in solidarity with the farmers), the Cowardly Lion represented the political class (who didn’t have the courage to intervene)
This, on the other hand, doesn't even meet that standard. If you read the book, the joke about those three characters is very clear -- the Scarecrow is the intelligent one, who solves all the problems the group encounters. The Tin Woodman is the empathetic one, who constantly worries about inadvertently harming anything else. And the Cowardly Lion is the brave one, always volunteering to put himself at risk for the benefit of the group. It's a major theme of the novel that they all already have the things they claim to need.
- Cpoll 7y ago> It's a major theme of the novel that they all already have the things they claim to need. But that still fits the message. They needed to learn that they have what they're looking for. (which isn't to say I have any opinion about whether it's a crackpot theory or not)
- WalterBright 7y ago> the Scarecrow is the intelligent one, who solves all the problems the group encounters. The Tin Woodman is the empathetic one, who constantly worries about inadvertently harming anything else. And the Cowardly Lion is the brave one, always volunteering to put himself at risk for the benefit of the group. I saw that once a year on TV in the 60's, but didn't notice this until much, much later. Heck, I didn't even notice the poppies on the wallpaper on the farm until someone pointed it out to me. (Hangs head in shame)
- anti-cognitive 7y agoIt's funny to me how you seem to grasp at arguing with such a soft fluffy denial. I mean this is less contradiction or refutation and more sulking and pouting about ideas you don't like. First, you just ad hominem with a blundering crackpot label. Then you try to dismiss detailed insights with completely compatible interpretations of the subject matter. It's like you didn't even notice that your perspective and opinion of the symbolism and characterization can interoperate and simultaneously work alongside the version you replied to. They aren't mutually exclusive. But for whatever reason, you've got this smug derision woven into your comment, like you've handily picked apart the ideas you saw fit to quote. It's very obvious that The Wizard of Oz fits an allegory for the dust bowl and great depression. All the pieces easily snap together when you recognize them for what they are. You seem to harbor some deep resentment of a truth that terrifies you. But why?